2 ms·
> In general, I think if it's the case that you can't reasonably defend a view you don't agree with then there's a very good chance you don't understand it. Wh
by shkkmo 9y ago
> In general, I think if it's the case that you can't reasonably defend a view you don't agree with then there's a very good chance you don't understand it.
While I appreciate this sentiment, it really only applies to arguments that are being made in good faith.
Pai may be saying "rules should be written as necessary instead of creating an enormous rule book based entirely on today's tech.", which is a supportable position that I can reasonably defend despite not agreeing with.
However, the action they are taking includeds removing any legal ability for the FCC to write and enforce these rules. Now congress can create these types rules without the FCC having title II authority, but relying on congress to write the rules as needed in response in innovation is going to be MUCH SLOWER to respond to innovation and bad behavior than giving the FCC the authority to adjust and enforce rules as necessary.
> What he actually says, and the implications of the headlines and comments snipped by third party organizations tend to be quite different indeed!
This is because what they say they are doing (and why) is quite different from the actual actions and motivations.
Pai keeps saying "we've got to remove title II to help small ISPs", yet the is the big ISPs that are constantly pushing for it's removal, Title II was put in place to regulate large monopolies just like them (Ma Bell), and many small ISPs actually favor maintaining Title II status. It is hard to take someone's arguments in good faith when they consistently misrepresent the issues.
> If the throughput for these systems starts to become an issue would it be so unreasonable for them to throttle or block sites consuming disproportionate resources?
Yes it is unnecessary. If they can't scale those systems to match supply to demand, they can increase the amount charged to limit that demand to match supply. Giving them
> Maybe the most basic argument is that it should be clear that net neutrality has not really achieved anything. Many people seem to think we always had net neutrality and stripping it away is some radical shift.
We have had network neutrality (mostly anyways) for a long time and proponents argue that net neutrality (and it's resulting competition) is what has caused the internet to innovate as such an amazingly rapid pace. That neutrality was not enshrined by law in the US until 2015 but that doesn't mean that the principle itself wasn't being followed by convention.
I hope your misleading arguments were made in good faith rather that being a deliberate attempt to mislead people like so much of the anti net neutrality rhetoric. (There is misleading pro net neutrality rhetoric too but I see more proponents making good faith arguments)