10 ms·
Whenever I read this stuff, I imagine similar articles about the US government. We don’t do it the same way. US government officials will “leak” certain inform
by TaylorAlexander 9y ago
Whenever I read this stuff, I imagine similar articles about the US government.
We don’t do it the same way. US government officials will “leak” certain information to the press, knowing the press will take it and run.
The goal is the same. The government wants to strategically distract the populace.
- colordrops 9y agoYes. The Chinese are learning this from the US. A powerful disinformation capability is so much more important in the US because of free speech.
- TaylorAlexander 9y agoWe call it “Public Relations”.
- emacsgifs 9y agohttps://archive.org/stream/publicrelationse00bernrich/publicrelationse00bernrich_djvu.txt https://archive.org/stream/publicrelationse00bernrich/public...
- jordanb 9y agoIn the context of the government and politicians it's actually called "Perception Management" although the tactics are the same.
- LiweiZ 9y agoWell, in the case of Chinese, most of people learned and are used to stop questioning/exploring/discussing/thinking/caring almost all of the unfiltered information. There is little room to be picky about the food tailor-made and there are even a lot of candies in the past few years. Why bother caring something you can not change/do/affect and sometimes may hurt yourself? More candies brings stronger heart beats and bigger bodies, too.
- meri_dian 9y agoHow is China learning this from the US? Chinese manipulation of social media is well known to be vast and incredibly coordinated. There just isn't evidence that the US government is engaged in anything approaching the Chinese scale. Sure we have tremendous surveillance capabilities, but we use them to detect criminal and terroristic behavior, not to police thought crime in the same way that China does. Don't be silly. It's so fashionable for pseudo-intellectuals to adopt a cynicism-all-the-time mentality, especially about America, but it's really just lazy thinking.
- colordrops 9y agoAs long as we are throwing out veiled insults, it's clear you exhibit a child-like ignorance and naivety. There's a news story a week some media collusion or propaganda apparatus being brought to light and people like you continue to remain in denial about the truth.
- wybiral 9y agoIt makes me wonder how the conspiracy people think this stuff is orchestrated. Does it all get planned out by one council of secret overlords masterminding the flow of public information? How many people are in on the secret? What is their end goal? ...Or maybe social dynamics and global relationships are more complex than that and patterns emerge even without the need for a conspiracy behind them...
- colordrops 9y agoIt doesn't take but a modicum of research to know these answers. I'd expect HN commenters to be better than speaking out of ignorance. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda_in_the_United_State... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Committee_on_Public_Information https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Committee_on_Public_Informatio... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Information_Agency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Information_Agen... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Under_Secretary_of_State_for_Public_Diplomacy_and_Public_Affairs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Under_Secretary_of_State_for_P... https://www.huffingtonpost.com/john-brown/propaganda-public-diplomacy_b_1547214.html https://www.huffingtonpost.com/john-brown/propaganda-public-... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Mockingbird https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Mockingbird https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manufacturing_Consent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manufacturing_Consent And this doesn't even begin to get into the deep collusion between the government and the media with lobbying, regulatory capture, government appointments, politicians on corporate board seats.
- zghst 9y agoChina is a historic nation reaching back thousands of years, inventor of mass foreign policy, bureaucracy, and more. She has no need to learn governance, nor the art of influence from the United States
- colordrops 9y agoYou say that as if there isn't a massive amount of innovation transfer in all fields, going both ways, with the China and the US, let alone most other countries. National pride is disgusting.
- zghst 9y agoI am not Chinese, however I can recognize it’s great contributions to humanity. I hold this nation in upmost respect, though I disagree strongly with its domestic policies. This has nothing to do with national pride and everything to do with the highest respect toward something that is greater, older and much wiser than myself.
- opportune 9y agoThis is just stupid. Does Ethiopia have nothing to learn from the rest of the world because that's where humanity (probably) invented fire? Good, useful information spreads regardless of whether a country invented any arbitrary institution in the past
- zghst 9y agoChina has institutional knowledge reaching back thousands of years. It does not need US expertise on how to handle foreign policy nor governance. It is arguable that the top layers of society such as technological progress, social hygiene, consumer culture, etc., hold value and are worthy of integration, however, the critical mass of civilization and intelligence within greater Chinese history serves as the best guide for their national affairs.
- simonh 9y agoChina has a long history of central control of the media, censorship, state propaganda and bureaucratic control all of which are directly relevant to this particular topic. All the poster is doing is pointing that out. It isn’t Ethiopia.
- zghst 9y agoWe don’t really have to bring the US into this, do we?
