10 ms·
The modern left-wing view of racism is as a systematic, structural power relationship between races. Individual decisions branching on skin color is neither nec
by closeparen 9y ago
The modern left-wing view of racism is as a systematic, structural power relationship between races. Individual decisions branching on skin color is neither necessary nor sufficient to get there, although it can and historically has contributed.
For example, divesting from your neighborhood out of concern for your property value when PoC start to move in does not necessarily reflect an individual racial bias. It could be a purely rational economic calculation based on other people’s biases. It’s still the bread and butter of the system of racism.
Just like discrimination that branches on culture or class and only incidentally produces outcomes along racial lines.
- Oxitendwe 9y agoOr, to put it a different way, "You don't actually need to be racist in order to be racist."
- twblalock 9y agoI'm not sure if you're being sarcastic or not, but that's correct under the explanation of racism given by the parent comment (which is not merely the left-wing view, but the consensus academic view). The example about divesting from a neighborhood due to concerns about property value is spot-on. In a systematically racist society, it is rational to behave in ways that produce racist outcomes even one does not personally have racist beliefs. Racism ends up being perpetuated even if most people don't think of themselves as racists or believe they are doing anything to promote unfair racial outcomes.
- Oxitendwe 9y agoThe Catholic Church called, they want their original sin back.
- sctb 9y agoCould you please post civilly and substantively here, or not at all? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- weberc2 9y ago> which is not merely the left-wing view, but the consensus academic view This follows only because academics (in relevant fields) are a strict subset of the left-wing (and generally the extreme left wing), and the relevant fields are in the middle of a reproducibility crisis largely due to their political confirmation bias. These fields are very open about their commitment to activism over objectivity (and many in these fields consider objectivity and reason to be "tools of white supremacy" or some similar nonsense). We shouldn't confuse "sociologists believe in X" with "X is true or even falsifiable".
- spaceseaman 9y ago> the relevant fields are in the middle of a reproducibility crisis largely due to their political confirmation bias. As someone who works very closely with academics (specifically sociologists), I would love to see some evidence for this baseless mud-slinging. All of science is having a reproducibility crisis Do you have a knowledge of the field? Or do you just disagree with their conclusions? I would be happy to be proven wrong so I can let my sociologist friends know that they are doing such a thing. EDIT: There's also this really neat nature article detailing some of the responses to the current reproducibility crisis in all of science. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41562-016-0021 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41562-016-0021 Based on this article, it looks like the social sciences are actually the ones spearheading the effort for more reproducible science. One of my colleagues is actually investigating how the typical formulation of ideas with the scientific method can implicitly lead to biases and errors in the science actually performed.
- barry-cotter 9y agoYou’re right. Which isn’t to say sociology isn’t a hostile environment for anyone who isn’t avowedly left wing, or that sociologists (or social psychologists, or anthropologists) don’t discriminate against people they know are right wing. But nothing I’ve read suggests that politics before truth is the majority position in sociology. It’s clearly a position, and not a fringe one, but it’s weaker than in the 60’s. Cultural anthropology is a writeoff though. I would hope the social sciences are leading the charge on reproducibility. If you want to learn more on that topic read Andrew Gelman’s blog.
- torstenvl 9y agoThe problem with that view is that, in such a definition of racism, it quite simply is not an -ism.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoOf course it is, it's just systemic, not individualized.
- twblalock 9y agoThere are lot of systematic "isms" -- capitalism, socialism, fascism, etc.
- humanrebar 9y agoThose words aren't used the same way as "racism". To wit: Are communist Americans also capitalist because they part of systemic structural capitalism?
- twblalock 9y agoYes, you might call them anti-capitalist capitalists.
- closeparen 9y agoThe point isn’t to find an adjective for the communists, but to describe the society they live in, and whether specific actions or policies make it more or less that way.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- weberc2 9y agoThe problem with this view is that it describes correlates instead of causes, and worse--that it confuses the two: most people understand racism to mean something like "differences caused by race", and thus something that is morally reprehensible. Your example is one that is caused (though indirectly) by racism, but others examples are not causal but correlated (or at least so indirectly causal as to be meaningless)--for example, that midwesterners appear racist because they have a lower threshold for cultural differences, which is caused by the correlation between culture and race. Besides this, the left-wing view is easily confused with the popular notion of racism, which is widely considered to be immoral, and I think often the proponents of this viewpoint abuse the confusion, deliberately accusing skeptics and dissenters of "racism" without being clear that they mean the probably-benign "systemic racism" instead of the clearly immoral "racism". Further, many of these proponents also tend to consider "questioning systemic racism theory" to be an act of (systemic) "racism" because it inhibits the consensus required to combat (systemic) "racism". TL;DR I think the marketing was deliberately obfuscatory, and this has had a huge detrimental impact on our national racial.
- throwawayjava 9y agoI believe the reason that the root post is the top-voted comment is that it poses a helpful question: how do we fix this? My suggestion is that people stop being so damn concerned about their moral status and start caring more about actually fixing things. A system with de facto separate and unequal schools is just as bad as a system with de jure separate and unequal schools. Whether that's the result of an emergent phenomenon or explicit planning has little effect on the people stuck in the system. If someone's fragile moral ego gets in the way of an accurate description of the problem... well, that person's ego is the problem. FWIW you see the same problem in flailing engineering projects.
