7 ms·
I recently ordered from DoorDash, a similar service. The app gave me a price for the order and then had a line item called “Dasher Tip” and asked me how much I
by TaylorAlexander 9y ago
I recently ordered from DoorDash, a similar service.
The app gave me a price for the order and then had a line item called “Dasher Tip” and asked me how much I wanted to put down. I put in $20.
Later when the woman arrived with the food, we stopped to talk for a minute. She was a little younger than my mom, and said she had just started working for the service after her husband died.
She asked me if she could ask me an awkward question, but I said okay. She wanted to know how much I had tipped her. $20.
She showed me her phone with the app on our order. DoorDash told her we had tipped her $6, which she thought was suspiciously low (we ordered $90 in food).
TL;DR:
DoorDash presented me with an optional field called “Dasher Tip”, which I wasn’t sure of but assumed this was the Tip for the woman bringing us the food. I paid $20 for this “tip” but only $6 made it to the woman (whose husband had died). Incidentally I offered her a cash tip but she refused - she said I had already paid it and it should come from DoorDash.
Last night my friends wanted to order food again. I called it in to the restaurant and we picked it up. I don’t want to use DoorDash anymore.
- cylinder 9y agoThe psychopaths are running the show now. I don't use any of these nonsense delivery apps.
- dzonga 9y agoVC money can't make up for their weak numbers and incompetence. They gotta push up revenue in other ways.
- narrator 9y agoThe delivery business is wildly unprofitable and just runs on VC money. As soon as this economic cycle is all over they'll probably all be out of business.
- jjeaff 9y agoYa, there is this ridiculous notion that, like Uber, you can just subsidize until they've run everyone else out of the market. But in reality, if Uber or door dash or whoever take over their respective markets and then back up prices, people will stop using them just as quickly as they started and smaller, cheaper competitors will pop right back up. You don't exactly need a multi-million dollar war chest to start delivering food.
- conanbatt 9y agoUnless they find an economy of scale solution, like driverless or automated deliveries that have huge upfront costs but once achieved leaves you with a dominant position for decades.
- tabeth 9y agoYour story is a great reminder to why tipping is pointless (among many other reasons, such as [1]) If you do decide to tip, you should hand the person you want to have the money cash -- that's the only way you can be for sure they're gonna get it. [1] http://scholarship.sha.cornell.edu/articles/27/ http://scholarship.sha.cornell.edu/articles/27/
- zulln 9y agoThat would however mean the delivery person will believe you intend to tip zero until you actually do. Not discussing whether it is right or not, but I assume that could affect the received service.
- tabeth 9y agoGiven that the vast majority of situations in which you tip (notably waiters, waitresses and other staff) result in the tip being given after service, and not before, I'm OK with that.
- zulln 9y agoAbsolutely, but there is one main difference: in those scenarios you do not communicate the tipping beforehand. A more similar scenario would be to go to a restaurant, annouce that you will pay no tip, and then when you leave change your mind. The delivery person will be able to see your intentions of tipping zero, as nothing else is communicated.
- CydeWeys 9y agoHuh? It's very common to tip delivery people in cash. I remember not that long ago when there wasn't even another option -- you'd order the phone and then pay in cash (including tip) when the delivery driver arrived.
- zulln 9y agoIn those scenarios you do not communicate the tipping beforehand. This time the delivery person can see that you intend to tip zero, until you prove that wrong by actually tipping.
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoMay I ask which state you reside in?
- TaylorAlexander 9y agoCA - Bay Area
- georgemcbay 9y agoYou should consider reporting this to both the California Labor Commissioner (Dept of Industrial Relations) and the IRS, both would be extremely interested in this especially if this is DoorDash's standard procedure. I've used the service a few times in the past and probably will again, but I'm going to start asking the drivers how much they got as a tip and will definitely report any discrepancies. The website specifically says 100% goes to the delivery person ("Dasher Tip (100% for your Dasher)") so I don't think they can weasel out of that by saying the tips are pooled or any of that other nonsense.
- xadhominemx 9y agoya this is so illegal I doubt it's true
- nicolewhite 9y agoCorporations have been doing egregiously illegal things since the dawn of time.
- jeremyt 9y agoCall me crazy, but when I use one of these services, I expect the service to be reflected in the price.
- mtpn 9y agoWhile that would be ideal, I do think it’s at least slightly crazy to truly expect that people delivering food are not somewhat depending on tips to make it work. That’s just how it goes in the real world!
- imgabe 9y agoIt doesn't have to go that way if we (all of us, customers and employees alike) refuse to accept that it should go that way.
- tertius 9y agoEither start a campaign or you're seriously busy being disingenuous.
- mtpn 9y agoI agree. I was pointing out that if this commenter “expects” the employee is adequately compensated by the price paid to the company for the service, they are mistaken. I don’t think relying on the individual discretion of each customer to willingly part with extra cash for you should be the foundation of a whole job’s viability. But currently, it is.
- drawnwren 9y agoThis certainly isn't how it goes outside of the US. Why should delivering food suddenly change this vs say driving a truck or car share?
- mtpn 9y agoI’m not at all suggesting that it should be the way it is. Instacart only operates in the US though, so I figured it was safe to take that as the context.
