4 ms·
Being white, Western, and male are totally social positions. That's why they matter, in a way an 'attribute' like your shirt size doesn't. Because our society i
by jrochkind1 9y ago
Being white, Western, and male are totally social positions. That's why they matter, in a way an 'attribute' like your shirt size doesn't. Because our society is literally structured around them.
Still not something you can do individually to change them, not something to apologize for being, not something to feel guilty about it. But something to be aware of? For sure.
Disagreeing that being white, western (when talking to/about China) and male amplified the negative impact of the tweets is to pretend society is different than it is. It's not one's _fault_ one is in that social position, but it _is_ a social position, and it matters.
This may be a stretch, but being an SF reader, it's helpful to imagine an SF story about, say, aliens that take over the earth and set things up so they're in charge. Remember the 80s show 'V'? That's pretty much what's really going on, except not with aliens. Doesn't mean the aliens in V had to feel guilty for being aliens, and they couldn't change being aliens. But some of the acted against the other aliens plans to steal all the earths water and eat the humans, others for them, and others just went along with it. But pretending things weren't set up to give aliens power over humans wouldn't have helped anyone (well, except power-hungry aliens).