4 ms·
> Even if it didn’t you act like ram is expensive. Everyone that complains it takes too much ram needs to get a job. Seriously ram is cheap it’s not 1970. Coul
by Fnoord 9y ago
> Even if it didn’t you act like ram is expensive. Everyone that complains it takes too much ram needs to get a job. Seriously ram is cheap it’s not 1970.
Could you explain how this rant or my job helps the amount of RAM on my phone or Raspberry Pi? Have you also ever considered that not everyone is from a first world country, able to afford the latest and greatest device with crazy amounts of RAM?
What you say is true for x86-64 desktops and servers in the first world. For everyone else, amount of RAM matters. And its you with the ostrich politics who has to stop. A quick glance at [1] suggests that, yes, you can run FreeBSD ZFS (OP was on about FreeNAS) but not without hassle.
[1] https://wiki.freebsd.org/ZFSTuningGuide https://wiki.freebsd.org/ZFSTuningGuide
- X86BSD 9y agoWhoa slow your roll willy wonka. You are contemplating a file system like ZFS for embedded devices?? Horrible idea. Horrible. Nobody said anything about the latest and greatest devices. But you clearly would not run zfs on embedded systems. You would use UFS or similar. Talk about the wrong tool for the job! Also [1] is horrendously out of date and inaccurate in regards to resource usage. And the FreeBSD universe always tends to be cautious and moderately conservative. It’s in our DNA. That doesn’t reflect anything other than were conservative and cautious.
- Fnoord 9y agoAgreed, horrible idea for the time being, but you made it seem as if ZFS could run on these low resource systems. There are certain features in ZFS which I'd love to run on embedded devices. I even remember Apple toying around with porting ZFS to macOS (back then called OSX or OS X) [1]. We're 10 years later, and only now has Apple rolled out APFS which has CoW and data integrity (yet no TimeMachine support for APFS). EDIT: to those who commented, was it ECC RAM? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ZFS#macOS_2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ZFS#macOS_2
- 2trill2spill 9y ago> Agreed, horrible idea for the time being, but you made it seem as if ZFS could run on these low resource systems. I've installed ZFS on a machine with only 1GB of ram. Yea that's a lot for an embedded device, But it's not a lot of RAM in the grand scheme of things. Was it fast, no, but it definitely worked.
- X86BSD 9y agoExactly. But it does work. I’m being down voted by the clueless brigade.
- tmikaeld 9y agoMaybe not all because of your points, but rather that HN is allergic to a preachy attitude. Try to stay objective while humble and it will work better.
- jsjohnst 9y agoAs the other commenter stated, the downvotes are most likely due to the holier than though attitude. It’s ok to be passionate and knowledgeable, but nobody wants to deal with jerks.
- Fnoord 9y agoWhen we talk about relatively small amounts of RAM its not telling a lot how much RAM the device has but rather how much RAM is devoted to ZFS. Because an Android device on 1 GB RAM is a completely different beast than a FreeNAS devoted to serving files running 1 GB RAM. The same is true for 512 MB, 2 GB, etc. PS: And was it ECC RAM?
- empthought 9y ago> PS: And was it ECC RAM? This myth seriously needs to die. ZFS does not care one whit what kind of RAM you use, any more than my other type of filesystem does. Who puts ECC RAM in a small, low-power, embedded-style system like an RPi? It makes no sense.
- radiowave 9y agoMy first ZFS install (almost 10 years ago) was on 512MB of RAM, sometimes including a Gnome 2 desktop. People get the RAM requirement thing out of proportion - yes it helps, because it's caching, and caching helps - and ZFS is a little bit heavier on metadata than other file systems (chiefly because of the checksums), but a lot of the online advice is IMO overly cautious, probably because you're giving advice to some random person on the internet and you have no real idea about how to characterize the workload that their storage system will be exposed to, and probably neither do they.
- late2part 9y agoNo, he didn't. Not to me.
- hnlmorg 9y agoI've run a 6TB pool (6x disks across 2x raidz2) on 2 GB RAM for several years. This was on desktop hardware. In fact it wasn't even an Intel CPU but some crappy AMD thing. Initially I ran Nexenta, then OpenSolaris before finally switching to FreeBSD. Network shares via Samba as well. I didn't have any performance issues for day to day stuff. Scrubs used to take a while, as did resilvering whenever I had to replace dead drives. But normal day to day operations worked fine. It was only around 5 years ago when I finally switched up to the Xeon with 32GB RAM machine I have now. Also FreeNAS is based on FreeBSD.