- weberc2 9y ago> My suggestion is that people stop being so damn concerned about their moral status and start caring more about actually fixing things. This is silly. Moral status is a necessary component of political capital. The entire reason the progressive left stuck to their confusing "systemic racism" term is because it conveniently allows them to strip dissidents and critics of the political capital necessary to implement their fixes or even advance the national discourse. Of course, we could think wishfully about a world where politics were irrelevant (as I sometimes do), but that's not productive.
- stcredzero 9y agoThe modern left-wing view of racism is as a systematic, structural power relationship between races So in other words, it's pretty much Marxism. Just s/races/classes/.
- nickbauman 9y agoHa. Marxism adopted terms like "class struggle" from older, Classical political economic theory that came before it. What the parent said is only the tip of the iceberg. Racism is a system to divide people so they are easier to control. So it hurts both black and white and other POC by making whites and browns fear downward mobility by making examples out of blacks and other out groups. If you look at any of civil rights leaders who were killed (MLK, Malcom X f.e.), you will see that the worst punishment (assassination) is reserved for those who realized that it's not about just racism. It's about dividing people against each other. Trump has done this spectacularly by making whites fear P.O.C. all over again when it's his class, the plutocrats, who gain the most from sowing this division.
- crooked-v 9y ago> Racism is a system to divide people so they are easier to control. For a historical example, in early American colonial history it was common to have indentured and/or enslaved servants of all races, and the focus on exclusively black slavery only happened after multiracial revolts by the poor against the rich. Dividing poor white and poor blacks drastically reduced the number of revolts attempted by either group.
- throwawayjava 9y agoYou'd need a damn broad definition of Marxism for that to make much sense. Economy and class are so central the Marx's philosophy that saying "Just s/<insert anything here>/class" doesn't make any sense. You can't just go into Capital and s/<insert anything here>/class and end up with anything that makes any sense. The entire analysis needs restructuring. At some point, if Marxism is defined that way, you might as well just call any materialist philosophy "basically Marxist". Which is silly. Tangentially, I've seen a lot of "so basically (cultural) Marxism" type comments lately about anything and everything left-leaning in the US. Something memetic is going on there.
- exelius 9y agoAgree with this. My personal way of saying this is "we all do racist things, but very few of us are racist." Very often the most pragmatic choice in a situation also happens to be racist. Just own the racist things you do, and try to change the world for the better so you are no longer pushed into doing racist things.
- aaron-lebo 9y agoI don't buy that. Moving out of an area due to declining property values is not inherently racist. It's a mix of economic, cultural, and class issues. Calling that racism is to potentially miss the root cause of much of this stuff, and it has to do with poverty. The poor of any ethnic group or race are treated badly.
- humanrebar 9y ago> we all do racist things, but very few of us are racist That's confusing because you're using two different definitions of the word "racist" in the same sentence. At some point we should do everyone a favor and use two words when we mean two things.
- exelius 9y agoThey’re the same word describing different things. Many white people are aghast at being accused of doing something racist because it implies that they themselves are racist. It shouldn’t, and it hampers the conversation to imply it does (the same logic can be applied to sexism and most other isms as well). Not saying there aren’t racists out there (lol tiki torches), but most people don’t fall into that category.
- humanrebar 9y agoSurely you see the issue when the same word describes perhaps the worst atrocities in human history and something people can't help being or doing. The implication is that people can't help but be the scum of the earth. Two words for two concepts would decrease the stakes of the conversation and perhaps make room for some actual understanding and progress.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> The modern left-wing view of racism is as a systematic, structural power relationship between races. Incorrect. More correct would be: the dominant modern left-wing view is that there exists now in much of the world, and has historically, a systematic structural power imbalances between groups identified as “races”, that this disproportionately harms some of those groups, and that this is bad thing. That the confluence of all those things is the proper referent of the label “racism” rather than that label referring to racial bias which is a component of all that is far more controversial even within the left. > For example, divesting from your neighborhood out of concern for your property value when PoC start to move in does not necessarily reflect an individual racial bias. It could be a purely rational economic calculation based on other people’s biases. It’s still the bread and butter of the system of racism. Uh, yes, because it's a product of someone's racial biases, it's still a part of systemic racism even by the simpler and more common definition of racism, because its a product of racial biases within the social system.
- closeparen 9y agoThe point is, structural disadvantages are perpetuated and worsened by people and behaviors that are not specifically discriminatory or hateful themselves. Of course the mechanism is usually related to discriminatory or hateful views held by someone at some point. I don’t like the conflation of terms either. But I see a lot of people talking past each other (“racism isn’t a big deal because most people aren’t racist anymore,” and “racism is a major problem in America because of structural inequality”). Parent got close to explaining how these statements are true at the same time, and I wanted to point it out.
- dragonwriter 9y agoThe statements aren't true at the same time. Racism—of the personal kind—is very common (nigh universal), even if much of it is subconscious. There are vast piles of research showing that personal racial bias manifesting through discrimination, whether or not it is conscious/intentional, is pervasive in America. Structural racism is real, but it is not independent of personal racism—it is produced by and perpetuates personal racism.