2 ms·
That's an uncharitable reading of the article you posted. Netflix pushes so much traffic that any company they buy transit from ends up using up all the good wi
by Spivak 9y ago
That's an uncharitable reading of the article you posted. Netflix pushes so much traffic that any company they buy transit from ends up using up all the good will of the people they have peering agreements with.
> Netflix attempted to address congested routes into Comcast by purchasing all available transit capacity from transit providers that did not pay access fees to Comcast.
And Netflix apparently knew they couldn't afford the traffic if they actually had to pay for it so they tried to route around it. And when they saturated those connections they had the audacity to tell Comcast it was their fault and they should foot the bill for infrastructure upgrades.
Netflix went to an all-you-can-eat restaurant, ordered two of everything on the menu, complained that the food didn't come out fast enough, tried to pay everyone else in restaurant for their seats, and then demanded the restaurant hire more chefs.
> “it is simply not possible for competing external providers to deliver gaming, or streaming video services to Comcast’s broadband subscribers” without directly or indirectly paying Comcast"
Well no shit since any company providing those services is going to push so much asymmetric traffic that either they or the companies they buy transit from are not going to be able to negotiate settlement-free peering agreements.
This isn't a "I send you some traffic, you send me some, no biggie" kind of agreement, this is a "I'm going to use 70-90% of your bandwidth at peak".
This article is trying really hard to paint Comcast as the bad guys but I actually don't think that's the case here. Netflix/Cogent had a similar spat with Verizon.
> What are you talking about?
I'm saying that allowing companies to price by volume and on/off-peak is really just a surcharge for streaming video which could be used to hurt competitors. It's not really a solution. So I think we're in agreement.
> You said it was NOT POSSIBLE...
I think we need to agree on what 'dumb' means. Connections between networks are inherently political no matter what entity presides over the negotiations. And since network access is a shared resource there will always be a need for network management policies to maintain service, respond to incidents, prevent spam, stop attacks, etc.. Both of these things make networks 'smart'.