6 ms·
I apologize for the off the wall comment. Every time I read about wall street programming, I've got this subliminal voice in the back of my head wondering how
by colordrops 9y ago
I apologize for the off the wall comment. Every time I read about wall street programming, I've got this subliminal voice in the back of my head wondering how anyone could find the motivation to do this work. I'm obviously revealing my biases against the financial industry here. Also, I'm unable to make myself do work if I don't see it contributing to some greater vision or cause. Are there people out there who love finance and learn these types of specializations on the job, or are they hired away from other industries lured by big comp packages?
I guess it's just a case of lack of empathy on my part. I just can't understand why anyone would want to put so much effort and skill into making bots for farming money for a bunch of questionable people.
I don't feel too guilty for saying this. Every time a story about bitcoin is posted to HN, people go off topic and start complaining about everything that is wrong with bitcoin. I don't see the same when we talk about finance in general, even though similar sentiments apply, maybe more so.
- tomrod 9y agoCash motivates plenty of people, as does the joy in solving a problem. Whether the value of that solution to society's benefit is positive or negative does not always factor into a solution architect's moral calculus. This is how I explain your observed point to myself when I see folks stoked to work for $largetechco or $adtechco.
- v64 9y ago> as does the joy in solving a problem This is it for me. Futures trading is a zero sum game (negative sum if you factor in fees), so writing a program to automatically extract value from an ever changing market is a nontrivial and ongoing project. But unlike a game, getting good at it can pay the bills in a real way. I understand that in the big picture long term, I'm not making much of a mark on society, but nevertheless it satisfies my personal and financial needs.
- Chyzwar 9y agoMarkets are not zero-sum game it is a common misconception. http://www.businessinsider.com/the-stock-market-is-not-a-zero-sum-game-2013-4?IR=T http://www.businessinsider.com/the-stock-market-is-not-a-zer...
- someguy12 9y agoThat quote is misleading. He's talking about perceived price. The actual price of an equity is the price at which the execution occurs. And for every execution there are two sides, hence the zero sum game is the only game in town.
- v64 9y agoThat's why I specifically called out futures trading. From [1]: > In the financial markets, options and futures are examples of zero-sum games, excluding transaction costs. For every person who gains on a contract, there is a counter-party who loses. [1] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/z/zero-sumgame.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/z/zero-sumgame.asp
- haskellandchill 9y agoYou’re comfortable enough to be ethical about your capital, for me it would be a big constraint. I’m sure I’ll get to be picky someday but that’s years from now. And at least there’s cool maths :)
- esh45y2345y 9y agoSome make a whole lot less than you and still feel ill at ease working for the finance industry when it seems to soak up so much capital and contribute so little to society
- cwperkins 9y agoThere's actually quite a lot of puzzle solving involved that makes it interesting. I think there are a lot of misconceptions of the industry at large and it suffers from bad PR after the global financial crisis. It's an interesting software problem to try and write algorithms that can earn alpha regardless of what is happening in the market. If anything computers have made our markets more efficient and it is great for price discovery. It may not be the same as creating a product or service that people love or solves a need, but it is an interesting problem to tackle.
- colordrops 9y agoSee that's the thing. I don't know what "earning alpha" means and why I should care, and working on "price discovery", which is also something I am unaware of, sounds more like a punishment than a reward.
- thibautx 9y agoPrice discovery means that anyone can find a fair price for some asset. For example, algorithms that provide liquidity in agriculture products ensure that farmers can easily liquidate their inventory, as well as hedging their risk through derivatives.
- linkmotif 9y agoI wouldn’t close your mind to it. Finance attracts “questionable people” but finance is also very interesting on many levels and is a central part of life. Work through some finance math. Calculate an IRR. See how it works. If anything there’s a lot of great human history in it.
- colordrops 9y agoThanks. I'm trying to be diplomatic here with my criticism and appreciate the positive and informative responses despite my negativity. You are right, finance is critical to social function and perhaps I've only been focusing on the negative aspects.