- pmorici 9y agoThat is really screwed up. That is basically Fraud on the part of DoorDash
- justifier 9y agoi am unsure where you are located but that is definitely illegal in california: http://www.dir.ca.gov/dlse/FAQ_tipsandgratuities.htm http://www.dir.ca.gov/dlse/FAQ_tipsandgratuities.htm if anyone does use the service.. definitely point the individual in the direction of the dlse
- artursapek 9y agoWow, that sounds very illegal
- justboxing 9y ago> I had tipped her. $20. She showed me her phone with the app on our order. DoorDash told her we had tipped her $6 This is why I almost always tip in Cash. I hand it to the person, in person. San Francisco's Indian Restaurants (Indian here, and I go to the Indian restaurants here all the time, that's how I know) are notorious for not passing on any of the tips left on the card to the waitstaff, and some even don't give them the cash that's left in a counter tip jar. I'd previously mentioned this situation on HN and someone told me that I could complain to some Labor organization that will investigate the Restaurant. Anyone have any experience doing this?
- rhizome 9y agotl;dr: it's wage theft. I don't have experience doing it, but both of these cases are highly, highly frowned upon and likely to get quick resolution if a complaint is made to the Department of Labor. http://blogs.findlaw.com/law_and_life/2013/05/legal-for-your-boss-to-take-your-tips.html http://blogs.findlaw.com/law_and_life/2013/05/legal-for-your... https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/should-supervisor-sharing-tips.html https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/should-supervisor-sh...
- justboxing 9y agoThanks! I'll give this a try!
- sushid 9y agoSeriously!? I go to Indian restaurants in SF all the time and I've only ever paid by card. Do the waiters get to keep the tip if you give it to them with cash?
- justboxing 9y ago> Do the waiters get to keep the tip if you give it to them with cash? In most Indian & Pakistani places, yes. There are some exceptions. The owner of Raavi on Jackson St takes the cash tips placed in the Tip Jar at closing (so the waiters don't get it even if it's cash). The owners of Little Delhi on Eddy St near the Westfields Mall take all the cash tips for themselves and don't allow the waitstaff to take cash from the patron. I tried giving it to the girl and she said they are not allowed to accept it. So I don't leave anything on card or cash when I eat at Little Delhi. I feel bad exposing these guys cos the owners are good friends, but this is just plain wrong. This is the reason I give cash, in person, to the person. Only way to ensure 100% that waitress or waiter gets the $. When I tried that at Little Delhi, the girl said "We are not allowed to take cash" and that's when I found out that the owner eat all the credit card tips, and cash tips placed inside the bill / check folder.
- tehlike 9y agoPlaying devils advocate (and not defending doordash in any way): Could the tip be shared potentially with the people preparing the orders and the delivery person?
- partycoder 9y agoThis is very upsetting, and contradicting with their FAQ: http://dasherhelp.doordash.com/new-dasher-pay-model-faq/ http://dasherhelp.doordash.com/new-dasher-pay-model-faq/ In the case of Instacart, I already gave up on them. They make too many shopping decisions on your behalf. Like ring your phone, and claim "they called you", and pick replacements themselves. I would like to know if GrubHub steals from the tip jar as well.
- Waterluvian 9y agoThat is appalling. A pox on the businesspersons at DoorDash.
- dalfonso 9y agoThis is terrible. The app definitely says, "100% goes to your dasher".
- justinjlynn 9y agoIf that's the case then I'd be surprised if it weren't classed as fraud.
- jeff18 9y agoThat seems weird, since I would expect to have seen something about that in the NYT, WSJ, or at least TechCrunch. I did some quick Googling and according to the DoorDash Reddit, your tips are only shown to you at the end of the shift and they are grouped together so you can't tell how much each person tipped you: https://www.reddit.com/r/doordash/comments/6dkjjw/tip_question_for_drivers/ https://www.reddit.com/r/doordash/comments/6dkjjw/tip_questi... Are you sure you weren't just looking at the $6 delivery fee and your tip would be added later?
- rokhayakebe 9y agoIf this correct I will never order from DD and I will ensure anyone I know does not either.
- fourstar 9y agoDoordash for whatever reason just deactivated my account. No warning, no explanation. Just deactivated. Sorry, but your service isn't worth my time to try to re-activate. Bye!
- GhostVII 9y agoSeems really odd that they make you send a tip before the food gets to you - my understanding of tips is that they are supposed to reflect and encourage the level of service you received - if you pay them before you were served, they don't really do much. Not a fan of them either way, but this seems even more pointless than normal.
- esolyt 9y agoUnfortunately, Amazon Prime Now does the same. Tips are simply becoming "hidden fees".
- TaylorAlexander 9y agoHEY ITS OP HERE: I don’t see an edit option so I’ll say here. This comment got a lot of attention so I should clarify. Some are saying this should be a huge story, it’s illegal in CA (where this occurred) etc. I’m not sure how the DoorDash app works from the Dasher’s perspective, so I was taking her word that the tip was $6. Also I was incorrect on my tip amount - it was 20% which was $14.21 (the order was $92.00 including fees and tip). She did show me an amount under $10 ($6 or $7?) as her pay for this task. She did have to wait for a while at the restaurant because their food was not ready in time, and I was under the impression that the figure she showed me was her total compensation for the delivery. If she in fact received my $14 after as some are suggesting that would be an improvement. She said she was somewhat new to DoorDash so there could have been a misunderstanding, but she was under the impression they had been stiffing her on previous nights as well, so I’m not sure it’s a simple case of her not knowing she would be tipped more later. Is anyone else here a Dasher who would be willing to confirm tip amounts with some customers? You do enter the tip in to the app before finalizing the order, so they will know.
- dba7dba 9y agosmh. So, that's how some get rich. Charge higher price, but pay workers less. Switch to cheaper ingredients with lower price, but pass only a small portion of the saving to the customers.