4 ms·
> I'm not sure what most of the anti-net neutrality side's supporting arguments are My friend was a lawyer for an ISP and now works for the FCC (I promise she'
by jedberg 9y ago
> I'm not sure what most of the anti-net neutrality side's supporting arguments are
My friend was a lawyer for an ISP and now works for the FCC (I promise she's a good person otherwise).
The main argument is that small ISPs can't compete if Net Neutrality exists, because they can't build a network big enough for every customer to stream Netflix and YouTube. If they could have most of their customers blocked from those services, they could afford to offer it to the few that want to pay extra for it.
The other main argument against it is that it's not fair that Grandma, who only wants to read email once a day and look at the kids on Facebook, pays the same as the kid next door who is watching Netflix while playing an RTS while torrenting three movies.
They're both decent arguments, and would totally make sense in a world where multiple ISPs could reach everyone's home.
- jimktrains2 9y ago> The main argument is that small ISPs can't compete if Net Neutrality exists, because they can't build a network big enough for every customer to stream Netflix and YouTube. If they could have most of their customers blocked from those services, they could afford to offer it to the few that want to pay extra for it. I find it hard to believe that the electrical grid, water, sewer, and natural gas systems all are able to make due but the poor ISPs rolling in cash can't. Meanwhile, these same ISPs are working to make competition illegal or impossible. This isn't an issue of providing better service. This is an issue of making more money by squeezing the customer every way they can while making recourse impossible.
- ryall 9y agoI wouldn't call either of these "decent arguments" for forsaking net neutrality. They can both be solved by offering tiered pricing and data caps. For instance, grandma pays $10 a month for a Gb of data, Netflix Youtube kid pays $100 for unlimited. Same goes for small startup ISP.
- jacques_chester 9y ago> The main argument is that small ISPs can't compete if Net Neutrality exists, because they can't build a network big enough for every customer to stream Netflix and YouTube. If they could have most of their customers blocked from those services, they could afford to offer it to the few that want to pay extra for it. Hypotheticals can be checked by referring to other countries with different market structures. Australia has a broader mix of ISPs and Telcos than the US, despite until the 90s being under the control of a single public system (Telecom), with a plurality of the current infrastructure owned by its privatised successor (Telstra). They seem to do fine with net neutrality. Regular competition. > The other main argument against it is that it's not fair that Grandma, who only wants to read email once a day and look at the kids on Facebook, pays the same as the kid next door who is watching Netflix while playing an RTS while torrenting three movies. Charging by bandwidth and usage is well settled. The point is that the ISPs don't want to segment the consumer market. Too hard: there's competition, which as we know is unamerican because it makes business haaaard. Instead they want to segment the provider market. Far fewer of them to negotiate and there's zero competition. You, the ISP, have at any point in time monopoly control over the consumer who is using your infrastructure. Providers have no other way to route traffic over the last mile. Nobody mounts this kind of lobbying effort from the goodness of their hearts. They see a gigabuck in it.
- gech 9y ago>The main argument is that small ISPs can't compete if Net Neutrality exists, because they can't build a network big enough for every customer to stream Netflix and YouTube. If they could have most of their customers blocked from those services, they could afford to offer it to the few that want to pay extra for it. What? This logic is like saying, hey the only business model that should exist is one where we should only cater to those that pay the most (whether through ignorance or lack of options, etc). >The other main argument against it is that it's not fair that Grandma, who only wants to read email once a day and look at the kids on Facebook, pays the same as the kid next door who is watching Netflix while playing an RTS while torrenting three movies. It's not fair that grandma is going to be even more duped by the limited offerings of news and media that these companies will tighten their grip on through this move. Also the pipe is just sitting there. It's not like Comcast is manufacturing electrons and packets that get consumed by users. Ask your friend to study other countries internet situations.
- wanderer2323 9y ago'We cannot build a big enough network for Netflix' is nowhere near a top reason people cannot start an ISP. Data caps and plans with different bandwidth is a working answer to the second problem. Are you sure your friend is a good person? She sounds like a typical sellout hypocrite if that's her arguments.