3 ms·
I agree with that, teach computer scientists mathematics while they are in high school, NOT CS. Have any other mathematicians out there had to review mathemati
by bilbo0s 19y ago
I agree with that, teach computer scientists mathematics while they are in high school, NOT CS. Have any other mathematicians out there had to review mathematically intense papers written by CS students. Frightening isn't it! How about we update the whole AP system and bring it into the 21st century.
AP Chinese or Japanese Literature courses are still being debated, but we were teaching Italian Lit?
I think we should start giving our brightest young men a larger dose of mathematics and Asia. They will work the rest out on their own if we give them good fundamentals.
Incidentally, the idea that Calculus is an AP course is indicative of the challenges facing education in the US. This course, and all of the math up to it, should be required to graduate high school. AP should expect more, at least differential equations, and I myself would be more comfortable if AP required Advanced Calculus, (Real Analysis).
Some people think I expect too much. To them I would say look at the numbers. China has more HONOR students than the US has STUDENTS, even when we include the drop outs. Keep in mind that includes only their TOP students, their 'B' students are excluded from that count, and a 'B' student in China would be an honor student here. The luxury of educational tracking as we have known it is one that is too expensive for us going forward. Time to raise the bar. It is going to be increasingly difficult to address this issue through immigration. Education is the only way out. All hands on deck. We should start to do what it takes to get this done.
- amichail 19y agoWhat's wrong with immigration? Don't many excellent Asian students want to move to the US?
- iamwil 19y agoThey still do, but current American immigration policy makes it more difficult for them to do so. In addition, students from some countries are bound by their gov't to return since the gov't paid for their full ride, they have to go back and work for a couple of years. So sometimes, they don't end up staying here in the US.
- bilbo0s 19y agoYes, but the issue is one of numbers. It would be challenging, in the extreme, to convince enough Indonesians to move to the US to close the numbers gap. In fact, the projections state that if EVERY Indonesian honor student moved here, and stayed, we would still be short. In short, how many techies can you convince to move to the US? Would that number be equal to the shortfall in students? And MOST importantly, do you bet your nation's future on the belief that all these things will happen? I am a firm believer that the only sure way forward, is through education.
- dgabriel 19y agoI hate to be stickler, but bright young women take these courses, too.
- wanorris 19y ago> Incidentally, the idea that Calculus is an AP course is indicative of the challenges facing education in the US. Most colleges offer H.S. Algebra II-level courses to incoming freshmen -- nevermind requiring high school students to take calculus to graduate. > This course, and all of the math up to it, should be required to graduate high school. My guess is that all we would be accomplishing is reducing the high school graduation rate. The only way it would be worthwhile to require calculus to graduate from high school is if we created a two-track high school system and started sending non-college-track kids to vocational school. In any case, I would say that if we were going to revise the high school math curriculum, we should add a year of probability and statistics, not more calculus, especially (god forbid) differential equations. Possibly by shifting "Algebra I" into junior high school coursework, or by making Geometry an elective. I strongly suspect that the fundamentals of probability would be a lot more useful to most people than Euclidean geometry. Having high school kids take DiffEqs would do more to make kids hate math than anything I can imagine.
- krschultz 19y agoThe problem with teaching ODEs is that some people just are not motivated to learn that stuff. Why would a business man need to know differential equations? I bet this country would be a lot better off teaching Econ 101 to every student graduating than teaching differential equations, or even Calculus. Who needs to know Calc? Math, Science, and Engineering majors. Some business and finance majors, but not all. That is not the majority of people in college must less the country. Yet everyone should understand the country's economy a bit better. I have always found a lot of smart people do not understand the actual demographics of the country because they only see the people around them, who are in fact also smart people. Realize that the country is largely made up of people who have never gotten closer to high math than what they see on the blackboards in movies like Good Will Hunting, and could care less. Also consider most education majors never are required to get past Calc 1, who would teach it? I'm all for offering it, I took Calc in high school and I know other engineers who took ODEs in high school, but requiring any more than Calc 1 in high school makes no sense to me.