4 ms·
They weren't "sworn enemies," they were rival empires sharing a border. This led to frequent clashes, but there was also regular trade and diplomatic emissaries
by boomboomsubban 9y ago
They weren't "sworn enemies," they were rival empires sharing a border. This led to frequent clashes, but there was also regular trade and diplomatic emissaries. That enables books to travel and ideas to spread.
All of your articles say the same thing, quoting again,
"It deserves to be noted that before the 12th century, the whole Byzantine output of Aristotelian commentaries dealt exclusively with the works on logic."
That's basically my point, his philosophical work was ignored. All of your sources have supported this, you even seem to be searching specifically for sources saying this now judging by that link.
What you haven't shown is any serious thought put into his philosophical work during that period, or given any other cause for his sudden resurgence besides Islamic influence. You're trying to disprove my argument that he was ignored until the Islamic works by saying "see they said Aristotle in 750, he wasn't forgotten."
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- iorrus 9y agoLooking into this further it appears you are correct in that Al-Farabi for instance actually studied in Byzantium for 8 years according to the preface in this book: https://www.amazon.com/Political-Writings-Regime-Summary-Editions/dp/0801453801/ref=sr_1_6?ie=UTF8&qid=1511194253&sr=8-6&keywords=Al-farabi#reader_0801453801 https://www.amazon.com/Political-Writings-Regime-Summary-Edi...
- mkempe 9y agoAll biographies indicate that Al-Farabi studied in Baghdad under a Christian teacher, not in Constantinople.
- boomboomsubban 9y agoHis actual biography is unclear, much of it coming from sources hundreds of years later. What's clear is that he wrote commentaries on Aristotle's works beyond the Organon, something that is missing from Byzantine history. As the other poster notes, he does have strong connections to Nestorian Christians of the time. They're the group that translated Aristotle from Syriac to Arabic that later led to the Latin translations bring made. And they had little to do with the Romans/Byzantines, having been condemned as heretical by the Roman church in the fifth century.
- iorrus 9y agoIt says in the preface he was there for 8 years. I'll take the word of the man who wrote a recent book on his philosophy over some guy on HN. He probably brushed up on Aristotle at the time. His early teachers were Nestorian Christians.
- boomboomsubban 9y agoThe preface is written by a translator, not a historian, and his source is another translator. Translating his works does not make him an authority on his biography. The contemporary sources are near nonexistent for his biography, and the major ones written later were contradictory. http://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/farabi-i http://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/farabi-i Either way, you agree his time in Baghdad with the Nestorians came earlier, and they were far more involved in writing about Aristotle than any Byzantine known today. Maybe he did seek Greek versions of his work in Constantinople, those works were not influential in the Byzantine Empire. I don't see how any of this is overly relevant to the discussion.
- iorrus 9y agoBased on your link there is a strong possibility that he studied with the Greeks. (Two sources say he did) What is mentioned no where is that Aristotle was 'forgotten' by the Greeks. In fact everywhere in those manuscripts it is assumed that the Greeks are in possession of their full philosophic heritage.
- boomboomsubban 9y agoThe link calls them "fabricated stories" and "legends," due to their emergence three centuries after his death. That would be like two biographies released this year on George Washington containing one sentence about how he sailed to China in his teenage years. Not a "strong possibility." I have no idea what manuscripts you're claiming say the Greeks are in full possession of their philosophical heritage, but that is obviously false when you think about how many works have been lost over the millennia. Even being in possession of them wouldn't change that they were being ignored though, the whole "lack of commentary until the thirteenth century" bit.