4 ms·
> The spillover is very real, just not on the same site. Which is good - concentrate the hate speech into a single place and then take it down.
by zimpenfish 9y ago
> The spillover is very real, just not on the same site.
Which is good - concentrate the hate speech into a single place and then take it down.
- ema 9y agoHow would that help? It's not exactly rocket science to open up yet another reddit clone for the untouchables afterwards.
- zimpenfish 9y agoSure but a registrar / hoster that has just closed one hate site isn't going to let someone spin up another immediately. And soon enough they'll be out of options.
- tambienben 9y agoYour brazen support of censorship is troubling.
- flunhat 9y agoWhy?
- zimpenfish 9y agoIf my earnest support for silencing Nazis, the alt-right, PUAs, MRAs, climate change deniers, woo peddlers et al troubles you, perhaps you need to start examining your own beliefs and figure out why you don't want them silenced.
- sintaxi 9y agoCensorship doesn't work. We must beat poor ideas with good ones. What happens if they are the ones who end up with the power to silence?
- abiox 9y agohelp what? is it a bad thing for reddit if other 'reddit clones' exist around certain worldviews?
- tscs37 9y agoWhat if you can't take it down? What if they end up on Tor? And tbh, this does sound very aggressive and Nazi-like; round up the [group we don't like] and exterminate. It's quite a hateful philosphy to have.
- pwinnski 9y agoRefusing to provide a free platform for them to publish their thoughts is not in any way, shape, or form equivalent to, or even similar to, the "extermination" committed by Nazis, and desired by their modern adherents.
- tscs37 9y agoThe way it was phrased, it definitely was. And especially as a german I am not comfortable with some of the solutions proposed in this entire thread.
- zimpenfish 9y ago> as a german Your country has literally banned Nazis, mentions of Nazis, symbols of Nazis, etc. Hell, even Twitter blocks Nazis in Germany. Has it descended down the slippery slope into authoritarian disaster?
- tscs37 9y agoNo, mainly because only literal Nazis are banned. You may hold any opinion which does not violate the dignity of humans, no matter right or left. And we do have a fairly active right and far right.
- flunhat 9y agoSave your energy - they just think that reddit banning a pro-racism community or a internet infra company refusing to serve a neo-nazi website basically means that we live in an authoritarian society. Never mind that the slippery slope argument is a known logical fallacy, never mind that these companies are private entities and can do what they like, never mind that if Nazis ever gain power they will literally, physically exterminate people they don't like, never mind that people are still free to express their own views on public platforms, never mind all of that. Ugh. The only consolation is that these communities are being censored, taken offline, and driven onto platforms where they cannot reach nearly as many people as before, and that this will continue to happen, no matter what HN libertarians say. And that the tech community is not nearly a-ok with hosting racist speech as HN would make you believe. We are moving forward, and what you're seeing is a last-ditch reaction to pro-racism, neo-nazi communities being marginalized.
- dethswatch 9y ago> then take it down. Love this idea! But I get to decide what's permitted and what's not. We're going to start with art that I don't understand, then off to literature that I don't care for, when all of that filth is cleaned out, it's on to expressions of thought that everyone intuitively knows are wrong, then we progress to purge politics of incompatible policy and incorrect voting patterns. Ok?
- flunhat 9y agoThat's the slippery slope logical fallacy. You've ignored the possibility that a meaningful middle ground exists.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dethswatch 9y agoOk- I'll tell you what. In compromise toward the middle-ground, I'll only eliminate art that I don't value. With some simple common-sense, I think we can really fix the art world.
- zimpenfish 9y ago> But I get to decide what's permitted and what's not What are your credentials for this job?
- dethswatch 9y agoMy subjective, but firmly-held opinions, naturally.