6 ms·
"Soviet Union had tested a 50 megaton bomb with no more than the usual local effects" The Tsar Bomba was tested over artic wildereness in Novaya Zemlya, not ov
by arethuza 9y ago
"Soviet Union had tested a 50 megaton bomb with no more than the usual local effects"
The Tsar Bomba was tested over artic wildereness in Novaya Zemlya, not over a city.
- pc86 9y agoDo the effects on the climate change depending on whether it's over a city or the wilderness?
- arethuza 9y agoI believe the idea is that if you explode an H-bomb over a large city an awful lot of stuff is going to catch fire resulting in huge firestorms that would (along with the effects of the explosions themselves) raise a lot of stuff into the atmosphere. Of course, thankfully, we don't really know what would happen when a large city receives a realistic attack from multiple H-bombs.
- ghostcluster 9y agoExcept we know what happens when major cities are fire bombed from World War II, and we know the effects of the much worse 1991 Kuwait oil fires which caused no such effects.
- vilhelm_s 9y agoI think it's not quite so easy. There were many cities bombed in World War II (maybe 60 in Japan and additional ones in Germany), but there were only 5 or 6 firestorms. Similarly, the Kuwait oil fires created a lot of soot, but the plume is isolated to a given point, which causes it to disperse before reaching the stratosphere. The claim is that firestorms in particular would create climate change, because a single city-sized plume could carry the soot much higher than if the city burned and released the same amount of soot in an ordinary fire. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Firestorm#City_firestorms https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Firestorm#City_firestorms https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_winter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_winter
- ghostcluster 9y ago700 oil wells along with several lakes of oil burned for months in 1991. Many of the same people who projected 'nuclear winter', advanced the same environmental winter projections for the hypothetical fires before the conflict. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_winter#Kuwait_wells_in_the_first_Gulf_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_winter#Kuwait_wells_in...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dwringer 9y agoI don't think we had either climate models or remote sensing capabilities during World War II adequate to assess what climate effects may have resulted from the several firestorms that occurred. The 1991 Kuwait oil fires were apparently projected by some to cause a "petroleum winter", but these models were disputed and many simulations apparently suggested that the particles would not reach the stratosphere (and evidently they did not)[0]. However, it seems that since 1998[1] it has been known that smoke from naturally occurring firestorms (resulting from wildfires) can reach the stratosphere and cause regional climate effects significant enough to alter hemispheric temperature patterns. [0] https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007%2F978-94-011-1685-5_3 https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007%2F978-94-011-1685-... [1] http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2006AGUFM.U14A..04F http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2006AGUFM.U14A..04F
- ghostcluster 9y agoExcept Carl Sagan himself was one of the scientists advancing the "petroleum winter effect" in 1991 in the lead up to the gulf conflict, just as he advanced his nuclear winter scenario earlier.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dwringer 9y agoIf your point is that Carl Sagan may not be the foremost authority on nuclear winter, I think it's already been made (though, that is an interesting catch). I have no ability to speak on that subject, I was merely pointing out that I find it misleading to suggest that firestorms have been shown not to cause climate effects when the opposite is also true in some instances.
- ajross 9y agoThe contention was yes: cities are built primarily of loose-frame wood structures that burn easily with rapidly-spreading fires (unlike forests, which are much harder to light and sustain). So the idea is that one bomb causes the inner city and all the urban expanse surrounding it to burn within a few hours as a "firestorm" that would lift the soot into the stratosphere. Now, that's been debunked apparently. But the hypothesis as stated is sound enough. It's not the blast itself, it's the fire.