10 ms·
As Silicon Valley Gets ‘Crazy,’ Midwest Beckons Tech Investors
- ryanx435 9y agoI made the decision a few years ago to never work in silicon valley or california. it costs WAY to much to live there and the social/political landscape gives off the impression of being some kind of authoritarian dystopia falsely touting itself as some kind of social utopia. not really interested in all that noise.
- cgore 9y agoIt's mostly the political atmosphere for me.
- conanbatt 9y agoI assure you that the main reason california doesnt get twice its population is because of the highly regulated real estate controls. You could build 500,000 units in one year and you would barely make a dent to the states rental rates, let alone bring them down to more reasonable levels.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- aantix 9y agoThat's too bad. Do you love to program? I don't think people quite get how engineering centric SF/The Valley is. There is a meetup for everything and every third person you run into is an engineer. It's truly a programmers paradise. And no where else do you have the salary leverage that you do in SV. If you have an amazing background with a couple of niche languages, and the right startup comes along that needs engineers with your skillset yesterday, you can manage a homerun salary deal. The engineer is king in SF. I lived there for five years. And will never regret that time. P.S. You can still manage good deals on housing in less trendy areas. Hire a professional relocation assistant. Monica McGee does freelance and corporate relocation. Money well spent and she helped my wife and I land a great deals on a couple of locations.
- jordanb 9y agoI love to program and I go to lots of meetups here in Chicago, but I also have a lot of friends who are not techies and I have conversations with people all the time that don't revolve around apps or frameworks.
- ryanx435 9y agothis sounds terrible. "hire someone to find you a place that you can afford because there are no affordable places" "if you luckily have the specific skill some random startup wants, you can make a "homerun salary deal", which you will need because living expenses are terrible, otherwise you are shit out of luck"
- danschumann 9y agoI'm deeply involved in the "beckoning" portion this article mentions. I volunteered at a conference in Green Bay, Wisconsin hosting Steve Case on his 'Rise of the Rest' tour. It's truly needed. We're consistently ranked top for small businesses (by %), but lowest for startups. Lots of people have little lawn and snow care businesses, but people move away if they want to start something larger. I think the key is to build a solid community, even if very small. The city should pick a block and try to put as many tech companies there as possible, giving them incentives. The higher density, the more tech culture can catch on. Mostly people need good examples of people who have made it or are making it. It's definitely catching on.
- pm90 9y agoThere are so many great universities in the Midwest graduating tons of engineers, so they do have a foot in the door already. Most leave for the coasts, even if they do fall in love with the area (I did).
- ben_jones 9y agoThey shoot that foot off though. Companies in those regions optimize for hiring cheap and replaceable, such processes will ward off real talent who realize they need to move elsewhere to have a upper middle-class lifestyle. Don't get me wrong though I definitely see the QOL that can be had with smaller incomes in such places and intend to move out of the Bay Area etc. eventually.
- cgore 9y agoThe other thing that's really starting to change things is remote work. There's no reason most developers need to be anywhere as long as they can get high speed internet.
- rm_-rf_slash 9y agoIn my opinion, the problem is less about the founders and early employees as it is about the scaling. It’s a lot easier to convince young college graduates (as older folks will want/need much more compensation when working for a risky startup) to join a company in hip, trendy metro areas than it is to convince them to work in, say, Wisconsin. I suspect that is why companies that intend to scale prefer to move to larger metro areas, even if that means going from a more rural part of a state to a bigger city like Madison. That being said, I have noticed quite a few specialist technical/consulting firms popping up all over my native Upstate New York. Those firms don’t need the armies of employees the way a Google or an Uber does, so I think that they can offer a higher pay to cost of living ratio and attract strong talent, kind of like Tom Cruise in The Firm, accepting a lower salary to work in Memphis but taking home more net income than if he had gone to New York.
- pmoriarty 9y ago"In Ohio, that $35 million is the equivalent of $70 million in the Valley in terms of being able to hire talent and sustain operating costs" Low salaries are an incentive for companies to move to Ohio, but are a disincentive for employees to move there.
- kinos 9y agoSpeaking as someone who recently got hired in Ohio? The relative rate of pay vs cost of living is amazing compared to somewhere like California or Florida. My pocket income is so far better than anything I ever got in Florida.
- adjkant 9y agoSpeaking as someone from FL who has worked in CA, Florida should not be lumped together with CA. The COL to tech pay ratio is the key metric here, which I suspect is much better in CA than FL if you are talking Tampa/Miami type areas.
- cgore 9y agoThe cost of living is a lot lower too though. I'm in Saint Louis, I have a 15-minute commute to work from a neighborhood where 2x my salary gets a 3,000-sqft+ McMansion with a big yard in a good school district.
- jonathankoren 9y agoWhere in STL, and what do you do?
