5 ms·
> One thing that could hurt the market is maybe making manufacturers liable for the damages caused by security holes in their devices That's what insurance is
by tzs 9y ago
> One thing that could hurt the market is maybe making manufacturers liable for the damages caused by security holes in their devices
That's what insurance is for. Something like this was discussed in my torts class in law school, except that was long before IoT devices existed so it was about things like lawn mowers.
The idea is that it might make the most sense economically to make the lawn mower manufacturer liable when users cut off a finger or toe, even if it was due to consumer stupidity instead of any negligence on the part of the manufacturer, because the manufacturer is in the best position to estimate the risks and purchase insurance to cover them.
Presumably, the manufacturer will pass on the costs of those insurance premiums to the consumers. The manufacturer still has an incentive to try to build safe mowers, because if their insurance company ends up paying out a lot the premiums will go up. They can pass those higher premiums on to the consumers, of course, but that will make them more expensive than their safer competitors.
The manufacturer is in a good position to deal with insuring for these injuries because they know how many mowers they are selling. Other candidates have less useful information. For example, a consumer usually has no idea what their chances are of suffering a lawn mower accident, so have no idea how to decide how much insurances is needed. Health insurance companies will have a good idea in the aggregate of how many of these accidents occur in a year, but they have no idea which of their customers use lawn mowers.
Done right, this should not hurt a market much.
I'm not sure it could work for IoT, though, because a lot of IoT devices are made by new companies that probably will not be around long. With things like lawn mowers, you could takes years to get around to cutting your hand off, and still reasonably expect the manufacturer to be around. Not so with a lot of IoT devices.
- heavenlyblue 9y agoHow do you deal with insurance fraud if the manufacturer is the one paying for the insurance?
- cobbzilla 9y agoIf a manufacturer engages in fraud and is caught, they would (a) be subject to criminal penalties for insurance fraud and (b) it would become very difficult or expensive for them to acquire insurance in the future. These two negative consequences serve as a strong deterrence against fraud.
- heavenlyblue 9y agoWhat I mean is that the buyers of the products would be incentivised to damage the products (or even themselves) since the manufacturers are paying for their premiums.
- whatshisface 9y agoDoesn't that mean that every single insurance payout will have to involve the courts, taking a long time and not always panning out? If I have an accident I probably need the money on the kind of time-scale that my bills are due on, not the time scale on which courts operate. Even then, that's ignoring the huge overhead introduced.
- specialist 9y agoWhat court? What payout? Freedom Markets™ are best served by binding arbitration.
- arca_vorago 9y agoYou obviously hit a nerve with this one. I agree with you though, binding arbitration is a major issue. For example, there was recently a thread on dell shipping Ubuntu. The Dell image of Ubuntu has a EULA that includes, you guessed it, binding arbitration. My comment about this got 0 attention though...
- shonenbat 9y agoYour post might've got killed by corporate hasbara, did you check that it isn't dead? I'm half serious. EULA's should die already. I think the problem is that they require of non-experts to parse legal documents. Very, very few people who agree to EULA's have decent grasp of the implications, even if they work their way through the whole text.
- forapurpose 9y ago> That's what insurance is for What are the outcomes for using insurance, and what are the outcomes for using regulation? Does anyone know the answers in a technical policy sense (not in a philosophical sense)? They are different tools useful for different problems. Thinking out loud, insurance seems like a poor solution when people will suffer serious, irreparable harm. If the lawnmower severs a foot, then an insurance payout isn't really sufficient; regulations should prevent that from happening in the first place. More broadly, my point is that there are larger issues than economics. > Presumably, the manufacturer will pass on the costs of those insurance premiums to the consumers. In economics, that is not the case. Businesses don't price goods at 'cost-plus'; they don't look at their costs and add a profit margin. Think of the soda at the movie theater on one hand, and on the other the car being sold at a loss because the market is soft; think of software. Like all businesses, the lawnmower manufacturer already is pricing their product at the level that maximizes total sales revenue, which depends on supply and demand; raising the price will reduce revenue (probably because unit volume will decrease too much to be compensated for by per-unit revenue increase). If they could raise the price and bring in more revenue, they would have done that already. There is an issue of elasticity: If your customers' alternatives are limited - i.e., if they can't go without your product, if there are limited competitors and substitutes - then you can raise prices more easily. A Van Gogh painting is highly inelastic; lawnmowers are much less so.
