7 ms·
What is our action plan against foreign interference?
- DivyaMehra 9y agoWant to Karol Bagh escorts from a renowned escort service in Karol Bagh Nisha is a Model escort in Karol Bagh and Provides Call girls in Karol Bagh Delhi Visit http://www.angelss.in/karol-bagh-escorts.html http://www.angelss.in/karol-bagh-escorts.html
- notimetorelax 9y agoWhat does foreign mean? Does all this apply to European elections?
- ghostcluster 9y agoTime to censor The Economist for meddling with the US political process! Speaking of, does Facebook censor Al Jazeera? It is foreign State run media that often runs English language stories tinged with Anti-Western agitprop. Their drive to limit clickbait is at least noble, though we'll see what that means in practice. Some of the worst clickbait offenders are none other than the large US media institutions themselves, from NYTimes, to WaPo, to Vice and BuzzFeed.
- ssijak 9y agoClickbaiting is new default in media. Where I come from I stop reading all news because clickbaiting is soooo overused and in EVERY article that it is painful to read something that seems as written by an adult who researched the topic.
- jackvalentine 9y agoThat was my question too - it refers to sharing ads with congress so does that mean this is US-focused?
- uoaei 9y agoForeign means parties outside the sovereign state in which they act.
- abraae 9y agoThe article clearly calls out only the US. Since this announcement would have been carefully vetted by Facebook management and legal, I have to presume that means that they are only taking action over US elections.
- ipsum2 9y agoNot true, Facebook is working on removing foreign interference for other countries like Germany: http://fortune.com/2017/09/27/facebook-fake-accounts-german-election/ http://fortune.com/2017/09/27/facebook-fake-accounts-german-...
- paralelogram 9y agoWhen I click on "Investing in operations" or "Updating our policies", I see US-formatted dates such as "August 28, 2017", so foreign probably means non-US.
- viraptor 9y agoIt's a US company, publishing some English text. Why would you expect them to use a non-US date format?
- abraae 9y agoBoth TFA and the embedded video reference "US election ads" which I find pretty shitty as a citizen of a country not the US (though thankfully our election is now behind us).
- meowface 9y agoI'm no fan of Facebook as a corporation but they seemed to handle the election interference situation about as best they could. The default stance for posts and advertisements should always be to not censor, which is what happened. When they were presented with clear evidence of malicious advertising and accounts, they provided everything they knew about them to law enforcement and to Congress. And now they're proactively monitoring for future attempts.
- viraptor 9y ago> When they were presented with clear evidence of malicious advertising and accounts, they provided everything they knew about them to law enforcement and to Congress. I kind of agree. The issue of fake accounts and pushing propaganda was known for a long time. It's only when it became common knowledge / no longer possible to ignore that they reacted. There was no proactive monitoring it seems so it had to be pointed out to them by third parties. A cynical person could risk a guess they cared about active users - doesn't matter if human or not. They definitely could've done better.
- ryandrake 9y agoI'm not a fan either, but honestly--if a presidential election can actually be swayed by "people buying ads on Facebook" then the USA has problems much deeper than Facebook. What happened to the five whys and getting to the root cause of a problem? To any politician ready to crucify Facebook over Russians buying ads I ask: "What have you personally done to help separate money from politics?"
- RyanZAG 9y agoAs a non-American, I haven't understood why this issue is about Russians to start with. Aren't there many countries who donated large sums of money to American politics [1]? Also if Russian adverts are having such a huge effect on American politics, why are Russian adverts different to political adverts bought by non-Russians? Any advert is obviously bought with the intent to swing the election in favor of company purchasing that advert - likely for malicious intent by many. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/21/us/politics/hillary-clinton-presidential-campaign-charity.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/21/us/politics/hillary-clint...
- jabretti 9y agoDamn, I'm a foreigner. Will I be banned from speaking about US politics on facebook?
- confounded 9y agoWho can tell? You won't be banned from speaking about anything, but whether anyone sees it or not is a secret matter, between Facebook and their clients.
