4 ms·
> the Australian court will say that the US court has no jurisdiction in Australia One would hope that'd be a given and go without saying. > The Australian co
by JoshTriplett 9y ago
> the Australian court will say that the US court has no jurisdiction in Australia
One would hope that'd be a given and go without saying.
> The Australian court could conceivably force the EFF to change how its site is shown to people in Australia
Not without jurisdiction over the EFF they can't.
> Then after realizing that people in Australia can still access the US version of the EFF's site, force the EFF to change its site in all countries.
Not without jurisdiction over the EFF they can't.
- bartart 9y agoIt just seems like the US court decided that the Australian court had no jurisdiction over the EFF. But does the Australian court agree with the US court's ruling? It may or it may not. Evidently the Australian court at one point believed it had jurisdiction because it took up the case in the first place and issued a ruling. To me just as an observer it seems that the Australian court gets to decide what is under its jurisdiction.
- benchaney 9y ago> it seems that the Australian court gets to decide what is under its jurisdiction. Nope
- int_19h 9y agoTo have jurisdiction over something, you need to have enforcement power there. The Australian court can make any claims they like, fine EFF, even charge its officers with contempt of court - but I don't see how this could possibly be enforced.