5 ms·
If you tax the rich, they won't leave
- qrbLPHiKpiux 9y agoThey won't, because they can't. Where else are they going to go?
- cgore 9y agoThe rich are the most capable of leaving. Even if they don't leave, they can have their money leave by playing silly games with corporate structuring or whatever, which they are the most capable of doing.
- ihsw2 9y agoAnywhere. We're experiencing the prisoners' dilemma on a global scale where nation states conspire against each-other, a sick tragedy of commons.
- johnhenry 9y agoSome argue that U.S. territories such as Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands are good places to go, but because they are still US territories, I'd argue that implementing a good tax plan would include stricter control of what happens when businesses are moved here. Outside of that, I wonder about the viability of moving to actual other countries?
- uptown 9y agoThe state of Connecticut disagrees.
- ivl 9y agoSo does France.
- johnhenry 9y agoNot trying to troll, but do you have data for Connecticut that contradicts the data presented in the article?
- uptown 9y agoIt's not only taxes, but taxes have played a major role in the state's poor business climate. Some of the state's major employers have moved or threatened to move out of the state in order to motivate other states to offer financial incentives to stay. GE left for Boston [1]. Aetna left for New York [2]. Stamford grew to support UBS and RBS, only to see them depart ... leaving enormous vacancies in prime real estate. You can find varying polls rating the business climate, but Connecticut has been ranked towards the bottom of many of those [4], with the state capital facing potential bankruptcy. State and Local Tax Burden Rankings study reported that Americans paid an average rate of 9.9 percent in state and local taxes in 2012. According to the foundation, the five highest state-local tax states were [4]: New York 12.7 % Connecticut 12.6% New Jersey 12.2% Illinois 11.0% California and Wisconsin 11.0% 2014 CNBC Top States for Business (Connecticut ranked #46) [5]: Economy – 49th Cost of living – 48th Cost of doing business – 47th Infrastructure – 42th [1] http://www.nationalreview.com/article/429874/ge-leaves-connecticut-boston-blame-taxes http://www.nationalreview.com/article/429874/ge-leaves-conne... [2] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-06-29/aetna-s-departure-from-connecticut-latest-hit-to-embattled-state https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-06-29/aetna-s-d... [3] http://www.hartfordbusiness.com/article/20170509/NEWS01/170509928/survey-ct-ranked-5th-worst-state-for-business http://www.hartfordbusiness.com/article/20170509/NEWS01/1705... [4] https://turbotax.intuit.com/tax-tips/fun-facts/states-with-the-highest-and-lowest-taxes/L6HPAVqSF https://turbotax.intuit.com/tax-tips/fun-facts/states-with-t... [5] http://www.ctcpas.org/content/26536.aspx http://www.ctcpas.org/content/26536.aspx
- throwaway2016a 9y agoNot proof but a strong anecdote. My parents have lived in Connecticut for their entire life (they are in their 70's) and are thinking of leaving. The primary reason they cite is taxes. And that is personal income, sales, property and estate tax, and my parents are middle class not rich. Many people I know are doing the same thing. But I'm not sure it is all taxes. A lot of jobs are leaving CT for the business powerhouses of New York City and Boston. So there are few jobs and very little incentive for young people to stay because there is nothing for them in the state. I left CT for Boston MA for college when I turned 18. I will never move back to that state in a billion years even with family still there.
- asdjasldkjkljd 9y agoTo be fair, the state of Connecticut doesn't have a lot else going for it otherwise. Hartford isn't exactly a bustling industry hub.
- for_i_in_range 9y agoI did. Virgin Islands (U.S.). Paid 4% in taxes and saved over $800k in taxes over 2 years. Others are doing the same via Puerto Rico. I’m lucky in that I got out before this hurricane season destroyed everything though.
- ihsw2 9y agoExactly. The cost to move off-shore is only getting lower and its knowledge becoming more wide-spread -- what this means is you no longer require "high" net-worth to access these "special" services.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoTrue. But it I think it misses the root crux of the issue. That is, you can now leave the USA and enjoy the same (read: close enough) "amenities" for a lower personal investment. That said, it might not be a brain drain per se but without infrastructure the mighty machine for printing money (often refereed to at the USA) becomes less and less effective. C'est Le Capitalism, isn't it? Money first, all else - including country - a distance second.
- itsdrewmiller 9y agoDo you disagree with the point of the article (that in general rich flight isn’t significant) or are just sharing a personal anecdote?
- heurist 9y ago4% is well below the effective rate that the wealthy in this country currently pay and are likely to ever pay (legally). Would you have stayed if your effective tax rate were 5% lower than whatever you were paying when you decided to move?
- vgrocha 9y agoDid you do it by yourself or through some company?
- malchow 9y agoThere are literally billboards on 101 in Palo Alto inviting people to leave California, and they will, if taxes, regulation, and zoning do not lighten.
- madengr 9y agoThe local U-Haul place had "Free Gas to California".
- jbb67 9y agoYeah, it's the guardian. Don't think this isn't an editorial piece pushing an agenda
- gadders 9y agoThe millionaires may not physically relocate, but what about their money? I would guess they stay where they are but use more elaborate tax planning. There is a reason why the Laffer Curve exists. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laffer_curve https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laffer_curve
- tatersolid 9y agoNot just their money, but their businesses. Here in Illinois, business of all types are relocating to Indiana, Iowa, etc. The jobs go with them, even if the rich owners still reside in IL. I have many personal anecdotes confirming this trend. There’s even a political ad running now where governors of neighboring states thank the inept Illinois Assembly leadership for all the new jobs and tax base in recent years.
