18 ms·
> The Nordic nation’s $1 trillion sovereign wealth fund said Thursday that it’s considering unloading its shares of Exxon Mobil Corp., Royal Dutch Shell Plc and
by loeg 9y ago
> The Nordic nation’s $1 trillion sovereign wealth fund said Thursday that it’s considering unloading its shares of Exxon Mobil Corp., Royal Dutch Shell Plc and other oil giants to diversify its holdings and guard against drops in crude prices.
That doesn't sound like activist divestment. And in fact, environmental activism isn't why Norway is considering this action:
> Norwegian officials say the plan isn’t based on any particular view about future oil prices
> ...
> the move has more to do with hedging risk than saving the planet. Norway derives about 20 percent of its economic output from oil and gas. Finance officials have long debated whether reinvesting those profits back into petroleum producers leaves Norwegians overly exposed to the volatility of oil prices.
So the headline and intro are fairly misleading, IMO.
- Banthum 9y agoIt's the national equivalent of "Don't invest in your employer, because if it goes bust you lose your investments AND your job."
- pfortuny 9y agoYou are already paud by your employer, you are not going to get more money or security from him.
- ekianjo 9y agomany companies encourage employees to buy stock with special rates.
- EliRivers 9y agoIf you're really lucky, as I'm sure you well know, you can ever put your pension into the company, and then when Enron goes bust you've got no job, no investments, no pension!
- cmpxchg8b 9y agoWhich any wise person would sell immediately to diversify.
- simonh 9y agoSure, but until those options vest you’re still doubly exposed. I’m in this position right now. A fixed amount from my pay goes into buying options which vest in 3 years time. Fortunately I could afford to lose that money if it came down to it, but it’s a real issue and in a worst case scenario that’s money I might need. It’s certainly a consideration.
- dash2 9y agoThat is not necessarily true. As an employee, you may be in a good position to judge whether a firm is likely to succeed, with perspectives not available to the market. This is why markets often react when CEOs buy/sell their own stock.
- gaius 9y agoA CEO is an "insider" in market-speak. Jo(e) Engineer is just a punter like anyone else.
- morgante 9y agoThat's not strictly true. Depending on the company, it's very possible for mere engineers to have access to material non-public information. There's a reason many companies impose broad blackout dates on trading.
- avar 9y agoThis advice is usually "Don't (only) invest in the industry you're employed in". See e.g. the dot-com bubble and how people who worked in IT and had invested their money mainly in IT were screwed, whereas it wasn't so bad if you just got fired and say invested in an S&P 500 index fund. But yes, investing only in your employer is a particularly bad version of that.
- jessaustin 9y ago...investing only in your employer is a particularly bad... Haha when I worked for Lucent long ago they actually had a program set up exactly for that, so my more foolish colleagues received vastly-overpriced stock in place of some percentage of their salary. Thinking back, the managers must have had some kind of incentive because they hyped it in unseemly fashion.
- arcticbull 9y agoESPP programs are fairly common, and usually a great decision because they yield a minimum 15% return on the final value of the investment at the end of the program period whether the stock goes up or down. If you sell immediately, you realize a minimum of 90% ARR over the program period. [1] No need to keep it there if you just want to take your gains and walk. [1] https://thefinancebuff.com/employee-stock-purchase-plan-espp-is.html https://thefinancebuff.com/employee-stock-purchase-plan-espp...
- jessaustin 9y agoIn some cases one would be better served to run rather than walk. I remember advising colleagues as to the riskiness of this program in late 1999. Three years later LU had lost 98% of its value.
- mercutio2 9y agoESPP is guaranteed to make money for employees. Everyone should sell ESPP shares immediately, of course, and most don’t, so functionally you’re right, they’re dangerous, but if you can be mildly disciplined, I don’t think there’s a better investment in the world than taking your employer up on discount ESPP shares then selling the moment they’re in your account.
- mtgx 9y agoAlthough driven by their own policy, the fact that almost half of the new cars in Norway are electric/hybrid vehicles is incredible. I think they know EVs are on a growing trend, and they just get to see it at an accelerated rate than everyone else - but they probably believe the same will happen elsewhere, just 5-10 years later. I think it's unlikely that this wasn't at least a small factor in their decision. I also believe that as EVs grow to 5%, 10%, 20% of the global sales for cars, Norway will increase its "hedging" over the next few years, which will show some direct correlation between EVs and Norway's decision to hedge its oil stock risk.
- semi-extrinsic 9y agoOne should factor in that Norway's petroleum exports are ~50% natural gas (of which <1% goes to fuels for cars) and ~50% oil (of which ~60% becomes fuel for cars, trucks, tractors, excavators, airplanes, etc.). So the total "negative exposure" towards EVs if all cars everywhere become electric is <30%. Furthermore, the retail sales of gasoline and diesel fuel has not yet shown any decline in Norway [1], despite EV-subsidising policies being in effect for a decade. So decreased fuel sales volume has a many-year (perhaps even decade) long lag behind increased EV sales. (The average Norwegian car is 17 years when it is scrapped.) [1] https://www.ssb.no/en/energi-og-industri/statistikker/petroleumsalg/aar https://www.ssb.no/en/energi-og-industri/statistikker/petrol... - petroleum product sales statistics, English description, you can export to csv file.
