22 ms·
(disclosure, I work at google, and previously at YouTube) This allows a user to donate to a content creator even if that creator doesn't have any way to get ac
by joshuamorton 9y ago
(disclosure, I work at google, and previously at YouTube)
This allows a user to donate to a content creator even if that creator doesn't have any way to get access the donations. That is, until youtubers start registering themselves in the payment tool, this is essentially watching someone's video, and then throwing money into a hole.
With other patronage systems, like patreon, you cannot donate money until the creator has an account. To me, that feels super sketch.
Edit: It reminded me to go and check my old bitcointip and altcointip accounts on reddit, on which I apparently had combined closed to $30 in BTC at today's prices, but which have both been shuttered and are now inaccessible. That's not promising.
- unfunco 9y agoNot being able to donate money to someone that has no way of receiving that money seems sketch, but letting money rest in the account of a third-party that has no affiliation with the receiver is fine?
- ltc5505 9y agoI believe that they meant YouTube allowing you donate without a receiving account is sketchy compared to Patreon, but their sentence placement/spacing was poor an obfuscated their point.
- joshuamorton 9y agoAs far as I can tell, Brave is doing both. The money rests in a third party account that has no affiliation with the receiver, and they have no way of getting to it until they register. To put it succinctly, I think it's unethical for a platform to accept payment on my behalf without my permission. (whereas yeah, I don't consider holding money in escrow unethical)
- username223 9y agoYeah, seems pretty sketchy, more or less like sending money via PayPal to random email addresses in the hope that the owner checks it for money. I respect Brave for trying, but accepting money from consumers and holding it until creators sign up to receive it is not good enough.
- michaelbuckbee 9y agoThat in large part is how Paypal got started. You would get an email that said: "You were just paid $25, click here to get your money." and you'd signup for Paypal.
- angryasian 9y agoNo there was a big difference. Paypal was a referral system and the money came out of Paypal's pocket not the user sending the referral. So if the user never redeemed it was no loss to paypal.
- philsnow 9y ago> This allows a user to donate to a content creator even if that creator doesn't have any way to get access the donations. That is, until youtubers start registering themselves in the payment tool, this is essentially watching someone's video, and then throwing money into a hole. This comment reminds me of mp3sparks / allofmp3 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AllOfMP3 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AllOfMP3 , saying they're on the up and up, content creators just have to ask them for their royalties.
- Ajedi32 9y agoFair point. Brave's system is still better than just blocking all ads without offering an alternate funding mechanism for creators though; and people seem to have no problem with browser extensions that do that.
- jasonkostempski 9y agoIts not better, theres a middle man collecting money, same reason no one likes AdBlockers acceptable ad extortion scam.
- philsnow 9y agofor disclosure, I also used to work at YouTube. revshare is complicated and governed by, among other factors, deals YouTube makes with various parties. Brave doesn't have access to any of that information, so they couldn't possibly know how to split revenue between the uploader of the video and all the other parties that might have content embedded in the video, even if it were their intention to do so.
- stcredzero 9y agoAs a consumer, the direct relationship between me and the content creator is much more important to me than those other issues. Those "other parties" other issues are actually between the various content creators, sponsors, and platform providers, and aren't really my problem. I'm quite tired of those other parties interposing themselves into my relationship with creators.
- fixermark 9y agoRight, but as a consumer, you don't have to deal with the ramifications of the other parties failing to be paid, a scenario which generally results in the content creator having their content pulled for incorrect / unauthorized (re-)use.
- stcredzero 9y agoRight, but as a consumer, you don't have to deal with the ramifications of the other parties failing to be paid Such issues came up in the old days, but they were settled without interposing themselves directly in my life. Back in the 90's, my music collection didn't start partially disappearing because of these things.
- wolco 9y agoWhy would they split anything with youtube sponsers or care about deals they are not a party to. That's youtube's business. In those cases the content creator is paid by two parties.
