5 ms·
> Case in point - is the 'undisclosed buyer' really benefiting $450.3 mil worth? Of course not! They are benefiting from whatever the difference is between $45
by crazygringo 9y ago
> Case in point - is the 'undisclosed buyer' really benefiting $450.3 mil worth?
Of course not! They are benefiting from whatever the difference is between $450.3M and what they expect to sell it for in the future, discounted to present value.
Which means they might either expect to make money on it, or at least not lose too much on it.
For some people, buying art aren't isn't too different from buying stocks... except you can't do anything to enjoy equities hanging on your wall.
- ktta 9y ago>For some people, buying art aren't isn't too different from buying stocks You are making it look like there's no emotion involved. Buying art in my opinion is mostly an emotional one, unless you're lucky and getting a Monet in a yard sale (which you admit by saying 'you can't do anything to enjoy equities hanging on your wall.'). Also, it is definitely not a logical rationale like buying stocks. Atleast not a stable one. For half a billion dollars there are better ways to invest, and diversity. Without risking a single point of failure like here. Also, what guarantee is there that this will appreciate? What's stopping from this painting's value from dropping to zero in a decade or two? Other investments do too, but that's where the diversification part comes in. Art definitely has it's place in the future, but a specific piece isn't worth risking half a billion dollars over.
- zippy5 9y agoThere is centuries of data about how this asset has appreciated. It has a brand that has endured 500 years. Most of the stocks you will invest in, probably won't exist in 50. What could you possibly want to diversify against? It has outlasted Governments, new technologies, and new ideologies. Diversification is a durability strategy and this painting has proven durability across a multitude of change.
- ForHackernews 9y agoWell, unless somebody proves this is a fake. Its authenticity has been questioned.
- ktta 9y ago>Most of the stocks you will invest in, probably won't exist in 50. I wasn't just talking about stocks. There are so many other places to invest with that amount of money.
- Cd00d 9y agoThat's right. There are certain luxury purchases that are not about spending money, but rather are a reasonably safe way to park cash.
- tryingagainbro 9y ago>>Of course not! They are benefiting from whatever the difference is between $450.3M and what they expect to sell it for in the future, discounted to present value. You're writing about him, so he's benefiting. He knows and everyone in his social circle know that he has a painting of DaVinci. His children's friends etc etc. After securing our daily bread and then some, we do things for bragging, pleasure.. Not knowing the buyer, it may also be a way to move cash outa his corrupt country (Russia, China, Saudi Arabia...). 'Whatever happens, I have 2 apartments in NYC, one in Miami and a DaVinci painting i can sell'
- m-i-l 9y ago> you can't do anything to enjoy equities hanging on your wall. I can't imagine a half a billion dollar painting being hung on anyone's wall. In fact I can't imagine it bringing much enjoyment to anyone, given it is likely to spend it's life locked up in top secret high security climate controlled vaults.
- joosters 9y agoexcept you can't do anything to enjoy equities hanging on your wall The buyers might not even get that benefit... there are billions of dollars worth of artworks sitting in storage in tax-efficient 'freeports': https://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21590353-ever-more-wealth-being-parked-fancy-storage-facilities-some-customers-they-are https://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21590353-ever-more-w...
- speedplane 9y agoI doubt the buyer would do that with this piece. It's too expensive and one-of-a-kind to stash away. If you're buying artwork just as an investment to stash away, you'd probably buy many much smaller pieces rather than a headline grabbing one. I'd bet that this will be hanging in someone's billionaire's living room somewhere (hopefully behind some protective glass). These guys have egos. Saying you own the most expensive piece of artwork ever gets you something that money can't buy (even though you did buy it).
- rootlocus 9y ago> Saying you own the most expensive piece of artwork ever gets you something that money can't buy (even though you did buy it). "Saying you own the most expensive piece of artwork ever" is literary what money can buy.