5 ms·
Byzantine monks had the same neoplatonic ideas that were common in Western Europe, having been established around Constantine's reign. Aristotelian ideas lived
by boomboomsubban 9y ago
Byzantine monks had the same neoplatonic ideas that were common in Western Europe, having been established around Constantine's reign. Aristotelian ideas lived on in the Arab world, and it is contact with their philosophical works that led to Aristotelian ideas in Christianity.
I can own a book my entire life, it doesn't make me an expert on it and people I interact with won't gain an interest in it.
- mkempe 9y agoThomas Aquinas read Latin translations of Aristotle's works by Iacobus Veneticus Graecus (James of Venice) -- who studied in Constantinople and translated Greek works held in Constantinople. The fact that Byzantine scholars were inclined to Platonism does not mean that they destroyed or completely ignored Aristotle's works. The fact that scholars in Europe thought by the 12th century that maybe they should pay more attention to Aristotle does not mean that they had entirely forgotten who he was. The fact that Pépin the Short (8th century) received a copy of Aristotle's works in Greek from pope Paul I does not mean that the West had completely lost --nor lost interest in-- the Aristotelian body of work.
- boomboomsubban 9y agoIt's not like James of Venice just tripped over a scroll and decided to translate that. Arabic translations had existed for a while, but multiple translations can change the text. Plus, a link to Islamic scholars would add resistance to the ideas spreading. He was largely ignored throughout the Christian world, but not completely. I haven't heard this Pepin story, quick research could only find it originating from the thirteenth century. Seems like standard Catholic propaganda, the great Pope sent books to ensure Charles Martel would have the knowledge necessary to stop the Muslim armies.
- iorrus 9y agoThere were Byzantium commentators on Aristotle see https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commentaries_on_Aristotle https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commentaries_on_Aristotle In fact most of Byzantium natural philosophy was based on Aristotle: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/byzantine-philosophy/#Top https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/byzantine-philosophy/#Top
- boomboomsubban 9y agoAfter six long centuries dormant they also were influenced by their Arab neighbors. Their philosophy would all be from around the same time, until 1054 they were a part of Christian philosophy.
- mkempe 9y agoAre we to believe that the Byzantines did not keep or study Aristotle's works in Greek? or that somehow the Arabs/Moslems taught the Byzantines about Aristotle? "Leo the Mathematician [790-869] ... appointed to the chair of philosophy at the Magnaura School in the mid-9th century, was to teach Aristotelian logic. In fact, elementary Aristotelian logic and natural philosophy combined with elementary mathematics would always form the standard philosophical curriculum in Byzantium" [for at least the next 400 years]. The heirs of the Roman Empire did not depend on nor need Moslem culture for the study and transmission of Aristotle's works. We know it because the Byzantines kept studying Aristotle for centuries, until they were destroyed by Moslem armies, and at the same time the Carolingians had access to Greek works and Greek translators -- including the Byzantines themselves.
- boomboomsubban 9y agoThey kept them, and there was likely some limited study over the centuries, but yes. Christian thought dominated the period, and it largely ignored Aristotle. I don't know why that's hard to believe, there has been a staggering amount of scholarly works lost over the centuries. Leo the Mathematician supposedly lived on an island with frequent contact with Muslims, and then supposedly met with the Caliph. Even still, I can't find where this tie to Aristotle comes from.
- mkempe 9y agoWhat is the basis for your statements? According to everything I've read about Leo, he was from the Greek mainland, he did not have "frequent contact" with Moslems, and he never "met with the Caliph".