- log_base_login 9y agoI think it helps to understand that the financial sector provides capital that serves to energize virtually every other sector in every industry. Without finance, there is no biomedical research (private especially). Without finance, there is no aerospace advancement. Without finance, there is no alternative energy. Being able to facilitate a more liquid, more transparent financial sector is, in my opinion, a calling worthy of any programmer who seeks to make the world a better place. Your assignment of people as 'questionable' is likely an artifact of the 2007 recession, and that kind of thing is a personal choice. I can guarantee you that there are 'questionable' people in every sector and in virtually every company. Sometimes people are great, and sometimes they aren't. Their field of employment has very little to do with what makes them that way, and I think that it's a little ignorant to be so casual (and I say this because you are certainly not alone in your judgment) with how you view people. Remember how, as children, we are taught to not judge books by their covers? Why do the same with a programmer who works in finance? Sure, some of the work may be a little pedantic, like squeezing an extra millisecond out of an algorithm, but hey, that's computer science in general, and I liken that to an F1 racing team spending hour upon hour sculpting the perfect frame for their car. Sorry for the rant, I've spent a decent amount of time working on financial algorithms, and what you said touched a nerve. Have a great day!
- carterschonwald 9y agoWELL said! :) I stumbled into finance a few years ago and I’ve had overall the best bosses and work env ofanyone I know. I’m also doing a more audacious program of research engineering/ computer science than I could likely do anywhere else. I like to sometimes describe my work as some combination of “making the systems that fund aerospace at least as reliable as commercial aircraft”, as transparent as intergalactic vacuum, and easy to use to boot! Or at least that’s the idea :) On the hft front I recently started at poking at how to get accurate time on a dev computer, which gets fiddly the moment you want really interesting accuracy on commodity hardware :)
- log_base_login 9y agoThanks for the praise, and for the insight per your experience. Sounds like a great gig! I looked you up, and see that you are likely working exclusively in Haskell, but thought you might derive some value from Carl Cook's presentation on optimizing HFT code at the most recent cpp convention. I recognize the languages are distinctly different, but he provides some interesting theoretical points along the way that might be advantageous to you. Here's a link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NH1Tta7purM&feature=youtu.be https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NH1Tta7purM&feature=youtu.be Also, I can sympathize with your plight to run scalable sims. I've done some work in bioinformatics, and am building a small cluster at home so that I can learn to write code that'll scale to more massively parallel systems that are de rigueur in that domain. Cheers!
- MathCompWiz 9y agoOf course people like finance. We are not all some hippies who want to help the world. Fuck this shit. I want straight cash! And if you think people at the top of the tech industry dont think like this ur just naive as fuck. Whats not cool about a bot farming money? Its like the best thing ever looool.
- consz 9y agoAs someone who works (hard) in the part of finance you're describing, it's a mix of a few things. From a purely intellectual standpoint, it's a very hard, very interesting quantitative/modeling problem to solve (ie. predict the price N seconds in the future is non-trivial). It's an extremely competitive field (you vs. other teams like you in the world competing for a slice of the pie), and you get results back from your experiments very quickly, so you know exactly where you stand. And finally, to your following point -- >Also, I'm unable to make myself do work if I don't see it contributing to some greater vision or cause This simply is not something I experience. I've never felt any particular satisfaction from that particular aspect of a job, it's just something that never crosses my mind and incentive me in any way.
- joepanda 9y agoYou are completely ignoring the enormous value that financial activities provide for society. Efficient capital markets, risk pricing and exchange are fundamental ingredients to an effective economy. Do you think these businesses get paid for nothing?
