3 ms·
> This would be a boon to any ISP who DIDN'T do this. Competition, and obvious lack of business sense, has always been a far larger counter-balance to this idea
by shmerl 9y ago
> This would be a boon to any ISP who DIDN'T do this. Competition, and obvious lack of business sense, has always been a far larger counter-balance to this idea.
Competition surely can help, but currently there is no competition in a lot of places. It's basically monopoly / oligopoly situation, with collusion and market division to boot. So increasing competition is a good goal, but it shouldn't block preventing monopolistic abuse with legal means.
Monopolists also created a lot of blockers that prevent increasing competition. Such as local state laws that ban municipal networks which could solve this very problem.
- webXL 9y ago> Competition surely can help, but currently there is no competition in a lot of places. Places with a lot of people? People who have been harmed by what NN is intending to fix? > Monopolists also created a lot of blockers that prevent increasing competition. Facilitated by government. If government was responsible in the first place, why not just undo what they did?
- shmerl 9y ago> Places with a lot of people? It doesn't depend on numbers. Depends mostly whether there is some other ISPs besides the coax provider (which are the most widespread).
- webXL 9y agoSo we should have a one-size-fits-all law? You're not that unimaginative, are you?
- khedoros1 9y ago> Places with a lot of people? People who have been harmed by what NN is intending to fix? Yes and yes. I've lived all over southern California, but never anywhere that had two broadband providers available at the same address. Parts in cities; I'm not talking about little desert communities, or something. I have however been inconvenienced by various ISPs' content-based packet filtering policies. > Facilitated by government. If government was responsible in the first place, why not just undo what they did? Part of it is that you're talking about every individual local government, with lobbying from the incumbent ISPs. A lot of those governments have contracts with those incumbents, giving them franchise rights in the city. They can't just declare those contracts void. Beyond the local level, a lot of states have laws that make setting up a new ISP difficult or impossible (especially municipally-operated internet access).
- s73ver_ 9y agoI live in Orange County, CA. I have access to literally one provider.
- webXL 9y agoWhat city? Provider of what?
- s73ver_ 9y agoI've lived in 3, and in all of them, there was exactly one cable/internet provider.
- webXL 9y agoWhen was that? Seems to be not much of a problem anymore if this is correct: https://broadbandnow.com/California/Orange https://broadbandnow.com/California/Orange
- s73ver_ 9y agoIt's now. And that site is extremely misleading, because while all those companies are in the county, they don't serve the same areas. And as long as 1 person in the census block has access to the service, it's counted as serving the entire block.