3 ms·
> If you don't get why someone might think special education is overfunded, go visit a special ed classroom and wonder "how much does it cost society to give th
by dahart 9y ago
> If you don't get why someone might think special education is overfunded, go visit a special ed classroom and wonder "how much does it cost society to give these kids places to drool on each other?".
Man, I hope some day, maybe when you have kids, you come to realize what a truly awful thing to say that was. In the mean time, it might be worth reading a bit of history to understand why our country has repeatedly re-affirmed it's decision to uphold the values in the Declaration of Independence to spend money to take care of all it's citizens and not just the lucky healthiest smartest richest ones.
> Your needling for sources is derailing this discussion.
I can totally empathize with feeling like you're being needled, as you say, when you're asked multiple times for evidence to support your claims that you don't have. I will stop asking. Is it possible that the lack of evidence says more about the value of those claims?
This discussion was derailed right from the start when you decided to pin the country's economic problems on difficult children and parents with questions -- things that objectively don't affect the overall budget very much, if at all. I've just been trying to figure out where your anger is coming from, what makes you think that some parents talking to teachers is some kind of drain on the economy, what you think makes it a serious problem that needs solving.
The irony here is 1) you jumped on me over a comment about education that I didn't make, the parent comment did, and 2) your entire calculus of fixation on short-term budget efficiencies is obsolete under UBI & other future possibilities. Using ROI for education is at best specious today. Should UBI come to pass, ROI will not be a meaningful metric at all.
- alexanderstears 9y ago>Man, I hope some day, maybe when you have kids, you come to realize what a truly awful thing to say that was. In the mean time, it might be worth reading a bit of history to understand why our country has repeatedly re-affirmed it's decision to uphold the values in the Declaration of Independence to spend money to take care of all it's citizens and not just the lucky healthiest smartest richest ones. HA! We got ourselves a liberal here. The world is revolting against your slave morality ideals. The authoritarian left and the authoritarian right are rising - neither of which are ideologies that affirm the rights of all American citizens. >Is it possible that the lack of evidence says more about the value of those claims? It's possible but not likely. I don't think the pencil necks would give anyone a lot of money to study the outcomes of the profoundly retarded. And cost-benefit will not be resolved in their favor unless we say that it's worth a sizable amount of money for parents to play dress up with their retard babies. It's funny to see a retard dressed like an elf, but it's not funny when I think about the resources we've wasted on that mouth breather.
- sctb 9y agoThis comment is so deeply uncivil that we've banned the account. If you email us hn@ycombinator.com and we believe you'll never do anything like this again we can unban you. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html