9 ms·
I'm a big fan of Foucault's conception of power. I think Machiavelli is commonly misunderstood by most people alive today, though. The bulk of The Prince cons
by nostrademons 9y ago
I'm a big fan of Foucault's conception of power.
I think Machiavelli is commonly misunderstood by most people alive today, though. The bulk of The Prince consists of positive statements, not normative ones. In other words, Machiavelli is describing his conclusions from observing a number of powerful families. He makes few value judgments of his own, but rather the book is framed as a set of tactical advice: "If you seek power, these are a set of strategies that will help you attain it." At the time he wrote The Prince, Machiavelli was not particularly powerful - in fact, he'd just been stripped of office, imprisoned, and tortured, and the book was an attempt to curry favor with the Medicis, the new Florentine elites. It was largely successful in this regard, in that Machiavelli was allowed to live out the rest of his life on his estate without further interference.
"It is better to be feared than loved", as a factual statement, appears to be true. Take a look at the approval ratings for U.S. Congress, President Trump, Putin, Xi Jinping, Mugabe, or any other powerful figure and then tell me, with a straight face, that they are loved. People take offense because Machiavelli is describing true statements that we wish were not true, i.e. they judge the work on normative grounds when evidence from the framing & history of The Prince suggests that it was written as a set of positive statements.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Take a look at the approval ratings for U.S. Congress, President Trump, Putin, Xi Jinping, Mugabe, or any other powerful figure and then tell me, with a straight face, that they are loved. Trump is demonstrably a historical aberration in approval terms in the US (and has been stunningly ineffective at implementing legislation); I doubt meaningful polling can be done in China or Zimbabwe, and Congress isn't a figure, while individual members of Congress tend, generally, to have fairly high approval in their own districts. So even though I agree that there is at least a sense in which Machiavelli’s statement is true, I don't think the specific thing you’ve asked people to look at does much to make the case for it.
- chmln 9y agoFYI, Putin has great approval ratings. http://www.pewglobal.org/2015/06/10/2-russian-public-opinion-putin-praised-west-panned/ http://www.pewglobal.org/2015/06/10/2-russian-public-opinion...
- ruytlm 9y agoMachiavelli is massively misunderstood. 'It is better to be feared than loved' is not the real message to be taken from that chapter. A different phrasing would be "you are better to have a promise from another for which you can compel fulfilment, than a promise for which you can't compel fulfilment". If someone promises you something out of love, and they do not deliver, you have no power to compel them to fulfil their obligation, and so you are left with an empty promise. If someone promises you something out of fear, and they don't deliver, you can use the thing they fear to compel fulfilment, and receive that which was promised. It's by no means saying that in all circumstances you should aim to be feared - and it explicitly distinguishes being feared from being hated. "Returning to the question of being feared or loved, I come to the conclusion that, men loving according to their own will and fearing according to that of the prince, a wise prince should establish himself on that which is in his own control and not in that of others; he must endeavour only to avoid hatred, as is noted."