4 ms·
The video is amazing, but let's be honest: fluid motion without falling is something you can expect from a minimum wage employee. And big robots are physical m
by ajross 9y ago
The video is amazing, but let's be honest: fluid motion without falling is something you can expect from a minimum wage employee. And big robots are physical machines that are likely to cost rather more than a minimum wage scrub to hire/acquire and pay/maintain.
This is a different world from, say, machine learning. It's equally true that we're just now reaching the point where ML is as good as we are at recognizing photos of our children or transcribing our voice mail. But those ML algorithms can be deployed at cloud scale for pennies, so it's worthwhile where physical things aren't yet.
- FriedPickles 9y agoThere's one proven application of this technology: entertainment.
- krapp 9y ago> fluid motion without falling is something you can expect from a minimum wage employee. And big robots are physical machines that are likely to cost rather more than a minimum wage scrub to hire/acquire and pay/maintain Fluid motion without falling, along with a lot of physical activities, turn out to be very hard problems both for robotics and AI[0]. So yes, while the applications may not be as potentially far reaching as with machine learning, as a technological achievement getting a bipedal robot to do a backflip is more impressive. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moravec%27s_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moravec%27s_paradox
- ajross 9y agoTrust me, I know. I was answering the question of why a solution to a very hard problem in one space sees pervasive application, and a similarly impressive solution in robotics gets no interest beyond backfliping robots on youtube.
- Johnny555 9y agoAnd big robots are physical machines that are likely to cost rather more than a minimum wage scrub to hire/acquire and pay/maintain Is that true? And if it is, will it remain true for long? To staff a position with humans 24x7x365 would cost over $100K/year ($7.25x24x365 = $65K, add in overhead and you get to $100K+ easily). If you can buy a robot to do the job for $100K, plus $1K/month for a maintenance contract), then you break even after the first 13 - 14 months. Add a year if the robot costs $200K. I don't know what these robots will cost, an industrial robot arm is in the $50-$200K range (or higher).
- carterehsmith 9y agoYeah, I guess that they are still looking for the killer app. For a while, it looked like they could be deployed as military mules; but they were too loud (due to the internal combustion engine) for that purpose. So, what can they do? Meantime, for $7.25/hour, you can hire a human that (hopefully) understands spoken words, and can do jobs requiring fine hand motor skills, e.g. pick-and-pack in warehouse, or serve meals and drinks, stock shelves, flip burgers etc. Boston Dynamics robot cannot do any of that. It can walk over difficult terrain, and flip, but who needs that? Perhaps they should focus on the "hands/arms" parts (as opposed to legs). Industrial robots don't use legs, they are fine with wheels and rails. Also legs are not really what stands apart - cheetahs and horses and mice can use their legs better than humans, but so what. What matters is hands - opposable thumbs, and so on.
- kayoone 9y ago> Boston Dynamics robot cannot do any of that Yet. It's clear that they are not aiming for a commercial product anytime soon, this is ongoing research and the progress over the last decade has been huge and will only accelerate.
- empath75 9y agoSeems like the first use will be working on dangerous environments.
- carterehsmith 9y agoThere are already robots being used for mine sweeping, bomb disposal, nuclear reactor inspection, even mars rovers. They all make do with just wheels, or sometimes rails. It is not clear if adding legs to the above robots would make them any better.
- brohee 9y agoLegs can access an order of magnitude more terrain than wheels. Think looking for survivors in rubble after an earthquake.
- carterehsmith 9y agoI think a simple drone can make this use case much easier.
- melling 9y agoWho said their market was to replace minimum wage workers? You made that up then tried to convince us that it’s a bad idea.
- simplyluke 9y agoBingo. Their market is the DoD and anyone said department will let them sell to. The fair comparison isn't $10/hour workers, it's the entire cost of training, equipping, and employing a soldier (even in non-combat roles) and/or current military tech such as drones.
- ajross 9y agoI did no such thing. I said their market was not billion-plus consumer applications as the case with much ML research, and that this might explain some of the lack of commercial interest mentioned upthread. I won't take a position as to whether this robot is a "bad idea". But pretty much anyone can see that (relative to the problem difficulty) it's a "worse idea" than, say, photo recognition.