- jasode 9y ago>farming money for a bunch of questionable people. The "questionable people" include grandparents, firemen, teachers, etc with pensions and retirement funds. >I don't see it contributing to some greater vision or cause. [...] I guess it's just a case of lack of empathy on my part. Your sentiment is common and I think it's caused by people not connecting the dots from grandparents' retirement pension to the hedge fund trader. As one example, at the micro level, grandparents are depending on a pension.[1] They also don't want their _real_ purchasing power to diminish. The "real" not "nominal" purchasing power is an important distinction because if the price of bread is $2 in 2017 but becomes $4 in 2037, they want to have adequate future money to buy food. In other words, they want their money to grow and keep up with inflation. Your grandparents stashing money in a savings account paying less than 1% will not protect their purchasing power from inflation. Likewise, the pension manager that oversees a $1 billion retirement fund to pay retired teachers will declare it bankrupt if it only gets a 1% return by buying Treasury Bills. The pension's assumptions to avoid insolvency might require 8% or better annual returns. Therefore, all these participants in the economy are looking for better returns. You can't get 8% from savings accounts and t-bills. That's where money managers like private equity, hedge funds, and VCs in Silicon Valley come in. They sell their ability to generate higher returns. This expertise attracts capital from entities like pension funds. So basically, a bunch of programmers are fine tuning algorithms because [...connect a bunch of dots...] your grandmother doesn't want to be a starving destitute and live under a bridge in her retirement years. If you multiply millions of everyday people not wanting to be destitute (macro level), you end up with hedge fund managers with billions to play with. That said, can we "reconfigure society" so that all this competitive activity of shuffling money from one pile to another isn't done? Maybe. It would involve fundamental changes that we all can't agree on. For example, if you stop inflation you can stop the incentive to generate returns that try to beat inflation; but then some would say that "deflation" would lead to people hoarding money and the economy would crash. Inflation is the current winning ideology for the modern economy. It's hard to see how we could alter society such that Wall Street traders go away. [1] for example, the $300 billion California Public Employees pension fund provides these benefits: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CalPERS#Benefits https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CalPERS#Benefits
- candiodari 9y ago
- tula 9y agoYou wouldn’t be able to type this comment on your computer (and neither would I) were it not for financial markets to organize funding for the company that produces your device. Or you might not have gotten a mortgage to buy your home. Financial markets serve a hugely important social function of allocating capital (intermediating between people who have money and those who need money).
- cm2187 9y agoFinance is a vast world and unfortunately too often reduced to pure speculation. First you have basic lending and borrowing activities. The bank can afford to pay you interest (well not now that interest rates are at zero) only because your money is invested, usually in loans. Then you have payments, cash management for companies. Then you have more complex services offered to larger companies, raising capital (equity and debt) on the market, helping them manage their risk with derivatives (interest rate, currency, commodities (oil, metals, livestock, etc prices), inflation, etc) plus some advisory on corporate actions (mergers, IPOs, etc). You have insurance, reinsurance. And then you have asset management, which you can call speculation if you want, but which is essentially people managing investment portfolios on behalf of savers, pension funds, insurance premium for long term risks, etc. With a wide variety of approaches from very conservative money market funds which invest in highly safe and liquid assets, to trackers who try to replicate a benchmark by over performing it by a little, to investments in illiquid assets (property, non listed companies) or very aggressive/leveraged strategies (hedge funds). Fundamentally what they are doing is to ensure your money gets invested wisely (at least they try). And of course all sorts of intermediaries: consultants, brokers, market data providers, research (sort of financial journalists), prime brokers (who provide financing when you leverage liquid financial assets), system providers, auditors, rating agencies, etc. Now you could call everything speculation: when a bank lends you money, it bets on your financial soundness. When an investor takes the opposite side of a commodity (say oil) transaction, it bets on the price of oil. But that allowed you to get money to run a business or to offset an oil price risk that could have made you lose money if oil increased (say your are an airline company). There is no real dinstinction between risk taking / risk transfer and speculation. But in most instances it does have a social benefit.
