4 ms·
It depends on what exactly is meant by "quite survivable." Does that mean you'll have a 99% chance to survive even if you do any special preparation? If so, nu
by mikeash 9y ago
It depends on what exactly is meant by "quite survivable."
Does that mean you'll have a 99% chance to survive even if you do any special preparation? If so, nuclear war definitely does not qualify.
Does it mean you'll have a greater than 50% chance to survive with good preparation? Nuclear war probably qualifies.
Or does it just mean that nuclear war won't result in human extinction? Nuclear war definitely qualifies.
An all-out nuclear war would definitely kill tens of millions immediately, and tens if not hundreds of millions with the after-effects. You may not see years-long crop failures due to nuclear winter, but you'll get the same ultimate effect from lack of fertilizer, machinery, and distribution infrastructure. And fallout. A good chunk of the US's productive agricultural land is downwind from ICBM sites which would be targeted for extremely dirty ground burst attacks.
- pvg 9y agoThere's no reasonable interpretation of a 50%-ish survival rate that can be described as 'quite survivable'. Toxicologists say LD50, for instance, not QS50.
- mikeash 9y agoYou have a quibble with that one but not with defining it as "humanity doesn't go extinct"?
- khedoros1 9y agoOn an individual scale? Sure. On a civilization or species scale? Survival of the larger group is almost certain if each individual has "only" a 50% chance of death.
- quotemstr 9y agoThe Black Death, after all, killed about half of Europe's population. European civilization survived.
- thaumasiotes 9y agoWell, a subset of the population persisted. The order of society changed radically, as it became impossible to enforce enserfment.
- ekianjo 9y agoWas it really half? I have seen figures around 30%. Are there any accurate records in every country at the time?