5 ms·
What are these "so many times" that scientists have incorrectly been warning about impending doom? Nuclear winter might qualify, but given that it's merely the
by mikeash 9y ago
What are these "so many times" that scientists have incorrectly been warning about impending doom?
Nuclear winter might qualify, but given that it's merely the difference between "everyone dies" and "humanity survives, but civilization is wrecked and we really must ensure that this never happens," it doesn't seem huge.
What else is there?
- FeepingCreature 9y agoY2K, ozone hole. I know that those "don't count", because they actually got addressed, but they still feed into an unfortunate perceptual pattern.
- mikeash 9y agoThat seems unfair... but since we're talking about how people perceive it, that doesn't make it wrong.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y agoEhrlich and the whole overpopulation predictions, DDT would wipe out songbirds, the prediction we would run out of oil, a new ice age, ozone hole, the whole concept of the doomsday clock, and now the whole AI will wipe out humanity fear. Part of this blame falls on the media. It amplifies the "gloom and doom" voices because that is what sells.
- mikeash 9y agoHow common was Ehrlich's prediction? A doomsday scenario proposed by one guy, no matter how popular his book is, doesn't seem like it should count. The problems with DDT and the ozone hole were averted because people took action in response to them, not because the warnings were incorrect. The "new ice age" thing was never a mainstream prediction. The idea that scientists were warning about global cooling in the 70s is a myth. Peak oil and the doomsday clock are both absolutely correct, they just haven't happened yet. Oil reserves are finite on human timescales, and global thermonuclear war would devastate human civilization and the chance of it happening is still disturbingly large. AI is too early to say, but already pegging it as an incorrect warning now, when nothing even close to human-level AI exists, seems a bit premature. (One could also argue that the warning is premature, but that's different from being wrong.)
- jack9 9y ago> The idea that scientists were warning about global cooling in the 70s is a myth. The Scientific American articles from the 80s still exist. Myth, is not the appropriate term.
- mikeash 9y agoThe key word in the quoted text is "scientists." The media hype was real. Unlike the current climate change hype, it wasn't based on scientific consensus.
- conistonwater 9y agoIndeed: The Myth of the 1970s Global Cooling Scientific Consensus, Peterson, Connolley, Fleck (http://journals.ametsoc.org/doi/abs/10.1175/2008BAMS2370.1 http://journals.ametsoc.org/doi/abs/10.1175/2008BAMS2370.1)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jack9 9y ago"consensus" is the new goalpost? SMH
- mikeash 9y agoWhat would you suggest here? It wasn’t even close to a majority.
- greedo 9y agoIn the context of the 70's, everything was a disaster or crisis waiting to happen. From movies that made you worry about earthquakes, burning skyscrapers, killer bees, to books Ehrlich's book, Rachel Carson's overhyped "Silent Spring" and magazines like Newsweek that touted a coming ice age. If that wasn't enough, the overwhelming sense of fear of a war with the USSR, or running out of oil due to an OPEC embargo was a real thing.
- PhasmaFelis 9y agoThe ozone hole was absolutely real. We took action and fixed it. We are running low on cheaply extractable oil, but we're making progress towards replacing it with renewable sources. This is not fearmongering, this is responding to the evidence and taking action. And the Doomsday Clock is a strange example of a false prediction, since it doesn't actually make strong predictions, just estimates the level of nuclear tension at any given time. You can hardly argue that we haven't been close to nuclear war several times in the past 50 years.
- Oletros 9y agoWhat whas wrong about the ozone hole? About the coming Ice Age, https://arstechnica.com/science/2016/06/that-70s-myth-did-climate-science-really-call-for-a-coming-ice-age/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2016/06/that-70s-myth-did-cl...
- ekianjo 9y ago> What are these "so many times" that scientists have incorrectly been warning about impending doom? Oh, like every time there's a bird flu epidemic? The WHO cries Wolf about every couple of years.
- jhbadger 9y agoThe "Spanish" flu epidemic of 1918 resulted in the deaths of 50 to 100 million. The fact that we haven't had a similar epidemic since is in large part due to the work of groups like WHO and CDC. But this preventive work is not unlike IT departments making backups -- nobody thinks it is that important until the system fails.
- ekianjo 9y agothaTs a pretty impressive claim to make in a pre antibiotics and pre modern medecine world when tuberculosis and rabbies were still killing a lot of people every year. we did not wait for the WHO to have better standards.