- Ajedi32 9y agoThe money doesn't go "into a hole". The funds are saved and a creator can retrieve them at any time once they sign up for an account: https://brave.com/publishers/#getverified https://brave.com/publishers/#getverified Basically, it's their money, and whether they decide to withdraw it or not is entirely up to them. IMO this is the right way to do it because it solves the chicken and egg problem that would normally exist with a universal funding method like this. Users don't have to worry about what payment platforms their favorite creators support; they can just browse the web like normal and the platform takes care of the rest.
- joshuamorton 9y agoIt's thrown into a hole in exactly the same way that my $30 I tipped btc is not mine, because I never got it out of the system. Edit: I said it better in response to a sibling of yours: I think it's unethical for a platform to accept payment on my behalf without my permission.
- ProAm 9y agoIt's thrown into an account that the creator can retrieve at anytime. A hole incorrectly insinuates it's never retrievable. This is a good way to get away from Googles monetization handcuffs.
- joshuamorton 9y agoSee my edit, if you didn't already, but there exist services that already do that. The asymmetry created by this kind of "pay me without my permission" means that someone providing a service now has to do a lot of extra work if they want to get paid, whereas a user who wants to pay someone doesn't. That's not a good system if your goal is really to get money to creators.
- ProAm 9y agoI still feel the benefits outweigh the risks of being at the whim of Google's inscrutable changes.
- slewis 9y agoBrave could return the payment if it’s not collected after some time.
- four-yellow 9y agoExcept they won't: "Where does my contribution go if a publisher/website is not part of this program yet? When there is about $100.00 USD in BAT for a specific publisher, from all contributors, Brave makes three attempts to complete the publisher verification process. We will hold unclaimed funds for a minimum of 90 days, after which it will be added to the UGP (User Growth Pool)." https://brave.com/faq-payments/#formal-terms-conditions https://brave.com/faq-payments/#formal-terms-conditions
- wmeredith 9y agoThat’s pretty toxic if you ask me. They’re monetizing others’ content for their user growth.
- relatedarea 9y agoHey, better than ads.
- rplnt 9y agoToo bad content creators put ads directly into the videos.
- trumpownsyou420 9y agopeep the google shill. kys libturd.
- mtgx 9y agoIt incentivizes people to use it, though. This is how Bitcoin gained adoption in the early days, too. As for the "thrown away money", that's people's business if they want to do it with a relative chance of the author gaining that money.
- hoofish 9y agowhat's more Brave cuts off the monetization the channels are getting in USD from YT ads. Not good for YT channels, and unclear how it is good for the user other than "hey we figured out a way to cheat the system so you don't have to watch ads!"
- alexnewman 9y agoDon’t worry brave handle that’s case with a refund.
- JohnTHaller 9y agoI'm now collecting for every charity in existence even though I don't have a relationship with any of them. All they have to do is contact me to retrieve the funds.
- timthelion 9y agoI have a bot that creates a new meta-charity every 3 seconds which does the same.
- CryptoPunk 9y agoBitcointip was taken over by Changetip. I believe you can recover your balance at https://changetip.com https://changetip.com
- joshuamorton 9y agoThe most important thing to come out of this. Thanks for the tip!
- CryptoPunk 9y agoYou're most welcome!
- pryelluw 9y agoIt does give whoever holds the funds a good deal of float from which they can earn interest. Which is why I have a feeling this has the potential to become the norm.
- monk_e_boy 9y agoAnd who are not regulated like a bank. Final Tweet: "Ooops we invested all your money. Now it's gone. :("
- gotrecruit 9y agoisn't that how paypal worked/works?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- whathaschanged 9y agoThrowing money into a hole is pretty much how the BMI/ASCAP music scheme works for artists who aren't part of their protection racket. Patreon is worse at this point because they have already demonstrated they will seize and/or not distribute funds to accounts they dislike. That's one step above Paypal levels of horrible business practices.
- mc32 9y agoDoes this provide an end around content creators who get demonetized, sometimes for arguably good reasons, other times seemingly political reasons?