10 ms·
How does the Japanese system live with the stuff that plagues Western transportation systems? For example in Munich there is nearly every day one or more huuug
by mschuster91 9y ago
How does the Japanese system live with the stuff that plagues Western transportation systems?
For example in Munich there is nearly every day one or more huuuge delays due to:
- people on the track (sprayers, drunkards, people whose phone fell down)
- animals on the track, ranging from stray dogs over wolves to deer - and in some cases, entire herds of sheep... one caused an ICE to derail and destroy a huge amount of tunnel track in the progress once.
- suicides (1.000 suicides in Germany per year, and that's only the successful ones)
- accidents on street crossings (okay, that's eliminated on the highspeed tracks, but regional traffic and metro rails suffer often enough)
- kids letting balloons loose in the underground sections, where they shorten out the power line, sometimes causing major destruction - and occasionally it's a bird that does the same and ends up grilled
- absolute morons who do not make room for people trying to exit the train
- people with disabilities (wheelchair users, but also old people who simply have problems moving!), who sometimes need to be attended by the conductor, e.g. to put out a ramp
- technical breakdowns
However, in Japan this seems to be nearly unheard of.
- acchow 9y agoA visit to Japan will be eye opening for you. The culture is unlike anywhere else I have ever seen.
- kysol 9y agoEvery time I've returned from Japan, I've always felt compelled to do my best where every I could. Sounds cheesy, but there is something about how well everything runs and has a place that makes you feel energised. がんばって ^^
- mirceal 9y agothe answer is in the question. Except for the technical breakdowns, all the other are caused by people. People stop doing stupid shit -> train can be on time. It's a cultural problem mostly. In Japan, you don't do the stupid shit (or you do it in private) and in exchange the train is on time. Every day!
- k_sh 9y agoHaving disabilities, animals damaging infrastructure, garden-variety traffic accidents, and suicides are all classified as "stupid shit"?
- drakonandor 9y agoYes.
- syncsynchalt 9y agoNo comment on "stupid shit" but culturally Japan has taken action to curtail things like rail suicide: https://www.irishtimes.com/news/health/families-fined-for-suicides-in-japan-1.1104002 https://www.irishtimes.com/news/health/families-fined-for-su...
- mirceal 9y agodid not mean it to be offensive. "stupid shit" is more like socially unacceptable in this context.
- kelnos 9y agoMost train stations and tracks in Japanese cities are difficult to access if you're an animal, and tracks are all either underground or elevated, so traffic accidents don't come into the picture. Another commenter suggested that they can clear out a suicide in under 10 minutes, something that will take over an hour, at least in the SF bay area. If you get far out of a city, things seem to be held to less of a strict standard, but trains still run frequently and mostly on time. I've never witnessed someone with a disability getting on or off a Japanese train, so I can't speak to that.
- jwr 9y agoOh, they do have some of these problems. The Chuo line (中央線, Chūō-sen) in Tokyo used to be famous for suicides. People would avoid the line, because it was quite probable that there would be delays. But in general the trains run really well, and an avoidable mistake is really rare.
- razakel 9y agoIIRC the relatives of people who commit suicide on Japanese railways are charged for the disruption caused.
- conanbatt 9y ago!!!! "The best way to stop people from buying a gun, is to kill a puppy once each time is sold"
- microcolonel 9y ago> "The best way to stop people from buying a gun, is to kill a puppy once each time is sold" That seems like it would ensure that the only people who buy guns are those with no regard for innocent life. I think you've invented the most perverse incentive ever devised.
- philipov 9y ago> That seems like it would ensure that the only people who ... are those with no regard for ... Sounds like what it takes to make it in politics.
- microcolonel 9y agoKilling puppies is probably one of the few things that would disqualify you from office.
- conanbatt 9y agoEach disposal of a puppy has to be maintained and paid by a tax on people that have no pets
- lomnakkus 9y agoThis is one of those things that I heard on QI[1] that seems really plausible -- thus I did not fact check it -- but I'm not sure if it's just because of my Western cultural bias and prejudices. Is it well attested/documented? [1] Which, I think, should mostly be considered "entertainment" rather than particularly correct, though I do believe that they actually do strive for correctness. It's more that it has turned into a sort of "twist the words" game -- which is a shame.[2] [2] It seems to have gained a little bit of a second wind with Toksvig in the current season -- as a sort of a more chat-about-random-things-prompted-by-question-X type thing. Which is nice. (Disclaimer: Only 2 episodes in.)