- superplussed 9y agoOn the subject of increasing transparency, Jason Calacanis had a suggestion that I thought was brilliant. There should be a public database of all ads running on Facebook, that would simply show the ad, the ad purchaser, and who the ad is targeted to. There ads would be filterable, so that someone viewing the database could filter based on the same criteria that Facebook allows advertisers to target. So if I search "non-college educated white males over the age of 40 in Midwestern suburbia", I get a complete overview of what these people have been shown. If I come across a nefarious advertiser, I can also filter to see what other campaigns they've run and who they've targeted. Transparency, solved. Now the responsibility to police the ads becomes somewhat shared and it's easy to imagine watchdog groups monitoring different types of campaigns looking for bad actors.
- abraae 9y agoThat's a great idea but "tooth and nail" doesn't even begin to describe how hard Facebook will fight against that kind of transparency.
- Maarten88 9y agoIt is becoming increasingly clear that Facebook (and other social networks) are not a net-positive thing for society as a whole, the way they currently are. So I wonder how much we should care about their opinion, other than understanding the power they can bring in fighting change. I think Facebook does not want to be evil, if the rules are the same for their competitors too they might be convinced to implement deep changes like this one. The alternative, which they will really not want, is that they are ultimately made liable for the defamation, paid disinformation campaigns and other forms of injustice they facilitate, in every jurisdiction where they operate.
- chronid 9y agoThat could become a terrible disadvantage for Facebook and could be weaponized by competitors - unless it is mandatory for all companies publishing ads online (and maybe offline?).
- Proven 9y agoFacebook fascists
- OoTheNigerian 9y agoForeign to whom? Just the US or to all governments? Will this transparency be available to the Russians? Saudi Arabians? Egyptians? Nigerians? Brits? French? Iranians? Even though all nations interfere in everyone's business,the undisputed number one interferer in others countries business is the United States government. Anything short of of making these tools available to everyone would position Facebook as an agent/agency of the US Government. - As an aside, the Russia brouhaha is a ridiculous sideshow led by people who are yet to come to terms of defeat. If a Less than a million dollars of Facebook ads shown to a few thousand people can determine who becomes president in the US, then there is a much bigger problem. But we all know that's not the case.
- statictype 9y ago>If a Less than a million dollars of Facebook ads shown to a few thousand people can determine who becomes president in the US, then there is a much bigger problem. Do we know that that’s all that happened? Or is this just the tip of the ice berg. >Anything short of of making these tools available to everyone would position Facebook as an agent/agency of the US Government. Facebook is an American company. So is Apple and Google. Even if they are not legally bound to serve the interests of the country, their employees are overwhelmingly American and probably patriotic and so we have to expect that when push comes to shove the interests of the US will come first.
- DeusExMachina 9y ago> we have to expect that How is that a moral justification? Even if we might expect it, it does not make the fact any better.
- OoTheNigerian 9y ago>"Facebook is an American company. So is Apple and Google. Even if they are not legally bound to serve the interests of the country, their employees are overwhelmingly American and probably patriotic and so we have to expect that when push comes to shove the interests of the US will come first." 85% of Facebook users are outside the United States. Taking the position of "when push comes to shove, we work for the US government" is probably not the best way to be seen. There is nothing stopping them to be equally transparent for everyone while keeping the laws of every jurisdiction in which they operate.
- confounded 9y agoWell, I imagine periodically setting up a pseudonymous account to catch invites to parties is about to get a lot harder. Unsurprisingly, many of these measures align with zucc's motives to make Facebook the new Experian as the canonical owners of your 'identity' for business purposes.
- phrygian 9y agoWhat does foreign mean to Facebook? I had assumed that Facebook sees itself as some transnational entity. Unless this is about picking winner states.
- macspoofing 9y ago>We're updating our policy to block ads from Pages that repeatedly share stories marked as false by third-party fact-checking organizations Eek. Those fact-checking sites are staffed by underpaid, inexperienced, 20-somethings with their own ideological bent. These young staffers aren't doing any investigative work - they just sit there and google stuff. Not to mention the fact that those sites have the same advertising pressures as other sites (incentive is for click-bait articles). Let's not go overboard with treating them as some sort of a gold-standard.
- thisisit 9y agoHow about this for an action plan: 1. Stop collecting data on people's political leaning 2. Stop allowing granular ad targeting which can reach people of certain political leaning and/or world view