4 ms·
Use rock-paper-scissors instead. It can be considered a game of skill but any one player can turn it into a game of pure chance if he wants to, as such, is can
by GuB-42 9y ago
Use rock-paper-scissors instead.
It can be considered a game of skill but any one player can turn it into a game of pure chance if he wants to, as such, is can be considered fairer.
The reason why RPS can become a came of chance is that there is no way to gain advantage over a player who plays randomly with equal probability : the outcome will be 50/50 no matter what. In game theory, it's called a Nash equilibrium.
Of course, if the opponent is playing sub-optimally (i.e. not randomly), you can try to take advantage of it.
- creaghpatr 9y agoThe opponent almost always plays sub-optimially, lots of research on this as well for example: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/arts-and-entertainment/wp/2014/05/01/how-to-win-rock-paper-scissors-almost-every-time/?utm_term=.4eb4cfb852c4 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/arts-and-entertainment/w... Need a random number generator or other computerized solution to create 'fair' 50/50 odds
- mikeash 9y agoHow can a human participant play randomly with equal probability without using a three-sided die or other such source of randomness?
- tdb7893 9y agoYou probably could get close enough by mentally stimulating a really simple prng
- GuB-42 9y agoYou can memorize a few random numbers beforehand. It is perfectly fine as long as they are used only once. You can look for external sources in order to increase your entropy, like the seconds hand of a clock. You can get additional numbers or limit your bias by mentally running a PRNG. A lagged Fibonacci generator is a good candidate for this. Otherwise, you are right, you simply cannot mentally generate good enough random numbers.
- tjoff 9y agoYou could memorize a random sequence.
- tzs 9y agoIt depends on how often you play RPS. If it is something that happens at most a few times a day, you could generate a random list of choices in the morning and step through it as needed during the day. If you are on a Unix or Unix-like system, you could make a list with something like this (line wrapped for presentation): xxd -p -l 5 /dev/urandom | tr [a-f] [A-F] | sed -e 's/./c&dlfx0=rd1-lfx0=pd2-lfx0=s/g' | dc -e '16i[d3-d3-d3-d3-****]sf[[rock]psd]sr[[paper]psd]sp[[scissors]psd]ss' - which gives something like: rock scissors rock scissors paper scissors scissors scissors paper To memorize your list for the day, probably some kind of system where you have several images associated with each of rock, paper, scissors, and then use some standard memory technique, like a mind palace, to remember an image sequence for your particular list. If you don't want to be memorizing something new each day, it would probably work to just memorize one reasonably long sequence and just cycle through it. Assuming we are talking about casual RPS here, not people who compete in RPS tournaments, your opponents probably are not going to notice that you have a pattern. For instance, if you happen to have memorized pi to more than the average person, you could step through the digits of pi, taking each digit mod 3 to get your choice (skip the digit 0). I don't know pi very far, just 3.141592653589793238462643383, but that would give me 7 days of 4 plays per day before repeating. For things like RPS to decide who drives to lunch at work and things like that, that would probably be good enough to not have anyone notice the pattern (well...unless someone else at work was also doing pi...).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tzs 9y agoI recall reading once about a RPS playing robot that would win most of the time against humans by taking advantage of its much faster reaction time and much quicker ability to process input. It delayed making its choice until it could see what the human was doing. The robot was fast enough that the delay was imperceptible to the human. Humans vary in reaction time and processing speed. I wonder if there are any humans faster enough than average to be able to cheat that way? Professional baseball players might be good candidates to try to train to cheat at RPS. They have to be among the fastest humans at processing input and reacting in order to hit major league fastballs.
- tjoff 9y agoIt's too late to react, a human has to look for clues before hand to try and predict the outcome (which is quite possible, I've for instance noticed that a person throwing a rock will often squeeze the hand noticably harder). But changing after/during the fact will be noticable.
- baddox 9y agoIsn’t hitting a baseball more about prediction and less about reflexes? I would think other sports would require quicker reflexes, like boxing, fencing, and table tennis.
- aidenn0 9y agoThey read the arm-slot, grip, and initial spin of ball from 90 feet away, and then react to it. Table tennis is similar because you read the spin based off of the position of their paddle hitting the ball (table tennis balls are typically unmarked so reading the spin directly is a no-go). OTOH, the table tennis stroke is more similar to a baseball bunt than a baseball swing as the paddle spends more time in a position overlapping the predicted path of the ball. This is somewhat negated by the much shorter distances in table tennis. It's hard to say which requires more quick reaction to complicated inputs.
- baddox 9y agoYes, they have some very small amount of time to predict the future path of the ball based on the motion and initial behavior of the ball, and begin a swing based on that. Apparently a fastball takes just under half a second from release to plate, and a swing takes 150ms to execute. That gives the batter about 300ms to decide whether to start a swing, which I'm guessing is around the same amount of time between hits in table tennis. Of course, I don't know how much a batter can adjust and aim the bat mid-swing. Also, some table tennis shots give you way less time than 0.3 seconds, but those are usually slams that would only be successfully returned if the player made a lucky guess.
- ColanR 9y ago> Of course, if the opponent is playing sub-optimally (i.e. not randomly), you can try to take advantage of it. I would not consider that little game to be even or fair...I've learned a few tricks such that, best out of 3, I can nearly always win.
- LgWoodenBadger 9y agosuch as?
- BeefySwain 9y agoCare to share?
- ColanR 9y agoPeople will copy a winning opponent, and will not repeat themselves (usually).
- coding123 9y agoRPS is definitely gamed - almost everyone that suggests RPS chooses paper first - the person presented with the option of playing the game will almost always choose rock first. Now I simply decline RPS because when I play my scissors, they end up saying 2 out of 3 man. crazy
- an_account 9y agoIt’s always best of three ;)