- cmurf 9y agoWestern countries are more heterogeneous, more individualistic, and that includes highly variable selfishness and cluelessness. Japan is an island nation, much more isolated, homogeneous, people are much more on the same page about things often even without having explicit conversations about it. Somewhere in between, Scandinavian countries. I think it's helpful to say "move, sloth" when people stand on the left side of an escalator, for example. That would be really insulting in Japan, but also it wouldn't ever be necessary. Actually, it's not even necessary in say, London. But in the U.S. there is absolutely zero imagination that someone might want to walk up an escalator, it simply does not even occur to most people. My favorite: train is full, some people have to get out in order make room for people to get out, and then a bunch of assholes on the platform try to get into the train before the people who got out to make room but intend to get back on. And then these freeloading morons get all pissy when called out for their bullshit. Yes, morons. Like really selfish clueless morons. Again, I sometimes find it useless to ask them if they're stupid. It's somewhat polite, I'm not calling them stupid, and in my delusions I think they might ponder whether they are in fact stupid. But deep down I know I'm wrong, they're so stupid, they will not reflect on their stupidity or ever improve. shrug
- zardo 9y ago>I think it's helpful to say "move, sloth" when people stand on the left side of an escalator, for example. That would be really insulting in Japan... Is there a place that wouldn't be insulting? Maybe Costa Rica.
- cmurf 9y agoActually, it's an insult to sloths. A sloth can and does move, just deliberately and slowly. Able bodied people who stand on the escalator, don't move at all, are lazy. And when they're standing on the wrong side, they're wastes of space. As in the space they are taking up, is more useful than they are. Sloths are badass.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- morsch 9y agoIt's a media trope, and I have little reason to doubt it, but it's surprisingly hard to come up with decent statistics on average delays and punctuality for Japanese public transport beyond the Shinkansen (average delay < 1 minute). DB (Germany) publishes a monthly average: https://www.bahn.de/p/view/service/auskunft/puenktlichkeit_personenverkehr.shtml https://www.bahn.de/p/view/service/auskunft/puenktlichkeit_p... As does OEBB (Austria): http://www.oebb.at/de/rechtliches/puenktlichkeit-oesterreich http://www.oebb.at/de/rechtliches/puenktlichkeit-oesterreich SNCF (France) has excellent data available: https://ressources.data.sncf.com/explore/dataset/ponctualite-mensuelle-transilien/ https://ressources.data.sncf.com/explore/dataset/ponctualite... The statistics from SBB (Switzerland) are worse than I would have expected: http://sbb-puenktlichkeitskarte.mxm.ch/?lang=1 http://sbb-puenktlichkeitskarte.mxm.ch/?lang=1 Roughly in line with the rest, but as I understand they designed their timetable to make sure that people can make their connection, and they report a figure[1] that does bear that out: https://reporting.sbb.ch/en/quality https://reporting.sbb.ch/en/quality Maybe somebody who speaks Japanese can find something similar for Japanese trains. One thing I did find is the list for delay certificates of the Tokyo Metro. It's obviously not on time, all the time, "passenger arrengement staff"[2] nonwithstanding: http://www.tokyometro.jp/lang_en/delay/history/ginza.html http://www.tokyometro.jp/lang_en/delay/history/ginza.html [1] "Customer-weighted connection punctuality", I do not pretend to understand what exactly that means [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pusher_(railway_station_attendant) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pusher_(railway_station_attend...
- mschuster91 9y ago> Roughly in line with the rest, but as I understand they designed their timetable to make sure that people can make their connection Hmm. Maybe that's something that's missed in the beancounter-ish environment of today's transportation networks... to allow for "slack times". Basically, have the train spend a minute more per station so there is always some inherent amount of time that can be used for stuff like a wheelchair user or a horde of kindergarden kids without impacting everyone else... IIRC something similar was attempted and then rejected at a local bus line, because it would have meant to hire another driver and a bus, and the beancounters said it's too expensive.
