3 ms·
>> The article explains that the setup only allows choices to do optional actions, and it is assumed the players always do them. As "programming" human players
by YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago
>> The article explains that the setup only allows choices to do optional actions, and it is assumed the players always do them. As "programming" human players to simulate a Turing machine would be too easy, they are replaced by mindless placeholders.
Yes, I read that bit - I didn't realise it was meant to make things "harder". That alone is good enough to convince me the proof is unnecessary. If you can make a proof easier, then you make it easier. There's no need for harder proofs.
Also, the fact that the proof does not involve human actions is another piece of evidence against the generality of the proof. You can model human choices as a distribution and allow for a fully-automated proof, that doesn't require human input in the strict sense. But leaving human actions out of the proof makes it less general- because the full game does involve such actions.