4 ms·
I find it weird that scientists get crap from other scientists for speaking publicly. Simple jealousy doesn't explain the vehemence. As for the politics of the
by mcguire 9y ago
I find it weird that scientists get crap from other scientists for speaking publicly. Simple jealousy doesn't explain the vehemence.
As for the politics of the issue, mutual assured destruction has been the working theory since Eisenhower. Those who think strategic nuclear war is winnable, as well as the SDI nutters, are threats to that stability.
- Xeoncross 9y ago> Simple jealousy doesn't explain the vehemence. In any industry, if you attack/speak-against my beliefs/views/plans/theories, then I don't like it. Even if you didn't mean too. Even if you didn't know I existed or had those views. It's not about science, it's about humans defending their worldview and beliefs. Even stamp collecting has this. Anything people put time/effort into has this. edit: ChuckMcM does a better job describing this.
- ethbro 9y agoAka https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Escalation_of_commitment https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Escalation_of_commitment https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confirmation_bias https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confirmation_bias https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognitive_dissonance https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognitive_dissonance
- ChuckMcM 9y agoI think of it more in terms of the people. Someone doing research on a topic for any length of time probably sees themselves as dedicated (time commitment) and intelligent (PhD and post doc work). They really strongly believe what they believe. And someone else comes along with similar traits strongly believes a different thing. If a person can acknowledge that this other person is smart and qualified, and recognize that they hold a belief that, if true, implies the believe that the person holds is incorrect. Then they have to deal with being wrong on something they have invested a lot of time into and believed for possibly a very long time. Throw in a bit of imposter syndrome and I think it would be surprising is people just switched their point of view when presented with an alternative. Instead it sets up this conflict where each party tries really hard to prove the other wrong, and after one or more rounds of that one point of view or the other generally prevails (at least from the perspective of the audience). This is when really good science gets done because it does a great job of neutralizing implicit biases.
- razakel 9y ago>I find it weird that scientists get crap from other scientists for speaking publicly. Simple jealousy doesn't explain the vehemence. I know a physicist who despises Brian Cox with a passion. It's jealousy.
- mseebach 9y agoIt's not about "speaking publicly", it's about claiming (implicitly, typically) that Science supports a particular side in a political debate. Science very rarely actually has the power to do that - it can advise on how (probably) best to achieve a given outcome under certain constraints. The political debate of Sagans time was unilateral nuclear disarmament and it fed eagerly on accounts of the horror of nuclear war. The unstated constraint was that it was perfectly happy to accept a significantly less restrained Soviet Union on the world stage. Science can't tell you if that's a good idea or not.
- nabla9 9y agoMassive retaliation and Mutually assured destruction are different concepts. During the Eisenhower era U.S. doctrine was so called massive retaliation using a force disproportionate to the size of the attack. It was viable strategy only as long as Soviet Union did not have nuclear parity. Kennedy realized that massive retaliation was not credible anymore and asked other options. U.S. nuclear strategy changed into so called flexible response strategy. Soviet Union had always relied in the use of tactical nukes. First use of nuclear weapons does not automatically lead to all out nuclear holocaust. There was nuclear escalation ladders even against Soviet Union. Mutually assured destruction (MAD) is deterrence strategy only against massive decapitation attack. Today locally limited nuclear war is more likely than ever before. It's part of Russian doctrine if Russia is outmatched in local conflicts. US has nuclear weapons and strategies dedicated for limited nuclear war.
- waterhouse 9y agoWhen a scientist speaks to the public, they represent (in much of the public's mind, anyway) all scientists in the field, and (arguably, to some extent) science and scientists in general. If they say anything wrong, then that harms the reputation of all of the above. From the perspective of a fellow scientist in the field, the speaker must (a) have made mistakes in his analysis, (b) have taken an approach to his analysis that was sloppy enough to allow such mistakes, and (c) have announced results despite having done an analysis that they should have known was sloppy. In other words, it demonstrates not just incompetence but negligence and a disregard for the truth. These are hateful qualities in a scientist. This is assuming the case of a scientist who confidently makes incorrect assertions. If they qualify what they're saying—"So far this is what the research says, but it's preliminary, there are a few other tests I'd like to see"—then that's a lot more defensible even if they're wrong. (There is a legendary tendency for reporters to remove all the qualifiers, but at least that's not the scientist's fault.) If they state everything confidently, more confidently than the evidence justifies, but they happen to be right on all their assertions so far, then that may be mildly irritating. If they're intellectually cautious and they're right, and if there are scientists that complain about these people, then that does sound like jealousy.