- matt4077 9y agoThis is possibly a stereotype, but I've read that the rail companies discourage people from suicide-by-train with the argument that they'd inconvenience society. (...which is awfully close to my (possibly equally stereotypical) opinion of why Japan has a suicide problem)
- kunimu 9y agoNot only that, but popular stations have barriers which are erected between the platform and the track. Whether these are there to prevent suicide or merely stop someone from falling onto the track, I don't know.
- microcolonel 9y agoNote: this is not about delays, it's about departing early. A delayed departure can have knock on effects (missing your next train), but an early departure can have immediate effects (not making it on to the train).
- marak830 9y agoI can't give you a link to official figures, but from living there 6 years I can answer a few questions. Suicide: by train isn't uncommon, but if they have to delay one line, there are similar lines people can use to route around the area (usually, and to great discomfort). People on the track: I have only seen this once, aside from workers and they know the schedules and have watchers to make sure the lines are clear. Morons not moving: pretty hard Todo that with the sheer mass of bodies moving out ;) also there is a system everyone adopts, on the outside everyone lines up in two lines outside the carriage doors, and let's the train empty, before attempting to get in. Its quite amazing how well it works.
- madamelic 9y ago>there is a system everyone adopts, on the outside everyone lines up in two lines outside the carriage doors, and let's the train empty, before attempting to get in. I would make a joke but it is interesting how having a culture that values the whole rather than the individual influences how they use public transportation. In NJ/NYC, I stand away from the door and people actually shove in front of me and through people getting off.
- lstamour 9y agoI don't know how much of it is culture exactly -- I find at Toronto's Bloor-Yonge station that people often do this -- they line up in two columns by the doors to let folks off before entering. I won't say it's done perfectly, but regular commuters seem to know it, here. It makes sense from a self-interest perspective: the faster you clear a path and allow folks off, the faster you can get on before the doors start closing. All bets are off at most other stations in Toronto though, they're often not busy enough for it to become an expected behaviour.
- Zancarius 9y agoAlthough it's been years since I've been overseas, I recall seeing similar behavior in Australia (no idea if it's changed; I doubt it). People waiting to board the train would let the people on the train disembark before attempting to board themselves. I'd imagine anyone forcing their way on would be met with an unwelcome reception. As you said, it's just common sense.
- mmanfrin 9y ago- absolute morons who do not make room for people trying to exit the train The lowest circle of hell is reserved for these people and bike thieves (and a few others).
- foxyv 9y ago...and people who stick gum underneath tables/chairs.
- unabst 9y agoThere is the cultural thing, but Japanese transit is also extremely well staffed to the point where any anomalies are caught and dealt with preemptively. It's endless city rail for the most part, and there are no true gaps until you're fairly far. During rush hour they have white gloved attendants pushing people in doors and confirming no hanging luggage or limbs, etc. Shinkansen tracks are also often suspended or walled in. In Tokyo you'll also often see signs apologizing for delays, but since the trains are still arriving every 2 minutes, it won't make a difference to you or your schedule whether that specific train is off schedule. Another factor is that many lines share tracks also. This means everything needs to be on time, or else they won't mesh. Even on one line you'll have various flavors of express that overtake slower trains on the same rail at stations... meaning they have to be on time. Of course, none of this is cheap, and neither are the tickets. It's not uncommon to find plane tickets cheaper than Shinkansen tickets. And even going 3 stations from Shibuya to Shinjuku will cost you 2 dollars on the Yamanote line. You could easily spend 10 dollars a day on a daily basis just getting around the city, and multiply that by the number of people who use the system, and it's a fortune.
- rootsudo 9y agoIf you get the Tokyo Metro pass, it's 800 JPY 1 day/1500 JPY 3 day you can alleviate the cost. You can also register a popular route you use and get it highly discounted w/ passmo/suica.
- unabst 9y agoAnything on your commute you will buy a pass for. But Tokyo Metro isn't JR or Odakyu. Transfers get expensive. And all fares are by distance. Any commuter passes are based on point A to point B also. They have a Japan Rail Pass that allows for almost unlimited travel within Japan, but you have to be a visitor from a foreign country. But I hear it's one of the best ways to tour Japan. Their trains are quite awesome.