- akhilcacharya 9y ago>One implication of the Laffer curve is that increasing tax rates beyond a certain point is counter-productive for raising further tax revenue. A hypothetical Laffer curve for any given economy can only be estimated and such estimates are controversial. The New Palgrave Dictionary of Economics reports that estimates of revenue-maximizing tax rates have varied widely, with a mid-range of around 70%.[2] There is a consensus among leading economists that a reduction in the US federal income tax rate would not raise annual total tax revenue.[3]
- tomjen3 9y agoThe Laffer curve applies even if nobody moves - if you have to pay 95% of your income in taxes, you are going to go have a beer with your friends and plot how to get a nice sinecure where you don't have to do much of anything.
- ryandrake 9y agoAnd even if they do leave, so what? Actually, that sounds kind of great! Reverse-gentrification. The fewer multimillionaires in my neighborhood distorting demand, the more affordable everything will be for the rest of us. I'd offer to buy them a one-way plane ticket but I'm sure they can afford it.
- Finnucane 9y agoWhen I hear someone say "I'm going to leave the country because of taxes" I say, don't let the door hit your ass on the way out.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoDitto. If they're not here to help and stick it out with the rest of us let them go. As the saying goes: "If you're not part of the solution then you're part of the problem." The truth is, they (i.e., the ultra wealthy) need us more than we need need them. A Kickstarter to buy them one-way tickets out might be the best collective investment we'll ever make :)
- vorotato 9y agoThey'll call themselves patriots too. Frankly disgusting.
- i_dont_know_ 9y agoYeah -- there's something fundamentally flawed about creating government policies tailored specifically towards only the most flighty investors. Do you want someone there because they like the area and want their taxes going towards improvements, or someone there because it's a bit cheaper than the next viable option? What kind of politicians would the latter support vs the former?
- Spooky23 9y ago25% of New York’s tax revenue comes from Wall St bonuses and their taxes. They pull out, the place will implode.
- LeifCarrotson 9y ago> People with high levels of education have very high mobility – but only for a short period after finishing their education. ... Migration is a young person’s game, and moving overwhelmingly occurs when people are starting their careers. > If millionaires were mostly college-going twentysomethings not yet tied to place by career or family responsibilities, place-based income tax systems would face serious challenges. The data does suggest that, to a degree, but it may be better explained by a combination of age plus education and careers rather than single-focused career-mindedness. It's just an anecdote, but in my experience 40-year-olds stay put because of their kids and homes, not because they couldn't find a career somewhere else. Someone a few years out of college with no kids can pack up their apartment into a few bags and try out something new on a whim. That gets more difficult with age and additional connections to an area.
- chevas 9y agoAnecdotal, but I have one multi-millionaire friend who left California strictly because of taxes. It takes a certain type of personality to just up and do it and he exemplifies whatever personality trait that is. Millionaires are established, and the article goes into reasons why they don't move around. However, what potential effect does higher taxes have on people starting businesses or thinking about starting one?
- ihsw2 9y agoI would argue that their wealth composition determines their capacity to move around -- or, more to the point, how liquid their assets are. Real-estate owners are obviously anchored to the land that their property occupies, naturally. One potential effect is that earned income (ie: wages and salaries) would precipitously fall much faster than cost of living, resulting in the drying up of credit and causing a credit crunch/housing crisis.
- rrggrr 9y agoI'm not sure this article is accurate. I started here: https://mises.org/blog/california-illinois-and-new-york-keep-losing-people-other-states https://mises.org/blog/california-illinois-and-new-york-keep... >This is why places with highly progressive income taxes – >such as New York and California – still thrive as centres >for talent and elite economic success. It it tax policy, or is it the thriving academic|tech|financial mass that accumulated due to historical events, an attractive climate, and defense related spending? I'm pretty sure its not tax policy. >Migration is a young person’s game, and moving >overwhelmingly occurs when people are starting >their careers. By the time people hit their early forties, PhDs, college grads and high >school drop-outs all show the same low rate of migration. Is it primarily young people migrating? I ask because two generations of cold climate dwellers have migrated to Florida, Arizona, North Carolin and California. This has left many of their former states with high taxes and declining populations. And according to the Tax Foundation: "Between 1999 and 2010, high-tax New York, New Jersey, and California lost about 1.2 million individual taxpayers and more than $97 billion of personal income. This does not include the corporate losses. Meanwhile, low-tax Nevada, Wyoming, and South Dakota –not known for their magnificent climates – gained about 172 thousand individual taxpayers and $15 billion of personal income during the same period, again not including corporate losses. People are moving to these states and their money is following. Certainly this trend is not a coincidence."
- kpommerenke 9y agoFlagging this article because you disagree with the data presented or its conclusion seems to violate the spirit of Hacker News.
- candiodari 9y agoHow does taxing the rich matter ? The 0.1% on top you can't tax. Just won't work. And to boot, won't matter in the budget. Then the 0.1% - 1% doesn't matter if you tax them, since they mostly (>50%) get money from taxpayers in the first place. I mean, I love the rightist "make money go round" argument, but what's the point. Obviously these people will simply demand more money from the government and judging by past performance doing that, they will succeed at this. I don't know what the solution is, but outright increasing taxes will make the problem worse.
- ivcha 9y agoIf we think about this as a wealth pyramid (a quite narrow one), then perhaps the answer is taxing progressively up the pyramid until the very top is reached. Otherwise, I agree, there's no clear solution to this, unfortunately.