The old logo may be cheesy looking, but in this situation, it's a hundred times better than the crappy generic one, and it is strong enough to balance the awful

The old logo may be cheesy looking, but in this situation, it's a hundred times better than the crappy generic one, and it is strong enough to balance the awful text set to its right. With the generic logo, the ugly text dominates. If the text was fixed up, perhaps the generic logo might stand a chance, but with the shown pages, it's way too weak. When I did my app site at femcalapp.com, I cribbed the basic design from something else, but I've worked steadily to refine it, albeit without any metrics, just my own metric of does it look better or not.