6 ms·
We are witnessing cultural norms shift right before our eyes. The line went past a lot of powerful people in the shift and now they're scurrying like roaches.
by jandrese 9y ago
We are witnessing cultural norms shift right before our eyes. The line went past a lot of powerful people in the shift and now they're scurrying like roaches. In the old days this was borderline behavior, but not something that would typically get them in trouble. A little butt slap here or innuendo laced comment there was tolerated and sometimes even expected, but those days suddenly ended when even the powerful and influential Harvey Weinstein could fall. One can argue that it might even be blowback from the election of a man who boasted on camera about showing dominance through sexual assault.
I'm actually excited about what the housecleaning of the old guard means for the future. Many of the men implicated in these cases should have retired years ago to give the fresh faces some breathing room. The message is coming out loud and clear now: If you sexually harassed your coworkers/secretary/etc... back in the 60s or 70s as was the custom your day of reckoning is coming. Get out now before the scandal hits.
- Alex3917 9y ago> We are witnessing cultural norms shift right before our eyes. I wonder how long until we see folks like Mick Jagger getting forced to resign their jobs due to using their status as rockstars to pick up women. Especially since most rockstars are also producers or executive producers, i.e. the same job that Harvey Weinstein or VCs have.
- dragonwriter 9y agoThere's a critical difference between using your status as a public celebrity to pick up partners (which is fairly noncontroversial) and using your power as someone who can open and shut career doors to pressure people to accede to or keep quiet about your sexual advances. Someone like Jagger or Weinstein may have both kinds of status, but there is still a difference.
- CydeWeys 9y agoYou're eliding the critical issue of consent. There are plenty of people who want to have sex with rockstars. There's no issue with that.
- Alex3917 9y ago> You're eliding the critical issue of consent. There are plenty of types of relationships that are consensual, but that are still either illegal or else forbidden by the ethics standards for various industries. Just because something is widely accepted today, doesn't mean that it will be acceptable in the future as long as there is consent. Ethical standards are shaped by the conflict between the world as it exists currently and the type of society we'd like to have. They're not immutable, nor are they guaranteed to move in any particular direction. E.g. if the human population outstrips the supply of cheap natural resources, liberal western values may go out the window very quickly around the world, just like they did in Iran.
- jandrese 9y agoAs far as I know the only person in the current wave of scandals who is being raked over the coals for consensual behavior is Bill Clinton. Every single other case involved men forcing themselves on women sexually.
- CydeWeys 9y agoSo are you making some kind of slippery slope argument then? The common thread with all of the housecleaning that's currently going on is that it's been harassment/assault/rape, i.e. non-consensual. I don't really understand what you're worried about? Is your argument that by allowing people to face punishment for non-consensual sexual behavior (i.e. harassment/assault/rape), we're opening the door in the future for people to be punished for consensual sexual behavior? History has also been going the opposite direction of what you're claiming anyway. Promiscuous consensual sexual behavior was much more heavily penalized in the past than in the present. It's going the other way. Many people were calling for rock music to be banned back in the day because of this kind of behavior they said that it idolized. Now, if anything, it's celebrated.