- igravious 9y ago> the retail sales of gasoline and diesel fuel has not yet shown any decline in Norway [1] Odd. The stats you point to say otherwise. Says motor gasoline is down (1.9%) and diesel is up (4.7%) – so it's kind of a wash. More interestingly (in the context of this news of divestment) the total figures are down year on year on year (in 1000 litres units) 2012 9 635 521 2013 9 279 405 2014 8 995 567 2015 8 827 093 2016 8 790 684 In light of those figures divestment looks sensible.
- semi-extrinsic 9y ago
- kristofferR 9y agoNothing in the title or intro indicates that it was caused by environmental activism, just that it's a major positive step in their view.
- barrkel 9y agoEnvironmental activism seems to be an almost entirely invented slant by the author and his or her selection of quotes. The piece reads like propaganda to me.
- RyanZAG 9y agoI've found that every message surrounding environmentalism from all angles - either for or against - is almost always propaganda. People without some sort of bone in the game have long since dropped out of the ironically toxic discussion. There's just too much money involved in it and no real desire for real discussion. Only zealotry remains. The winning move is not to play.
- njharman 9y agoShot heard round the world Implies exactly that. If it had nothing to do with activism then 1) activism effort to influence investments failed and 2) this lends no momentum to the movement as it was a coincidence and could be changed tomorrow regardless of environmental impact. The only way this is positive news for EA is if they spin and misrepresent it as is done here.
- anigbrowl 9y agoStrongly disagree. Markets are not rational and changes in portfolio allocation by sovereign wealth funds are likely to have a ripple effect no matter what the stated reason. If it pans out, that means fossil fuel stocks become de facto optional rather than mandatory.
- valuearb 9y ago$35B divestment out of trillions in oil businesses market caps is a rounding errror.
- marvin 9y agoWell, yes and no. This is plausibly a move which could be performed even in a world where oil is expected to be the only viable energy source. But on the other hand, if you wanted to divest from oil with the expectation that oil will become a non-essential resource, you wouldn't go around proclaiming it loudly. I had the same thought when I first heard the announcement; this is going to be interpreted as more than a diversification move, and I'm not certain that it _is_ purely a diversification move. Saudi Arabia is doing the same thing by listing Saudi Aramco on the stock exchange. If oil will eventually become a (relatively) niche resource, the market value derived from non-extracted resources will tank, and divesting needs to happen now, before everyone realizes what's going on. To do this without triggering the very thing you are hedging against, you need to have plausible deniability, which Norway does.
- SomeStupidPoint 9y agoThe question that you're circling, but can't seem to put your finger on is "if they weren't concerned with oil's future, why would they diversify?" Historically, oil has gone gangbusters. I doubt any of the sovereign wealth funds lost money buying oil stocks. Yet, within a decade, we've seen a few of them announce that they're going to diversify. Ostensibly, this is a move to stabilize their long-term value against market fluctuations, but given the criticality of energy and how well historically these companies have done, it seems more likely that they're worried about a major market shift on the 30-50 year horizon and are looking to reposition themselves ahead of when the market itself moves. So to me, it looks like major oil producers are preparing to leave oil, when viewed through a generational lens -- the wealth funds are clearing out, educational training programs are shifting, etc. In 10-15 years, the flow of new workers will hit whatever low-level long-term carrying will be; in 30-40 years, oil will have settled into some kind of "post primary energy" role. (It's not like petrol products are suddenly not useful; just the bulk of traffic will shift, and so there won't be enough business to support several nations.) Of course, 2050-2060 was when people were guessing that was going to happen for quite a while. But this seems like a sign we're on track for that, broadly speaking.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tuna-piano 9y ago“This is like praising Exxon Mobil Corp. for taking other oil-company stocks out of its 401(k) plan. Sure it has sold some oil stocks. But it remains an oil company! “ “Norway is a petrostate with a sovereign wealth fund, and it has sensibly decided that that sovereign wealth fund will do a better job of diversifying the country's wealth away from oil if it does not also buy oil stocks. Norway has plenty of oil! “ https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-11-17/absent-regulators-and-activist-votes https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-11-17/absent-re...
- sova 9y agoFace it dude, fossil fuels are a thing of the past.
- vidarh 9y agoThat may eventually be true, but that just underlines that there are economic reasons to diversify whether or not you care about the environment.
- amontes 9y agoThe bottom line is these companies are being valued by the market based on the assumption that they'll be able to sell the barrels of oil in their proven reserves. If those reserves are "unburnable", the current valuations are not accurate, because the market for their product will be much smaller. Either they are valued correctly, or we're going to take action that prevents the worst effects of climate change - but it can't be both.
- jabretti 9y agoAnd also the present, and at least part of the future.
- grogenaut 9y agoOil isn't just about fuel. What's that computer or phone you typed this on made out of? Generally not wood, clay or pure steel.
- tryingagainbro 9y agoYup, they're already invested in oil, buying XOOM etc shares just un-diversifies (is that a word??) their investments.
- jmalicki 9y agoThe opposite of diversify in this context is usually concentrate.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dalbasal 9y agoNorway has been remarkably successful, clever and a little lucky with this sovereign wealth fund. Hedging makes sense. The funds primary source of growth is oil and oil prices, the outside money. Why carry the same risk in the portfolio itself?
- eighthnate 9y ago> So the headline and intro are fairly misleading, IMO. Pretty much Bloomberg's modus operandi when it comes to their select few pet projects.