3 ms·
Most of the reason chemical weapons don't get used is because they're not very effective. It's hard to disperse them on the battlefield, changing weather has a
by mikeash 9y ago
Most of the reason chemical weapons don't get used is because they're not very effective. It's hard to disperse them on the battlefield, changing weather has a nasty habit of blowing the stuff back onto your own troops, and protective gear is cheap enough to equip everyone in an army. I'm pretty sure that everyone was willing to ban them internationally not just because they're horrible but also because they're not very useful.
Compare with nuclear weapons, which are way worse and have a lot of support for a ban, but there's no serious hope of that ever happening, because they are really good at killing people and destroying stuff.
Seems to me that a ban is only realistic if the stuff doesn't work well.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago>> Most of the reason chemical weapons don't get used is because they're not very effective. Against a modern military equipped and prepared to withstand them, perhaps. Against a civilian population or a less well-funded force, not so much. This is doubly the case when the attacker is a non-state agent (like a terrorist). Remember for instance the Sarin gas attack in the Tokyo metro by the Shinning Path [1]. An air force bombing a major city with chemical weapons would also cause vast casualties. I think what you're trying to say is that chemical weapons are primarily designed to be terrifying with lethality considerations coming next. However, you could argue the same about nuclear weapons. After all, the attacks in Hiroshima and Nagasaki were not acutally meant to wipe the Japanese apart, only to scare them into submission. And nuclear deterrence works on the principle that an enemy won't dare attack a nuclear power. In general, you could think of all weapons ever as aimed primarily at the morale of the enemy rather than their life and that thought may have some merit. After all, an army that breaks and runs is beaten faster and with fewer losses to the other side than one that fights to the last [2]. However, the important point to keep in mind is that weapons, even when they're primarily designed to be terrifying, are designed to be terrifying in the manner they kill. So I think you'll find that most people would agree that chemical weapons should be banned because they kill in a horrible manner, not relative to the number of casualties they may or may not inflict. I do think you underestimate their potency btw. __________________________ [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tokyo_subway_sarin_attack https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tokyo_subway_sarin_attack [2] Cough cough. In war games, certainly.