- alexasmyths 9y ago"A little butt slap here or innuendo laced comment there was tolerated and sometimes even expected, but those days suddenly ended when even the powerful and influential Harvey Weinstein could fall." That's the thing - 'what is it'? A 'slap on the butt' is point blank harassment and never really accepted in any culture. You could 'get away with it' but it was not ever considered perfectly ok. 'Sexual innuendo' - that is normal in many places in the world, 'Commenting on a woman's appearance' is a positive trait in many places in the world. 'Showing up at your door in a bathrobe' - is not unethical behaviour. There has to be a lot added onto that to make it inappropriate. And there are huge levels of inappropriate. What if you are out drinking with a co-worker, then back at your place drinking, you're both flirting - and then you go in for the kiss? A sales lady jumped in the pool naked at a hotel where we were staying. Nobody cared, we were drinking, it was funny. But if it's a dude - it's wrong? Putting drugs in a girls drink and then raping her ... well that's beyond immoral and very illegal. The problem I think - is that a lot of this stuff is getting lumped together. A lot of this behaviour is really only 'no acceptable' wherein there are very high bars for behaviour. You don't put your hand on a woman's knee at the office. You can put your hand on a woman's knee if you're out on a date with her. What if you are co-workers? What if one works for the other. ... This is all complex and nuanced stuff, I don't think we can just lump it all together. FYI - it was 'progressives' in the 1960's pushing for sexual liberation - and 'consent' is in the vast majority of even positive cases, not exactly given verbally. So there is a 'new set of norms' but a lot of it is based in fear. Have you seen the 3 second video of Gigi Hadid who received a 'buddha doll' (possibly not buddha, just a fat man), it's really cute. She makes a face, puts the doll next to her, and smiles like the doll. It's just fun, I don't think racist at all - and yet the Chinese government got involved. The smallest mis-step - one person - in one place - can say something - and it blows up. The 'new order' will not be a 'moral order' - it will be a 'sanitized order' - wherein every word - every action - every thought - will be scrutinized so intensely that I'm weary we're giving up a lot for this. So yes - the 'new norm' of 'don't harass your interns and grab their asses' is really good - but I fear it won't just create a 'safe place' for people, it may ultimately create a hostile place where we can't just be human. I stayed at a friends house in SF recently, she came out of the kitchen naked, and went into her bedroom - just as I was falling asleep on the couch. She was giggling. She was not flirting with me - just kidding. And I laughed because it was funny. We work in the same industry. Should I charge her with sexual assault? Anyhow - it's complicated. A few steps forward a few steps back.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Firebrand 9y agoSo many stories are going to come out over the next few weeks that it will get to a point where none of it sticks. If everyone's a pervert, then nobody is. (And that will be how Roy Moore wins.)
- dragonwriter 9y agoNo, Roy Moore will win (if he does) because of political tribalism; to the extent the flood of accusations against others is relevant, the “lots of allegations but who could know the underlying reality” thing will be part of how people voting for Moore rationalize their vote more than a key factor in the actual decision.
- aaron-lebo 9y agoBut lots of people aren't... and to your parent comment, this isn't limited to older men.
- jansho 9y agoUnfortunately we’re already starting to see this.
- rayiner 9y agoCharlie Rose was fired, so it's clearly still sticking. And the fact Roy Moore might win doesn't matter so much. At this point he's literally running on "would you rather elect a pedophile or an abortionist?" That might fly in Alabama. Is it going to fly in board rooms in New York or San Francisco? That's the more relevant question to your typical HN reader.
- Firebrand 9y ago>Is it going to fly in board rooms in New York or San Francisco? Yes, because it was clearly known internally at CBS and PBS for years before becoming public. And yet Charlie Rose only gets fired--near instantly--after the Washington Post publishes a piece about him.
- 9y ago
- ryandrake 9y agoMakes me wonder where the next "shift" will be. A lot of things that are unambiguously bad today were not yesterday, and there is no guarantee that something you do today will not be seen as taboo tomorrow. I've had conversations at work in the distant past that I'd probably get fired over today. What about 20 years from now? I've recently mentioned in co-worker chit chat that I like to go the the range every now and again to shoot clays and targets. How do I know at some point in the future I won't be forced to resign for a "history of discussing weapons in the workplace," after those cultural norms shift again?
- icebraining 9y agoMaybe it's because I'm not in the US, but I find this concern overblown. For the most part, we're not talking about perfectly innocent things suddenly shifting into unacceptable. We're talking about behavior that was merely tolerated from people in positions of power. And 20 years ago most of these were probably already covered in sexual harassment advisories. As far as I'm concerned, the change took too long, not the other way. Who do you see having been fired for stuff done 20 years ago and that was completely acceptable back then?