- cgore 9y agoI write Clojure mostly (also Python when I'm unlucky.) I'm working in Creve Coeur.
- kendallpark 9y agoSt. Louis is the best kept secret of the Midwest. People have all sorts of weird ideas about what St. Louis is like based on this or that news story. Or maybe they've visited once, but I don't imagine it's an amazing tourist destination. It was great growing up there. It still catches me off guard when I have to pay admission to walk into another city's zoo/art museum/science center.
- jdlyga 9y agoI'm surprised New York doesn't get mentioned that often. It's a wonderful place to work for software developers. Sure, the housing is expensive, but nothing like Silicon Valley. And you're in the middle of one of the most amazing cultural centers in the world.
- kcorbitt 9y agoI realize that the housing market isn't the only thing keeping startups and talented, ambitious people out of the Bay Area, but it's probably the biggest one. If the Bay Area can't get its act together and start permitting new housing in proportion with its economic and population growth, it will go down in the books as one of the largest and most obviously foreseeable squandered opportunities in modern history.
- Finnucane 9y agoRight, clearly the Bay Area has to accommodate every startup, and no one else should have any.
- techsupporter 9y agoI don't think kcorbitt meant that at all. I read it as that if the Bay Area wants to remain (regain?) competitiveness with other, lower-cost areas, it must adapt, not that the Bay Area is entitled to hoard every startup. Other areas are competing on the basis of cost or livability so the Bay Area has to navigate that competitive landscape if the people there wish it to remain a destination.
- Finnucane 9y agoWhy do they need to be competitive? Is it a zero-sum game? Will people suddenly decide they don't want to live there any more? The only way the Bay Area/Silicon Valley is going to suffer from this is if the entire tech industry collapses.
- kcorbitt 9y agoI knew I'd get this objection. :) It's true that to some degree Silicon Valley's loss is the rest of the world's gain, and I'm totally cool with that. But I worry that to a perhaps larger degree companies that would have been successful will simply never be formed, because the founders that could have made them happen won't be in an environment with the critical concentration of capital, mentorship and skilled employees. That outcome would be a tragedy for all of us.
- valuearb 9y agoThis article has been written many times in the last 30 years. Somehow Silicon Valley survives.
- Apocryphon 9y agoThe question isn't if Silicon Valley will survive. The question is if there's a chance for new hubs to develop.
- sputknick 9y agoWhat other cities not mentioned in this article should I consider moving to? I've heard Kansas City and Nashville. I want a city smaller and cheaper than Seattle.
- techsupporter 9y agoWhat else do you want? If all you're after is less expensive and smaller than Seattle (I presume you mean "Puget Sound" because there are many cities in the region that are smaller and less expensive than Seattle itself), many metro areas fit the bill. Tyler, Texas; Midland/Odessa, also in Texas; Oklahoma City; Shreveport, Louisiana; Lincoln, Nebraska; Cheyenne, Wyoming; and so on. Do you want a liberal/progressive-style government? Do you want a conservative/libertarian one? Do you want transit? Walkability? Large lots and houses? Small ones? A particular type of weather? It's a lot to consider and articles like these don't provide a lot of detail to go on...
- noahl 9y agoI moved from Seattle to the Raleigh-Durham (North Carolina) area this summer, and I'm very happy with it. I'd be happy to answer any questions you might have about it.
- sputknick 9y agoI might take you up on that, my wife was just looking at houses in Raleigh. IF we want to be close to downtown, is NE, NW, or SW of downtown the best? My wife liked the houses around Lenior St best.
- nunez 9y agoHighly recommend BNA (Nashville). Great weather, great people and BOOMING tech scene.
- Apocryphon 9y agoCan you provide details? How's it booming?
- 9y ago
- coreyw 9y agoDon't forget about Chicago. There are many great universities near the Chicago Metro area with a lot of great tech companies to choose from for a job. Cost of living is less than the coasts and the salaries are on par or above for cost of living in the city if you work in technology.
- leggomylibro 9y agoThe Midwest (you know, parts of it) has one big advantage over the West coast: the people. Holy cow, it's like night and day. Compare how willing people are to...not even talk with, but just acknowledge you in somewhere like SF or Seattle, to somewhere like St. Paul or St. Louis or Detroit. The juxtaposition is staggering. On an individual level there's like this universal basic assumption that everyone is a person who has merit, which is totally lacking on the West Coast. Kind of ironic, considering the political differences. But hey, you can go somewhere your vote counts, right? That might be a controversial opinion, but I've experienced both as a liberal techie, and I call a spade a spade.
- aphextron 9y ago>there's like this universal basic assumption that everyone who looks, talks, and acts exactly like me is a person who has merit, Fixed that for you
- leggomylibro 9y agoWell again, no, I actually saw far less segregation amongst (very friendly) neighbors in the Midwest - in city burbs, I'll grant you, but still. I'm not going to argue that the institutional and structural problems are better there, but individual people treated each other like people for the most part.
