4 ms·
How can a human participant play randomly with equal probability without using a three-sided die or other such source of randomness?
by mikeash 9y ago
How can a human participant play randomly with equal probability without using a three-sided die or other such source of randomness?
- tdb7893 9y agoYou probably could get close enough by mentally stimulating a really simple prng
- GuB-42 9y agoYou can memorize a few random numbers beforehand. It is perfectly fine as long as they are used only once. You can look for external sources in order to increase your entropy, like the seconds hand of a clock. You can get additional numbers or limit your bias by mentally running a PRNG. A lagged Fibonacci generator is a good candidate for this. Otherwise, you are right, you simply cannot mentally generate good enough random numbers.
- tjoff 9y agoYou could memorize a random sequence.
- tzs 9y agoIt depends on how often you play RPS. If it is something that happens at most a few times a day, you could generate a random list of choices in the morning and step through it as needed during the day. If you are on a Unix or Unix-like system, you could make a list with something like this (line wrapped for presentation): xxd -p -l 5 /dev/urandom | tr [a-f] [A-F] | sed -e 's/./c&dlfx0=rd1-lfx0=pd2-lfx0=s/g' | dc -e '16i[d3-d3-d3-d3-****]sf[[rock]psd]sr[[paper]psd]sp[[scissors]psd]ss' - which gives something like: rock scissors rock scissors paper scissors scissors scissors paper To memorize your list for the day, probably some kind of system where you have several images associated with each of rock, paper, scissors, and then use some standard memory technique, like a mind palace, to remember an image sequence for your particular list. If you don't want to be memorizing something new each day, it would probably work to just memorize one reasonably long sequence and just cycle through it. Assuming we are talking about casual RPS here, not people who compete in RPS tournaments, your opponents probably are not going to notice that you have a pattern. For instance, if you happen to have memorized pi to more than the average person, you could step through the digits of pi, taking each digit mod 3 to get your choice (skip the digit 0). I don't know pi very far, just 3.141592653589793238462643383, but that would give me 7 days of 4 plays per day before repeating. For things like RPS to decide who drives to lunch at work and things like that, that would probably be good enough to not have anyone notice the pattern (well...unless someone else at work was also doing pi...).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]