5 ms·
> The idea that we've solved all that needs to be done is remarkable. Yeah, true. The last time society worried that new technology and machines would lead to
by dahart 9y ago
> The idea that we've solved all that needs to be done is remarkable.
Yeah, true. The last time society worried that new technology and machines would lead to mass unemployment, the opposite happened. We're in a bigger hurry than ever. Maybe that will accelerate even more.
But, if the human labor need for the trucking industry goes away, for example, it doesn't matter whether we've solved all problems, we will have a very large class of people out of work, even if it's temporary.
> Pay people for education first. We aren't even doing this!! Pay people to resolve climate change. Pay for more research. Pay for xyz that drives humans to new levels while enabling them to valuably contribute to our society.
I agree with this too, but one way to think about UBI is that it could, for the first time, pay people for doing things that are valuable to society, but not profitable. The reason we don't pay much for education or fixing climate change or research is our economy is driven on short term economics. If it doesn't lead to more customers or more dollars in the next year, it doesn't get funding. At it's imagined best, maybe UBI could enable an economy of social good rather than profit.
- alexanderstears 9y ago>The reason we don't pay much for education or fixing climate change or research is our economy is driven on short term economics. I don't think that's the case at all. 1) How can our economy be driven by 'short term economics' when we have trillions of dollars locked away in 20+ year investments (government bonds)? That's hardly 'short run' thinking. But it illustrates that there are trillions of dollars available for longer term thinking. 2) We do pay a lot for education [0]. We spend something like 9k/student/year. that's a substantial amount of money. But we get bad results, a lot of kids don't live in very good environments and school funding goes towards things their parents should be doing - like teaching them how to read and feeding them breakfast. I think we'd invest more in education if we could demonstrate better returns, but the bleeding hearts in charge of education want to spend more money on the worst investments. Teachers and admins have created a system where education for the intellectually disabled gets funded 30:1 - 100:1 over education for the gifted. People with too many chromosomes aren't going to fix climate change or do the research our economy needs, yet down syndrome students get a lot more funding than genius students. Hilariously, the solution to education funding is more of the 'short term economics'. We should spend less money on educating would-be gangsters and more money education would-be scientists. [0]: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/us-education-spending-tops-global-list-study-shows/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/us-education-spending-tops-glob...
- lovich 9y agoOoh, you might have had a point about spending on education for mentally disabled people far outpacing that for the average student, but adding in the part about having to pay to feed children and "would-be gangsters" makes me think you might have an ulterior motive beyond fixing the education system. I also want to point out that you included teaching to read in you list of things parents should be doing and not the teachers. Because teaching is not something teachers should be doing
- alexanderstears 9y ago>you might have had a point about spending on education for mentally disabled people far outpacing that for the average student, but adding in the part Do you discredit an idea because of the person espousing it? If so, go hang out with normies who read gossip mags. >you might have an ulterior motive beyond fixing the education system. My ulterior motive is a society where the productive people are unleashed to be as great as they can be, and the lazy/incompetent aren't given things at the expense of better investments. >I also want to point out that you included teaching to read in you list of things parents should be doing and not the teachers. Yeah, I want to live in a society with a norm of parents reading to their children and participating in their child's development. The expectation that only teachers are responsible for an individual's education is the reason we can dump so much money into the system and have little to show for it.
- lovich 9y agoYou can just say eugenics. Hiding your argument behind vague terms like "My ulterior motive is a society where the productive people are unleashed to be as great as they can be, and the lazy/incompetent aren't given things at the expense of better investments." when one of the things you mention is food, just makes your argument seem weaker. If you really believe in it back it up
- alexanderstears 9y agoI donate to planned parenthood, I do back it up. I raise the point in internet discussion, I do back it up.