6 ms·
iRobot is testing software to make sense of all the rooms in a house
- dovik 9y agoHN's readers, how do you deal with your connected devices? Do they use the same network as you? Or have you a dedicated network to them? Or an on-demand dedicated network (connection only when necessary/allowed)?
- frik 9y agoIt might be unpopular on HN, but use the older iRobot generation that is not "smart" aka no WiFi, no spyware, just a "dump" little robot vacuum cleaner. Do you think Mark Zuckerberg, or Elon Musk let such devices roam their home? Nope. Mark wrote his own home assistant, security system ,etc with PHP and unix tools. These devices are for the noobs, the general public, that doesn't care.
- visarga 9y agodump -> dumb
- StavrosK 9y agoI have four Wifi networks: One for me/trusted computers, one for untrusted devices without internet access, one with, and one for guests. My network can access everything else, the untrusted networks can only initiate connections to my home server on the firmware upgrade port (which is used by devices around the house that I've made and which often look for OTA updates on my server), and the guest network can only access the internet.
- e40 9y agoI would love to hear/see more details on how you set this up. It's something I'd like to do, but I'm not sure where to start (hw, sw, etc).
- StavrosK 9y agoThe wifi? I just got a Tomato-compatible router, there's a section in Tomato where you specify the networks you want. The connections are a few iptables rules, I could write a post at some point. EDIT: Turns out I don't remember which settings were set by me and which ones the router added by itself. If you have a Tomato router and would like to help me replicate the setup so I can write the post, send me an email (email in profile)!
- FidelCashflow 9y agoMore details please. This is a glaring security hole in my home that I'd like to address.
- StavrosK 9y agoI've set up virtual networks in Tomato and multiple Wifi access points, and bound each access point to each network. Then, with iptables rules I've allowed/disallowed connections from/to each. I can write it up if someone helps me reproduce it.
- acdha 9y agoI use Google WiFi with a primary and guest network. Anything which doesn't get security updates goes on the guest network so negligence on the part of Lenovo, Toshiba, etc. doesn't offer an easy jumping-off point to attack the devices with data I care about.
- rullelito 9y agoVery cool. I got a Neato Robotics years ago and it was very good at doing its cleaning room by room, going through each room very methodically. I think it used SLAM.
- jgrahamc 9y agoI owned a Roomba for a while. It did an OK job of cleaning the kitchen floor but was noisy, slow and didn't do a good job of corners, or under cabinets that stick out a little, etc. But worse I had to carry the thing from room to room because, of course, it can't climb stairs nor will it vacuum them. And in any room with wood floors and rugs it got stuck repeatedly. The most labour intensive part of vacuuming my house is the stairs; Roomba 'solved' the easy part.
- visarga 9y agoYou're doing it wrong. You need a house with no carpets, all furniture at a clearance of min 15cm, no stairs, and to make sure there are no USB cables on the floor or thin slippers which might get "stolen" by the bot. Then it can do its magic unattended. I observed that running the robot daily gets much better results than my best attempt at vacuuming. It's just more attentive to detail and goes methodically without missing a spot.
- hawski 9y agoWhen I was lately buying furniture I had this in mind. However now I have a crawling baby with lots of toys and now it's not as relevant.
- visarga 9y agoI too am expecting a baby soon and bought the robovac with the intention to run it daily in his room (now I realize that I want it for the whole house, because it's so good). It's true that little toys get stuck in, but that's the same with traditional vacuuming as well - you still need to pick up the toys before vacuumig.
- visarga 9y agoI have a Xiaomi Mi robot vacuum and it is capable of mapping the whole house and showing me on the phone where it is and what was the cleaning trajectory. It's quite smart, it understands room layout, and can handle many rooms without attendance. Example of house map: https://www.androidcentral.com/sites/androidcentral.com/files/styles/medium/public/article_images/2016/10/mi-robot-layout.png https://www.androidcentral.com/sites/androidcentral.com/file...
- StavrosK 9y agoI only wish I could tap the map and have it go there. I keep having to operate it using the phone controls, and the signal goes to the US and back even though the damn vacuum is right next to me. This leads to > 1 sec response times, which make it impossible to steer.
- visarga 9y agoI agree, pointing to a location, or even selecting a rectangle on the map should work.
- StavrosK 9y agoYes, especially given the fact that it already does the exact same thing when you tell it to go back to the dock (ie it finds a way to a spot on the map, its dock).
- jsight 9y agoSome of the Samsung robot vacuums can do this: http://support-us.samsung.com/cyber/popup/iframe/pop_troubleshooting_fr.jsp?idx=665321&modelname=&modelcode=VR2AK9350WK%2FAA&session_id=&from_osc= http://support-us.samsung.com/cyber/popup/iframe/pop_trouble...
- netsharc 9y agoAnd if they pull a Logitech (https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2017/11/logitech-to-shut-down-service-and-support-for-harmony-link-devices-in-2018/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2017/11/logitech-to-shut-dow...) I guess you'd have at least a tiny spot on the floor which will be very clean. If you could reverse engineer it I would fake the control server (e.g. have a router that will spoof DNS) and have the spoof server be in your network. I wonder if the server does anything more intelligent than relay the messages from your phone, or if it has SSL... Hah, man-in-the-middle for a vacuum cleaner. Welcome to the future.
- uptown 9y agoAnybody here have any experience with the Dyson 360 robot vacuum? It's pricy but claims to address some of the limitations of the Roomba regarding range and multi-room coverage. However the reviews on Amazon are less than stellar.
- chisleu 9y agoThey need to work on hardware that can actually connect to the app. 3 different Android phones and 3 different Braava Jet robots and none would connect to the software. Their support gave up. App rating is almost 3 starts now with tons of reports that it won't connect. I only mention it because they get such good press, but no one is reporting on all the disappointed customers.
- stinky613 9y agoI think I vaguely recall some confusion when I first set up my Roomba 960 with my Android phone, but once I got it going it hasn't had any issues since.
- SurrealSoul 9y agoI feel like iRobot needs to work on it's software to justify it's hefty price tag. My roomba just drunkenly roams around the house cleaning up things, but its just a matter of random luck if it gets full coverage in 1 hour, or 3 hours. Still beats manually vacuuming though
- chrisgd 9y agoIt beats manual, but I agree, it seems so much of the battery use could be better served. I would think there would be a robot where you attach a stick to it and walk it through the path you would take to vacuum the room. Then you can save paths and the robot will just run through each path as saved.
- moe 9y agoSmarter robots have existed for a long time (e.g. the Neato or the high-end Roomba model). They create a map of your place and then clean it systematically instead of randomly like the cheaper Roombas. This is obviously much faster, but also less thorough (lower number of passes over any given spot) and less robust (navigation easily gets confused by sunlight, dirty sensors, room changes, etc.).
- vinay427 9y ago> less thorough (lower number of passes over any given spot) If the device is smart enough, thoroughness can be a choice so the user can opt for multiple systematic passes instead of being required to wait through multiple random uneven passes. > less robust (navigation easily gets confused by sunlight, dirty sensors, room changes, etc.) This implies that robot vacuums that are sufficiently intelligent don't exist yet.
- dominotw 9y ago>Still beats manually vacuuming though For me main cost of vacuuming is prep work not the actual task of vaccuming. Picking up cat toy string, feather toys, kids legos, random one of things. The actual act of vacuuming is fairly simple and enjoyable. So I don't get how roomba is useful. Doesn't your roomba choke on charger wires, toys, hair ect ? I have a neato that I don't use for these reasons.
- spdustin 9y agoThey just need to add in a shit sensor. Big messes are made when Roomba runs over Fido's "accident" when the owner's not home.