3 ms·
But... there was a great deal of discussion about this. You can still find the threads here, every possible aspect of this was argued up and down. It doesn't re
by krapp 9y ago
But... there was a great deal of discussion about this. You can still find the threads here, every possible aspect of this was argued up and down. It doesn't require an "extreme" approach to disagree with him or his assertions, although it is true that most people who agreed with, or disagreed with, Damore's essay didn't bother to actually read it, or engage with the content. The extremists showed up first, as they tend to, and strawman fought strawman for the high ground, then came the more reasoned, well-researched and thought out criticisms.
Google, however, is a business and isn't obligated to "reach a consensus" on anything, or to try to convince an employee about anything regarding their political views. What Google did was a business decision, because the bad publicity his essay created and its effect on Google's work environment.
- abnry 9y agoWe still need to remember that Google bills itself as a company open to new and challenging ideas. Leadership matters and even if the decision to fire was based purely on publicity and work environment concerns, Google showed it cares more about a certain ideology and keeping its employees happy in their ideology than actually having debate.
- krapp 9y agoIt is possible that Google is hypocritical in that the public culture it projects doesn't match its actual corporate culture, but they would hardly be the first company for which that was the case. But it's also possible that Damore wouldn't have been fired if the memo he published hadn't gone viral. I don't know one way or the other but that seemed to me to be more about damage control than suppression of political views.