- nunez 9y agoAbsolutely. Folks from the Midwest are much friendlier than in the coastal cities.
- throwawayjava 9y agoHm. I grew up in the midwest and I have the exact opposite opinion. Where did you grow up? I wonder if this is that thing where we see the ugly under-belly of our homes with a clear eye, but see new places with rose-tinted glasses.
- dan_quixote 9y ago
- paulsutter 9y agoRemember that if Silicon Valley is tough for investors, that probably means it's good for entrepreneurs. Conversely, if the midwest is promising for investors, that probably means it's tough for entrepreneurs. Just saying.
- jonathankoren 9y agoAs a native midwesterner, I've heard this for 20 years now. (Remember all the "Silicon Prairies"?) Yeah, I'd love to be able to spend million dollars on a home, and actually have it feel like I spent a million dollars on a home instead, a perfectly normal home. But, there's just not that much there. It's a chicken and egg thing. There's no reason why you couldn't do something there, but it's harder because there's just not the critical mass of talent and capital. Outside of Chicago[3], there's a paucity of jobs. See Louisville[0], St Louis[1], Columbus[2]. Even the quality of jobs in Chicago feels pretty meh compared to SF / SV, but that's just my opinion. [0] https://whoishiring.io/search/38.2527/-85.7585/11?category=programming&location=louisville%2C+ky&type=full-time https://whoishiring.io/search/38.2527/-85.7585/11?category=p... [1] https://whoishiring.io/search/38.6270/-90.1994/12?category=programming&location=st+louis&type=full-time https://whoishiring.io/search/38.6270/-90.1994/12?category=p... [2] https://whoishiring.io/search/39.9612/-82.9988/11?category=programming&location=columbus+oh&type=full-time https://whoishiring.io/search/39.9612/-82.9988/11?category=p... [3] https://whoishiring.io/search/41.8781/-87.6298/11?category=programming&location=chicago&type=full-time https://whoishiring.io/search/41.8781/-87.6298/11?category=p...
- sulam 9y agoSeattle, Boston, New York, LA (Snapchat) — sure. I’ve never had anyone try to recruit me to join a company in Columbus, or any of the other places mentioned here. I’ll believe these regions are really building a tech center when the companies there seem to actually be looking for senior tech talent.
- stevenj 9y agoThis seems to suggest that these investors are doing some form of value investing in VC. VC doesn't work like that. In order to survive (and prosper) as a VC it takes picking and investing in Apples, Googles, Facebooks, Amazons, Airbnbs, etc. I could be wrong, but this feels like there's too much money chasing too few good companies. That seems to be true even in Silicon Valley itself.
- rconti 9y agoThis is great, but I don't see how it solves the "two americas" problem. It seems to me the places that are depressed rural areas will remain so indefinitely. It's great if we can create more evenly-distributed jobs, but the brain drain to the 'elite' areas will still be in effect, there will just be more of them to go to. FWIW, I spent a week in Columbus (at a BigCorp datacenter) and absolutely loved the town. That said, brand new condos right in the heart of downtown are far from cheap. Desirable areas are desirable areas no matter where they are. I was shocked that a condo (the nicest of the nice, mind you) would be over $1M. I can't do the humidity, but loved the city.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cinemaguy23 9y agoCollege Station is not in the middle of nowhere. You are just barely over an hour from Houston and two hours from Austin. If you were in the DFW metroplex those two distances would barely classify you as a suburb. It's great that you are looking in the midwest but an hour outside of the ~4th largest city in the US is hardly the middle of nowhere.
- nathan_long 9y agoI've been working remotely for more than 4 years now. I live in a nice town far from the "tech scene", but I work with interesting (to me) tech, make good money, and paid 1/10 the price for my house that it would go for in San Francisco. I don't know about companies, but developers who can pick their location might consider "not Silicon Valley or New York".
- emerged 9y agoI'm in the same boat, about 5 years in the Midwest. I have absolutely no financial concerns in my life with what would be considered a fairly modest senior software engineer salary. I don't even have the slightest interest to push for raises anymore because I'm already so comfortable and happy.
- 11thEarlOfMar 9y agoIt's part of the impetus from YC, if I read the tea leaves right, but if there is a UBI, I could easily see 'hacker communes' emerge where the combined monthly stipend of the developers funds living expenses of a communal space. They could work on their startups indefinitely, and try new ideas for years without having to worry about food and shelter. Depending on the stipend amount, such communes may only be affordable in lower cost areas, including the Midwest. In large enough numbers, I could see this become a kind of movement that brings a different kind of resurgence to the deflated economies of the Midwestern States.