4 ms·

Gerrit: https://www.gerritcodereview.com https://www.gerritcodereview.com. Hands-down.

• chrisjshull 9y ago
  I’d warn against Gerrit. From the best my team has been able to figure out, Gerrit encourages a development flow that breaks the golden rule of rebase and treats all pushes as force pushes. The result is that in a collaborative environment your changes are occasionally reset by someone else pushing changes. (To my eye Gerrit seems like it was written by people who wanted git to work like svn.)
  • zwily 9y ago
    You can configure Gerrit to cherry-pick, and I believe the default is to do a merge.
  • khazhou 9y ago
    They've set it up wrong. I use Gerrit in a large team and have never seen that problem. Force push is explicitly disabled in our config.
• arjun27 9y ago
  What do you like about it?
• usr1106 9y ago
  We tried to introduce it at work 2-3 years ago. We never got over a pilot installation. It seems rather challenging to install/configure into an existing automatic build system, because gerrit wants to be its own git server(?), but the implementation/hooks are not compatible with "normal" git. Didn't work with that part, so don't remember the details. The UI did not feel very intuitive, might be quite a learning curve.