4 ms·
> There's a risk that some portion of respondents heard "fraud", even though the question was about legal loopholes. Isn't that the point? People see tax avoid
by DanBC 9y ago
> There's a risk that some portion of respondents heard "fraud", even though the question was about legal loopholes.
Isn't that the point? People see tax avoidance but don't see it as fraud; people see legal benefit maximisation and see it as fraud.
> First, I don't know what a legal loophole to claim more benefits is - either you qualify for a given payment, or you don't.
A benefit claimant's benefit is paid by the secretary of state for the department for work and pensions. That person is obviously busy, so they employ decision makers who sit in benefit centres across the UK.
There's no way to interact directly with a decision maker. You can only ever interact with them via forms and postal letters, and those letters and forms go through an intermediary.
A decision maker looks at the details of the person's claim. They apply the various acts, statutes, statutory instruments, and case law to the person's claim. All that law is scattered across various places, and so decision makers have a couple of handy guide books.
These are available online.
https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/decision-makers-guide-staff-guide https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/decision-makers-gu...
https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/advice-for-decision-making-staff-guide https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/advice-for-decisi...
The advice for decision making is for:
> DWP decision makers now use Advice for decision making (instead of the DMG) for decisions that involve:
> Universal Credit
> Personal Independence Payment
contribution-based Jobseeker’s Allowance and contribution-based Employment and Support Allowance for people who are eligible for Universal Credit
I think all the rest use the decision makers guide.
Have a look at the guide. Have a look at the page numbers listed in each volume. The decision makers guide is 14,000 pages (fourteen thousand) long. And there's no index.
It's impossible for ordinary people to work out if they're really entitled or not to a benefit. And the quality of decision making is, frankly, piss poor.
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/oct/30/staggering-rise-pip-complaints-rot-system-disability-benefits https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/oct/30/stagge...
here's a judge from a first tier appeal panel saying the decision making is terrible: https://sirhenrybrooke.me/2017/11/08/poor-decision-making-personal-independence-payments-pips-and-pip-appeals/ https://sirhenrybrooke.me/2017/11/08/poor-decision-making-pe...
So, a legal benefit loophole might be a skilled benefits adviser who helps claimants make claims by helping them fill in the forms and gather evidence, and then helps them attend the independent medical assessments, and then helps them write the letter for mandatory reconsideration and then follow up with an appeal.
- mseebach 9y agoMy argument is that I don't think that's what people hear when you ask them about "legal loopholes". And so the survey accidentally, implicitly ends up comparing "legal tax avoidance" with "benefits fraud" which is apples to oranges. If the questions instead had been "working with your accountant to minimise you tax liability in legal ways" vs. "working with your benefits advisor to make sure you receive the benefits you legally qualify for", I suspect the result would have been different. If you want to write the article the author actually did, the more relevant question would probably have been "tax fraud" vs "benefits fraud". I'd be curious to know what those numbers are.