- meri_dian 9y agoThey try so hard to make everything about America... I've noticed that so many people on this site are incredibly cynical, it's sad. They're so wedded to conspiratorial thinking they lose sight of reality.
- zghst 9y agoWith my statement I make no assumptions on the intentions or advocacy that they reader may want to relay. I want to keep the conversation focused on the topic at hand, with relevant discussion.
- wybiral 9y agoPeople love having something to hate and someone to blame for things not being ideal. It sure is a lot easier than acknowledging that the world is incredibly complex and nuanced.
- opportune 9y agoThis is not conspiratorial thinking, it's verified fact. The world is not run by completely well-intentioned people, just as it's not run by completely evil-intentioned people. Just people, which can be capable of both
- jlarocco 9y agoSpeaking of being cynical and conspiratorial, I think you're making more out of this than there really is. HN is hosted in the United States and that's where most of the readers are. It's natural for a person to use their own country as a comparison in discussions about governments and countries that are foreign to them. There's no conspiracy, and the same thing happens on any discussion site where a majority of users are from a specific country.
- volgo 9y agoThe reason to bring US into discussions like this is more because it's a familiar comparison, and less of whataboutism. When you look at something objectively, it's hard to know how sinister (or lack thereof) it is. Because most folks here live in the U.S., it makes the comparison easier.
- taneq 9y agoThe same thing happens in Australia too. We have some scandal in a state government and then some poor sod conveniently gets eaten by a shark and we're in for three months of nothing but "Shark cull: Yes or No?", "How you can avoid being eaten by a shark", "Huge Protests Against Proposed Shark Cull", "Building a Net To Keep Sharks Out", "Sharks are a Vital Part of Our Aquatic Ecosystem", blah blah blah. It's pretty blatant. What happened with the Mayor's kid and the drug lab? Who cares?! SHARKS!
- jabretti 9y agoAre you suggesting that the government causes shark attacks? Do they control the sharks, or just have agents to push the swimmers into their jaws? Seriously though, democratic governments are much less good at propaganda operations than despotic ones, not necessarily because the people involved are much more honest on an individual level, but just because democratically elected governments are never really in all that much agreement about what sort of propaganda ought to be spread. The genius of democracy is that if you keep the people in power constantly fighting with each other they don't have as much time left over to screw the rest of us. So although "whatabout the US?" is inevitably the top comment on every thread about the evils of China, I think that just sometimes we ought to actually pay attention to China qua China.
- Cpoll 9y agoI think the point is that shark attacks are non-news, and the surge in interest is suspicious. You can probably replace 'shark attack' with any other 1-in-10-million occurrence/human interest story. Of course, the cynical interpretation is that there's nothing weird going on, and people just have a larger attention span for gruesome fluke accidents than for corruption.
- jabretti 9y agoShark attacks are no more non-news than at least 80% of the crap that fills media outlets, and it's not the least bit suspicious. Shark attacks are lurid and scary and human attention is notoriously poorly distributed. Yesterday, President Trump gave a speech about his trip to Asia, and 90% of the headlines were about the fact that he drank water during it.
- forapurpose 9y agoIt's not comparable at all. Leaking stories to media organizations independent of the government, who may or may not report it, and who may or may not report it in the manner that the government wishes, is not the same thing as wholesale propaganda on a massive scale. As the U.S. president regularly demonstrates in his complaints (and as all his predecessors did, to a lesser degree) the U.S. government has little power over the news media and is very unhappy with what they do. I do think the government's ability to place favorable stories and narratives in News Corp. publications (Fox, Wall St Journal) might be comparable as a propaganda operation. My sense is that that's their primary purpose. But it's still different; News Corp has the choice of whether to comply.
- existencebox 9y agoI find this comment upsetting for a few reasons. 1. It's a blatant example of whataboutism[0], and a discussion of the reprecussions/implications of Chinese social manipulation can be had entirely without bringing America into the picture. 2. Even if we accept that we do the same thing, that in no way justifies it in either place, as you seem to suggest in a comment below 3. If you've read the article you'll see that distracting from the topic is a key tactic the propagandists use to derail discussion. I'm going to be generous and not assume you're in that basket, but can you see why your response might seem tone-deaf in that context? 4. The extent to which China has been experimenting with social manipulation is so beyond the pale of anything that happens in the US. [1][2][3] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Credit_System https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Credit_System [2] http://www.independent.co.uk/news/muslims-china-police-state-state-surveillance-freedom-human-rights-religious-freedom-a7841401.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/muslims-china-police-state... [3] https://www.theregister.co.uk/2017/07/24/china_installing_mobile_spyware/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2017/07/24/china_installing_mo...