4 ms·
> The internet was born and thrived w/o explicit net neutrality laws for a long time (~20+ years). On the other hand, while the internet is approaching its 50t
by acdha 9y ago
> The internet was born and thrived w/o explicit net neutrality laws for a long time (~20+ years).
On the other hand, while the internet is approaching its 50th birthday for most of that time there was far less money involved and fewer players with monopoly status over it.
In the 90s, we had dialup and DSL from hundreds of service providers because DSL was subject to a similar neutrality provision which meant that the phone company had to resell access to copper at cost. That's a pretty huge difference: had, say, PacBell tried to steer pets.com traffic to a partner, every single one of their customers had the option to switch ISPs immediately without any loss of service quality.
Unfortunately that wasn't preserved for fiber and there has been massive consolidation in the industry, so most people have a choice between — if they're lucky — a massive cable company and a massive phone company. Many people live in buildings with exclusive contracts for only one company. In that environment, your choices are basically falling back to DSL if it's still available (increasingly not) or going without an increasingly vital utility.
I would be very hesitant to say our past experience is a good source of prediction for the modern market.