3 ms·
The nuclear industry is best run without competition. See France. The whole energy industry there is like soviet-style centralized economy. This leads to higher
by lispm 16y ago
The nuclear industry is best run without competition. See France. The whole energy industry there is like soviet-style centralized economy. This leads to higher costs and at the same time to low safety. France for example brings a lot of nuclear waste to siberia where it is stored just under the sun, outside.
You would never get real costs out of the nuclear complex in France. It all cleverly hidden. Yet they can't even produce enough energy for their country and deliver it. Last winter the power lines in France we almost collapsing. Heating is done with electricity and the winter was long and cold. The whole structure of energy production is very centralized (and not mesh like). At the same time 20% nuclear reactors were off the grid and Electricity had to be imported.
Even for a conventional energy production it is important to have competition. But the big energy producers are getting monopolies for their regions. In France it is even worse: there is EDF and not much else.
Next, the nuclear reactors are not using their heat in any useful way in France or Germany. They are mostly used to heat up the rivers. Which at the same time limits how many reactors one can put at a river. They need lots of water for cooling.
- lispm 16y agoLet me add the hidden cost of mining. From the Areva wikipedia page: --- Areva has been criticised both in Niger and the west for a neocolonial relationship with the former French colony, having obtained monopoly rights to mine uranium for nearly forty years, while Niger remains (as of 2006) the least developed country in the world.[16] There has been specualtion that Areva was the primary vehicle (and motivation) for French government involvement in the Nigerien government's poor history of democracy and human rights since the late 1960s. Areva argues that it is a good steward of the environment and a partner in development with the Nigerien people. The company stresses that most workers it directly employs in Niger are locals, and that the revenue generated by these mines is the single largest foreign exchange source for Niger.[17] When the population of Niger was exposed to a serious famine in 2005, Areva donated 130,000 euros in June 2005 to the food crisis coordination group of Niger, and 120,000 euros in July in the form of two planes loaded with food and organized by Bernard Kouchner's Réussir NGO. Nigerien critics point out that this aid amounted to 0.05% of Areva's annual profits of 428 million euros.[18]. In January 2008, a Swiss human rights group awarded Areva's Niger operations their "2008 Public Eye Global Award" for the "worst company in the world", citing charges of radioactive pollution, poor working conditions, and the deaths of a number of workers.[19] The Tuareg based rebel group fighting in the Arlit area has echoed these charges. ---
- confuzatron 16y agoPeople in the developing world suffer from injustices, but it's silly to argue that this is a hidden cost of Nuclear. If the reserves were in a developed country they would be mined as cheaply and more safely. And don't forget 'the hidden cost of PV' - massive pollution in China, bad working conditions, damage to workers' health.
- sedachv 16y ago"People in the developing world suffer from injustices, but it's silly to argue that this is a hidden cost of Nuclear." Right, just as Superfund cleanup and cancer treatment is free to the US taxpayer. "If the reserves were in a developed country they would be mined as cheaply and more safely." What prevents Areva from doing that in Niger?