- cobbzilla 9y ago> What are the outcomes for using insurance, and what are the outcomes for using regulation? Bad question, false dichotomy: these are not apples-to-apples comparisons. How about some minimal regulations that include an insurance requirement?
- Nomentatus 9y agoEven "insurance" is a distraction, the argument is really about tort law (which raises the insurance rates, case by case.) Note that ordinary risks aren't economically insurable, almost by definition, so corporations insure far less than most people would guess. A building burning down is an ordinary risk for a conglomerate so it may not be insured - insurance is too expensive since the company can more cheaply absorb the risk itself.) So I agree: yes, the existence of tort law sometimes obviates the need for regulation; but has hardly banished regulation or the need for it entire!
- wyager 9y agoThe problem is that this subsidizes stupid people at the expense of not-stupid people. Injuring yourself in dumb, preventable ways should have personal repercussions.
- schrodinger 9y agoOftentimes the dumb, preventable way has repercussions on others. In the case of not updating these IoT devices, it could be a botnet, that really doesn’t even impact the dumb person who failed to take preventive steps. In the case of the lawnmower, expense to the healthcare system.
- AnthonyMouse 9y agoThat's the point. You have a manufacturer that sells a product with N years of support and a customer who buys it and keeps operating it out of support for N+5 years, what is the manufacturer supposed to do about that? Support the product until the end of time? Remote brick the customer's property?
- cmurf 9y agoApple (at least) has shown us for some time that the device you buy is not really 100% your property. All kinds of proscriptions are in the EULA that prevent you from doing whatever you want with a Mac, and it's far more extensive with iOS devices. So yes, the company is remote bricking their property. What the consumer paid was a one time rental payment, not a purchase.
- AnthonyMouse 9y agoIt sounds a lot like you're proposing enshrining that sort of corporate serfdom in the law and prohibiting the situation where the customer actually owns their own property.
- cmurf 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- fulafel 9y ago> I'm not sure it could work for IoT, though, because a lot of IoT devices are made by new companies that probably will not be around long. If we regulate insurance so that a product needs to be backed by a 10-year liability insurance, it might have 2 good outcomes to fix this: 1) the insurance company might ask a lot of hard questions and require audits, plans, etc 2) the insurance company might require escrow to the iot device's update mechanism in case of bankruptcy, so they can remote-brick the devices It's unlikely that the reality would be so rosy though - mainly the claims against the insurance would likely be too small in many cases. It might help in 10 years against the biggest ddos botnets. Not nearly as good as direct regulation.
- _Codemonkeyism 9y agoIn principle I'm pro insurence, but it often creates an entry barrier for new companies as they don't get the same conditions from insurance companies compared to e.g. Google.
- snarfy 9y agoRequiring insurance is such a huge barrier to entry it would completely destroy the market. Only the incumbents will be able to play. Imagine you came up with the next greatest fizzbuzz app and wanted to publish it to the market. Immediately you need what, $10/mo, $100/mo, $1000/mo for insurance? Does an adjuster need to go through your app and determine your risk and thus rate? Does your rate go up overnight when your app lands on the front page of HN and you gain a ton of users? It sounds great if I'm MegaCorp with an entire department for dealing with this stuff, but as an independent developer trying to start something it's a horrible idea.
- pjc50 9y agoEveryone in business should have some indemnity insurance anyway, it's just that software and products that contain it seem to have escaped liability claims for quality up to now.
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> I'm not sure it could work for IoT, though, because a lot of IoT devices are made by new companies that probably will not be around long. With things like lawn mowers, you could takes years to get around to cutting your hand off, and still reasonably expect the manufacturer to be around. Not so with a lot of IoT devices. This is the problem. And "solutions" like that can easily backfire, because they squeeze medium sized companies out of the market, who might stake out a middle ground between $20,000 Cisco hardware and $150 "disposable cameras" from Fly By Night Corp, by charging $200 for a product that actually guarantees patches for a specific number of years. Because the liability risk raises the price the middle-ground company has to charge to the point that they can't compete with Fly By Night Corp who doesn't care. Which means more sales of insecure garbage products, because the customer no longer has the option to buy an affordable product that receives patches, and that customer can't afford the $20,000 industrial grade product, so more people end up with the insecure garbage. It would be much more effective to just require manufacturers to provide security patches for e.g. 7 years. Fly By Night Corp still wouldn't do it, but then at least Samsung would.