- kelnos 9y agoYeah, I did he JR Pass a year ago, and it was $249 for 7 days. I did some math after the trip, and if I had't had the pass, my Shinkansen bill would have been nearly 2x that. Plus I saved a bit here and there (on the order of $30) since I could use the local JR rail for free. The only transit expenses while there were when JR didn't have a convenient line and I had to use Tokyo Metro or the local trains in Kyoto and Osaka.
- hinkley 9y ago- people keeping the doors from closing When I was in Tokyo I witnessed on two occasions a man try to dive through the doors at the last minute and get caught. The doors do not open again. Both men were in clearly obvious levels of pain, trying to get their arms or legs back. I for one had no intention of repeating their experiment. Warning to others: successful. You get a cue that the door is going to close. They close about 10%, open again, and then slam shut. That’s the only warning you get (there may have been a beep too) but it’s really the only one you need. They also have herders during peak traffic that either shove you in or warn you off. Like traffic cops but for the trains.
- Deimorz 9y agoI had trouble getting a large hard-shell suitcase onto a train in Tokyo once, and didn't quite get it inside before the doors closed on it. They crushed it so strongly that it cracked before I could pull it through. I absolutely wouldn't ever want to get any part of my body caught in there.
- uremog 9y agoJapanese train suicide crews are actually so fast that they can clear the train to continue in 7 minutes. Otherwise, they take train transportation VERY seriously. It is their main mode of transportation both local and in-country long-distance.
- mikekchar 9y agoI think the thing most people are missing is that the lack of delays is due to having a system that has few delays :-) When I lived near London, my morning train into London had the following performance record: 75% of trains arrived within 10 minutes of schedule, 95% of trains that weren't involved in a cancellation arrived within 10 minutes of schedule. "Involved in a cancellation" means that either the train was cancelled, or was late because a previous cancellation made it late. So this means that more than 20% of the trains on the line were late directly due to cancellations (which is a horrible statistic -- my line was one of the worst). But even when you think of that terrible statistic, when the next train comes -- there is not enough room. Because the platforms are not long enough and/or the signalling equipment can't handle it, they can only run trains of a certain length. When a train is cancelled, then it causes mayhem down the line as people cram to get on the trains to get to work. If you have 5 trains an hour, you only have to get to a delay of 12 minutes before you need to cancel a train. It all snowballs. Basically, what I'm saying is that it's not like Japan doesn't have all the problems you've stated, it's that they realise that if they don't deal with the problems quickly the entire system breaks down. As others have said, some of it is cultural (Japan is a rule following culture so if you put up signs saying "This is the rule", then by and large people will follow it). But other things are just that the train companies realise that it is more than worth their while to pay for solutions to small problems in order to avoid the snowball effect. For example: - There is a guard on the platform almost all the time. My dad actually dropped his bag on the tracks once and the guard quickly and efficiently retrieved it. - They have equipment to inspect and clear the tracks. They use it regularly. Japan does not have large herds of animals in general, so animals are less of a problem it seems. But the shinkansen has very large fences all along the length and the track is regularly patrolled. My mother in law lives near the shinkansen tracks and I've seen them patrol the tracks several times a day. - Virtually every street crossing is controlled. This makes a big difference. - People with disabilities are looked after by guards at the station, not the conductor. When you go through the gates, you can ask for a wheelchair. The guard will go and get one. They will accompany you to the platform and make sure you get on the train. They will call ahead to your destination and a guard will meet you to take you off the train. Also, it's important to understand that the platforms in Japan are almost universally perfect so getting on and off the train is very easy. - Technical breakdowns are rare because they spend money on maintenance. However, in the UK, I recall hearing that many of the problems are due to people stealing copper wire from the switching equipment to sell as scrap copper. Again, this is a cultural thing -- that kind of crime is just incredibly rare in Japan. Trains are relatively expensive (about the same as the UK), but the main answer to your question is that they are managed really well. They use the money efficiently to stop small problems becoming big problems.