14 ms·
I wouldn't say the problem is tech overuse; more specifically it is internet overuse. Offline is fine, in fact many probably many people have fond memories of t
by andrepd 9y ago
I wouldn't say the problem is tech overuse; more specifically it is internet overuse. Offline is fine, in fact many probably many people have fond memories of tinkering with computers when they were younger, and many even became programmers or similar because of playing with computers when they were young. It is often a very stimulating activity.
However the internet is a completely different beast. Some thought must be had about whether it is desirable for children to have unfettered access to a medium that puts them in touch with anyone in the world, and most importantly in the net of today, puts them in the targets of hyper-optimized manipulation and advertisement campaigns, and websites and services designed to manipulate your psyche no matter the side effects (e.g. depression from using social media), in order to get you to buy more stuff.
New technology isn't automatically good because it's new technology. We must have these debates.
- 0xcde4c3db 9y ago> most importantly in the net of today, puts them in the targets of hyper-optimized manipulation and advertisement campaigns, and websites and services designed to manipulate your psyche no matter the side effects (e.g. depression from using social media), in order to get you to buy more stuff I think this is the bulk of the problem. There's nothing in the technology to say that that a website or game must bend over backwards with "engagement" bullshit and microtransaction teases instead of just being a good reading/playing experience. It's a socioeconomic and cultural problem, and blaming the technology isn't going to solve any of it.
- jsonne 9y agoThe problem is that internet advertising as a model for 99% of companies (Facebook, Google, and a handful of others making it work being the exceptions) is fundamentally broken. When you're a media company you fundamentally trade on people's attention and advertisers pay you to get a piece. You can do that with great content, or with dark patterns and manipulation. Usually its some combination of both. Regardless the vast majority of the web needs a new business model, but I'm not sure what the answer is.
- andrepd 9y agoIt's capitalist incentives. If the name of the game is maximizing profits, and this is the way to do it, then everything else be damned. The current state of the internet is a direct consequence of the current system of economic incentives.
- tluyben2 9y agoI think you are right; I grew up in the end 70s/begin 80s with most of my time (from a young age) and most my friends their time tinkering with electronics and computers ; it made people happy. Programming and soldering made us always have something to do, always keeping our minds busy and creative. I think the internet added pressure in every way to that; everything is a performance, everything is compared and everything can have a longlasting effect. I cannot imagine this kind of connectivity being good for people (young or old) who are not immune to the possible effects. And children can hardly be expected to be immune yet and they might never be.