4 ms·
Seems like small potatoes today, doesn't it? When one takes at face value the extremely simplistic way you stated it, yes, it seems small. But that's not what
by mikestew 9y ago
Seems like small potatoes today, doesn't it?
When one takes at face value the extremely simplistic way you stated it, yes, it seems small. But that's not what happened. Microsoft was convicted of using their monopoly position in operating systems to extend their reach into web browsers. Practically speaking, the only consumer operating systems at the time ran on personal computers, either desktops or laptops, and in that market Microsoft held an overwhelming market share. There were no mass market smartphones (there was WinCE, but few I knew had them), Palm Pilots held the PDA market for a short while, but all a drop in the bucket compared to full-blown OSs.
When was the last time you've heard of anti trust litigation because iPhones come with Safari or a whole bunch of Apple services?
Go buy a turnkey Android phone if you don't like it.
What about Google and its software on any and all Android phones?
Go buy an iPhone if you don't like that.
And why can Amazon tie Kindle to its book store and not get sued by competitors?
Apple's iBooks has about everything you'll find on Amazon. Haven't used it, but I'd be surprised if Google Books wasn't close enough.
What were you going to buy computer-wise in 2001? A desktop or laptop that came with Microsoft Windows whether you wanted it or not. That was your practical choice, and the courts found that though it was fine for Microsoft to own the OS market, it was not fine to leverage that into driving Netscape out of business.
- hungerstrike 9y agoYou can't build a mobile app business and not release iOS versions of your apps. Sounds like enough of a monopoly to me.
- mikestew 9y agoIt might sound like it, it might be the way you wish things to be, but that does not define a monopoly even by the loosest definition.
- Fnoord 9y ago> Go buy an iPhone if you don't like that. Or use LineageOS + microG [1] > What were you going to buy computer-wise in 2001? A desktop or laptop that came with Microsoft Windows whether you wanted it or not. That was your practical choice, and the courts found that though it was fine for Microsoft to own the OS market, it was not fine to leverage that into driving Netscape out of business. Yep, not only that, Microsoft insisted a computer should come preinstalled with an OS (an anti-piracy argument IIRC). So eventually, some vendors included FreeDOS. Also, if you wanted to run something else like Linux on a computer it would cost you serious work. An example is "winmodem", an onboard software modem instead of a traditional dedicated 'hardware' modem. Or WiFi drivers which wouldn't work because the drivers were closed source. The main alternative was building your own computer. That's not feasible with a laptop though. Also I recommend people not just look at only SCO but the whole Halloween documents (and do realise even those are a summary). For example, have a peak at one of the earlier Halloween documents which described how Netscape was driven out of business. [1] https://lineage.microg.org/ https://lineage.microg.org/ [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halloween_documents https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halloween_documents
- dnautics 9y agoIronically the antitrust authorities did not come down very hard on Microsoft for some incredibly uncompetitive practices it did to keep a stranglehold on the bootloader. https://www.theregister.co.uk/2001/08/31/jean_louis_gass_233_e/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2001/08/31/jean_louis_gass_233...
- jgh 9y ago> Or use LineageOS + microG [1] Eh, that's like arguing that Linux was a viable alternative for the everyday consumer during the Microsoft days. While you _could_ do that in a practical sense most people don't have the know-how (as you mentioned in your reply).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- throwaway328429 9y agoBut you could argue that Internet Explorer was indeed a critical piece of the Windows experience, as Microsoft tried to argue, and it was for the next couple decades to come. Today, a certain company ships an entire operating system on that concept. How do you see leveraging a monopolistic position on search to push a browser that is arguably the IE6 of the browsers today: high market share, bloated, actively invades privacy, and bends web standards often? throwaway because I may or may not work for one of the companies in question :P
- WalterBright 9y ago> What were you going to buy computer-wise in 2001? Lots of people bought computers and put linux on them. You could also buy Macs. There were lots of screwdriver shops where they'd put together a machine for you with no "Windows Tax", if you wanted one. The thing about browsers at the time - they were all free. Explorer, Netscape, Opera. It's a weird anti-trust case to complain about software being free.
- mjw1007 9y agoSupplying stuff "for free" (particularly as part of a bundle with expensive stuff that you have a monopoly on) to undermine your competitors is a pretty central example of the sort of behaviour that anti-trust law is there to prevent. It's an extreme case of predatory pricing. I agree that it's odd to see such a case when the competitor's product is also free, though. Opera used a pay-to-remove-the-ads model around that time, but I don't know if Netscape ever considered doing so.
- Nomentatus 9y agoThe legal term is "bundling." If multiple companies are doing, it, even in the same niche, it's an awfully sure sign that the laws haven't been enforced in a long while.
- WalterBright 9y agoI never understood how throwing in a free browser was detrimental to me. The kerfluffle over uninstalling it was irrelevant, too. Don't like it? Don't use it. It wasn't necessary to uninstall it. So what if it sits there on the disk. I don't use probably 90% of Windows/Linux/OSX, but it doesn't disturb me that they sit on the disk. I currently have both Chrome and Explorer installed on my Windows box. Sometimes I use one, sometimes the other. So what.
- zaarn 9y agoThat's you. Most people simply use what comes with the operating system given no other choice.
- shubb 9y agoAmazon may have a monopoly position in some markets though. They have 80% of the ebook market (90% in uk) and 75% of the ereader market (apparently). In some countries much higher. I suspect they are gaining monopoly positions in smart buttons (which currently don't matter) and audio assistants (echo). It doesn't matter as I understand it if there are competing products when no one buys them, and here in the UK I've seen many echos, but not one Google home in the wild. Given echo and kindle both cross sell amazon's online marketplace, that could get nasty.
- dsacco 9y ago> Apple's iBooks has about everything you'll find on Amazon. Absolutely not. Look for technical ebooks and compare the results between iBooks and Kindle. iBooks only matches Kindle for popular "what's everyone reading" and "cultural zeitgeist" fiction/nonfiction books.
- eli_gottlieb 9y ago>What were you going to buy computer-wise in 2001? A desktop or laptop that came with Microsoft Windows whether you wanted it or not. That was your practical choice, and the courts found that though it was fine for Microsoft to own the OS market, it was not fine to leverage that into driving Netscape out of business. And this year, I bought a laptop and found out that routine BIOS updates via UEFI capsule don't work if I've installed Linux. Microsoft still has an OS monopoly to such an extent that OEMs feel fine about failing to support any situation in which you run anything but the bundled Microsoft OS, even at the hardware/firmware level.