6 ms·
The process used in academics looks very similar. Someone write a dissertation and several other papers. Someone question the conclusion. An audience/council/bo
by belorn 9y ago
The process used in academics looks very similar. Someone write a dissertation and several other papers. Someone question the conclusion. An audience/council/board either support the author, or the disputant.
It is not fair. The default is a negative, and its up to the author to convince everyone to add specific information to the global collective. It is also susceptible to attacks from popular opinion, which is a common theme for practically all major breakthroughs. Being "right" has a long history of not being enough at the short time, while social cliques has a long history of allowing the "wrong" facts.
The question however remains: what is a better process? If they had the HN models, your edit could just as easily be downvoted by that "guy" and his support. They could abandon the deletionism model but then limit google/wikipedia search to only show articles that has been approved by the "featured article" process, but which would result in zero traffic for most articles and effort spent on Wikipedia.
- cardiffspaceman 9y agoWikipedia editors have the power to make your contribution "to the global collective" disappear. On the other hand, if you get a physical book published, it can almost certainly be purchased or borrowed even though many disagree with it or harbor ill intentions towards it. So it remains in "the global collective"
- geezerjay 9y ago> It is not fair. The default is a negative As it should be. That's how false positives get filtered out, even at the risk of losing some minor true positives in the process. If your contributions are solid then they are kept in. If they are not then keep it in your blog.