4 ms·
That is an excellent summary and why the solution should be Federal law and not a State law. The EU model would work well in that case. However, the actors (St
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
That is an excellent summary and why the solution should be Federal law and not a State law. The EU model would work well in that case.
However, the actors (States) aren't exactly operating in a reasonable way. What I speculate is the case is that people who you can obligate to pay taxes and yet cannot vote on those taxes make the best targets. Taxation without representation has been a sore spot for quite a long time :-).
The key here is the business license. By requiring it, the State, County, and City all get a bite at the Apple and can add their own level of tithe to the requirements. Whether it is that you meet their ADA requirements, their street address requirements, or their officer disclosure requirements, all things to generate revenue from "business" which when that business is out of state become exceptionally burdensome.
Again, the only solution I can see is a Federal law that can supercede any local law when the subject party is not a resident in the same jurisdiction. But they states will lobby very hard against that happening.
- Spooky23 9y agoAmazon and the third party sellers aren’t being taxed. The consumers are. Amazon could setup a big warehouse complex in South Dakota or something and avoid this problem — but they want to benefit from local distribution.
- xxgsdzfwser 9y agoNo, the businesses are taxed, and they pass the cost to the consumer. The "sales tax" itemization the end of the receipt is for informational purposes only.
- ghaff 9y agoThey are collecting a sales tax on behalf of the taxing government from the buyer and are then legally required to pass that money on. Of course, money is fungible so the revenue including sales tax goes into the big bucket and then money has to be taken out of that bucket to pay the tax. But in principle, they're just taking in money and passing it through.
- SeckinJohn 9y agoIt's a sales tax, not a 'buying' tax. Say, a company sells you a $100 item for $100, forgetting to include the tax in the final price. And say no one ended up paying tax for that transaction for in that tax year. Who is the government going to go after once they realize this to collect the $8.75 sales tax - you or the company? Edit: I think you are confusing it with income tax. What you are saying happens for salaried income in USA.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoExactly this. It is a tax on a business based on their sales, and it is demanded whether or not the consumer pays it as a separate line item or not. That said, it is a common misunderstanding, and it is made more so by companies that advertise "and we'll pay the sales tax!" They are always paying the sales tax, just most times they pass that cost along to the consumer.
- nkurz 9y agoThey are always paying the sales tax, just most times they pass that cost along to the consumer. While you are technically correct that this is how "sales tax" works, it's worth keeping in mind that in most states "sales tax" is mirrored by "use tax", and that these two "mutually exclusively" apply to the same purchases. That is, if the seller is subject to the laws of a state they are generally required to obtain a "seller's permit" and to pay the sales tax, and are liable if this tax is not paid. But if a resident of that state purchases from someone who is not under that jurisdiction, the buyer then legally required to pay the same amount as a "use tax", and assumes the same liability. For California, see Question 1 here on "What is the difference between sales tax and use tax?": https://www.boe.ca.gov/sutax/faqtaxrate.htm#1 https://www.boe.ca.gov/sutax/faqtaxrate.htm#1 Which leads me to ask: for those of you in this thread saying "sales tax is not a buying tax", are you aware of the existence of this "use tax" and making a subtle semantic point that accidentally encourages illegal behavior, or are you unaware that of the interplay between the two? If previously unaware (and assuming you've ever purchased an item in a situation where sales tax was not charged), are you likely to change your behavior and self-report, or do plan to knowingly continue to engage in tax fraud? (For the record, I do not self-report, although I do feel guilt about it.)
- Spooky23 9y agoSales taxes are usually kept in segregated, designated accounts and are swept weekly to the taxing authority. Some merchants bury that cost in the sales price, but generally speaking it’s a seperate line item that is treated differently. Merchants comingle those funds at their peril.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- anonymous5133 9y agoThe consumers are taxed but if you have nexus and don't collect the tax then the business becomes fully liable for the uncollected tax.
- vkou 9y agoWhat I don't understand is why you need to have a local presence to be affected at sales tax. Why on earth should selling goods from Oregon in Seattle not be subject to Washington sales tax, but selling goods from Seattle to Seattle be subject to it? This punishes local businesses, and encourages tax arbitrage. As far as I see it, if you sell to residents of Washington, you have a presence in Washington.
- zifnab06 9y agoIn Washington, you're supposed to pay use tax on any untaxed item brought into the state. I don't know anyone who does though.
- Aloha 9y agoI wouldn't even know how
- astura 9y agoThey are subject to tax. You're supposed to pay "use tax" for things you buy from outside of your tax jurisdiction and didn't pay sales tax on. That's absolutely everything, technically. For my state you're supposed to report all your out of state purchases on your income tax return. The reason is because a given jurisdiction has no power to tax a business in another jurisdiction. They can tax you though,you are in their jurisdiction.
- coin 9y agoWashington can't force a company located outside of WA to pay taxes.
- vkou 9y ago
- fludlight 9y ago> Taxation without representation has been a sore spot for quite a long time :-). For non-American readers: this is why the USA declared independence from Britain.