- mrchicity 9y agoI do HFT and think about this a lot. I am essentially a middleman that facilitates trading across: 1. Time - I quote buy and sell prices continuously in Microsoft stock trying to earn the spread between them. You want to buy stock and my offer to sell is the cheapest in the market. We trade. Later, someone else comes along to sell and I have the highest bid, so I buy the stock back from them. In between I'm exposed to price fluctuations, so sometimes I make money and sometimes I lose, but I make a profit on average by charging a spread between my buy/sell prices and predicting small price movements. The two of you could have met had you waited, but I let you lock in a sure thing by bearing risks you didn't want. Think of this like insurance. Odds are you spend more on car insurance than you're expected to receive in payments, otherwise the insurers would go out of business. But you probably prefer spending $1000 a year vs. spending $0 most years and $30000 once in your life. 2. Place - You're in the US and want to buy Nokia stock. Someone in Finland wants to sell for a cheaper price. You don't have access to the European exchanges and she doesn't have access to US exchanges, but I do. I trade against both your orders and earn a couple cents per share in profit. I helped you meet halfway across the world and also keep prices efficient to reflect global supply and demand. 3. Product - You want to invest in an index ETF that holds 40 different stocks. I quote an offer to sell based on where they're trading in the market plus a small profit margin. You buy my offer. I turn around and buy the stocks to hedge my risk. I'm better at trading than you are and have very low costs. Even considering my profit margin, it's cheaper and less risky for you to buy the ETF from me than 40 individual stocks. I keep the ETF and stock prices aligned and also helped people who wanted to sell stocks get their orders filled. Win win win. I think the work I do clearly benefits the market and natural investors. All of these trades are competitive too, so I can only earn razor thin margins per trade, or someone else will undercut me. I do sometimes question how the market picks winners and losers, typically based on speed. Is someone whose system is hundreds of nanoseconds faster more deserving of arbitrage profits? Do high technology costs naturally lead to consolidation and reduced competition? https://faculty.chicagobooth.edu/eric.budish/research/HFT-FrequentBatchAuctions.pdf https://faculty.chicagobooth.edu/eric.budish/research/HFT-Fr... this paper has some interesting thoughts on the topic. FWIW I do think continuous price-time priority trading is flawed in that it creates an arms race in speed, but it's the least bad option. Other mechanisms like batch auctions are even worse. As a thought experiment, consider the #3 ETF trade I described. If I can't immediately hedge my risk and instead go into a batch auction for each stock, how will that affect the price I offer in the ETF? PS: I do think it's a fun job. You get to play with cool technology and it's like a game that gets harder every day against very skilled opponents. Even the arms race isn't all bad. HFT firms have effectively bankrolled modern innovations in high speed ethernet, FPGAs, low latency kernel bypass networking, etc. that have knock-on benefits for other applications.
- mac01021 9y agoDoesn't this sentiment preclude you from almost every programming job? It's almost always going to be about finding the optimal way to funnel money toward whoever is in control of your employer.
- colordrops 9y agoYes, it took me about 20 years to find an employer I am happy with, and that included myself for a while in the list of those I wasn't happy with.
- mac01021 9y agoMay I ask what industry you ended up in? I assume it's something that you feel is adding value to the world?
- hopemonster 9y ago> how anyone could find the motivation to do this work There a lot of challenging problems in the finance. Some people like the problem solving and $$ > I just can't understand why anyone would want to put so much effort and skill into making bots for farming money for a bunch of questionable people Its making money for yourself as well. Many jobs in Wall Street at % of profits based rather than a fixed salary.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cleetus 9y agoMy feeling is that most criticisms of finance are based on a combination of a lack of understanding of what finance is and does, and indignation about how much money some people in the industry get paid. It's any easy target. Absolutely there are 'questionable people' in it, but are programers focused on getting users to click on more ads or spend time on a given app any better? Is tech really saving the world? There is so much more to tech than that, and most people in tech don't feel that's a fair representative of what they do. I think finance is similar, but I don't work in it so maybe I'm wrong...
- cocoablazing 9y agoMost of the quants and quant devs I work with are out-of-work physicists who want to provide for their families. Most of them would rather be tenured. I work in this industry because I cannot find employment in my field of engineering near my friends.
- golergka 9y agoI don't work in finance, but I see the modern global financial system as one of the greatest achievements of humankind and one of the main reason behind humanity's prosperity. I would love to work there if I had the skills or patience to gain them (instead, I work in gamedev, where I acquired immense domain knowledge over the years).
- sn9 9y agoTo add an angle from someone who shares your concerns about the financial industry, the high pay makes it so you can donate large amounts of money to charitable organizations of your choice. It's actually a recommended route in the effective altruism community for those with the aptitude.
- gaius 9y agoI just can't understand why anyone would want to put so much effort and skill into making bots for farming money for a bunch of questionable people. Be aware that a large part of the Internet industry consists of persuading people to click ads, in order to enrich the Saudi sovereign wealth fund. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/06/technology/unsavory-sources-money-fueling-tech.html?_r=0 https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/06/technology/unsavory-sourc... Does that float your boat?