4 ms·
Investor accreditation makes sense (for now.) Giving poor people free access to untested-investment-vehicle-X is basically the same as giving them over-the-coun
by derefr 9y ago
Investor accreditation makes sense (for now.) Giving poor people free access to untested-investment-vehicle-X is basically the same as giving them over-the-counter access to scheduled drugs. Mistakes will be made, and the people making them—lacking resources as they do—won't be able to recover from them.
Right now, we're spending a lot of money trying to figure out how to get people out of these ruts. (Free housing seems to be helpful.) Creating more ways for people to get themselves into them seems ill-thought-out.
On the other hand (to pile tangent upon tangent), something like UBI would neatly fix the "problem" that investor accreditation addresses, because it would mean that even the poorest people would have a cushion in case their investments don't work out.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jrs95 9y agoIt's not about poor people. A huge number of middle class people aren't accredited investors. But they could easily put a small sum into a high risk investment and potentially benefit greatly from it. Bitcoin is a decent example of this. There aren't any accredited investors regulations, and I highly doubt there's hardly anyone who bought so much of it that they'd go bankrupt if it became worth $0
- dmoy 9y agoI would be absolutely shocked if Bitcoin hit $0 and nobody came out of the woodwork sheepishly admitting that their investment strategy was "put 110% in Bitcoin". People go bankrupt on much sillier schemes than Bitcoin on a routine basis...
- skyfold 9y agoI already cashed out enough to pay for school, a new house, and a new car. My parents are farmers. Even if Bitcoin went to $0, the number of people who became wealthy vs broke would be skewed towards individuals becoming wealthy because the late money is primarily institutional.
- dnautics 9y agoThey won't go bankrupt because they aren't purchasing it using leverage.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- walshemj 9y agoWhy I don't see many people in the UK going bankrupt of stockmarket investments opposed to say video poker in the Bookies Its just the Maggie meant what she said about a shareholding democracy And even Sweden has a strong retail shareholdings they even have national organisation that looks out for their interests
- derefr 9y agoI don’t think you have the correct picture of what the US “accreditied investor” laws are about. Anyone can invest in publicly-traded companies. The law prevents unaccredited (i.e. not rich) investors from investing in private companies. A company has to go through a number of processes, such as disclosure and underwriting, when it goes public. These processes effectively make it a much safer investment vehicle, amenable to purchase by pretty much anyone. A company that hasn’t gone public hasn’t gone through these processes, and therefore might just be a huckster’s sham. For a look at what it looks like when private companies are allowed to raise money from the public, don’t look at other countries (which have similar laws) or at Bitcoin (which nobody but rich people even understands.) Look at early Kickstarter, before they put in more stringent disclosure requirements; and look at Indiegogo, which still doesn’t have such requirements. Especially look at projects that started on Kickstarter, were kicked off for not meeting the disclosure requirements, and then went on to raise money on Indiegogo. You know what percentage of those are scams? It’s not small. Early US stock market investment, before the requirements to IPO were made stringent, look a lot like Indiegogo. Anything and everything was up for investment, without examination. Many people did lose their livelihoods.
- andr3w321 9y ago"Investor accreditation makes sense (for now.)" No it doesn't. It's pure nanny statism. The government has no business telling people what they can and can't invest in or spend their money on. Yes startups are risky. So are lots of things. Why should the wealthy have no restrictions on them, but the poor do? This is literally "class warfare".
- derefr 9y agoThe government isn't telling people what they can invest in; it's telling companies whether they can take people's money. It's not illegal to hand money to a private company (you will not be charged with a crime); it's illegal to, as the company, accept that money. Private companies are a very specific kind of company—they're supposed to be a temporary condition, a way for companies to not have to go through the effort of going through disclosure, underwriting, etc. right away, because they're still just two guys in a garage and don't have the resources to do so. Private companies, as a special case, don't get to participate in all the things public (i.e. "normal") companies do. Private companies are to public companies as minors are to adults. In your phrasing, you could say that government also "tells people what they can and can't" eat, in the form of the FDA. But, just like this case, it should be clear that the FDA never goes after someone for eating a poisoned cucumber; it just goes after the company for selling poisoned cucumbers. (The DEA, on the other hand, is pure nanny-state-ism.)
- andr3w321 9y agoRegarding the FDA I don't think the government should be telling me what drugs I can and can't take. Plenty of people are denied from taking early stage drugs because they are not FDA approved and dangerous, but if people are aware of the risks I think they should have every right to take them. In your poison cucumber example I think this would qualify as knowingly poisoning someone else which is clearly illegal and we do not need the FDA for that. As long as the cucumber is labeled as "poison" I have no problem with people selling them.
- dragonwriter 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- kakarot 9y ago> basically the same as giving them over-the-counter access to scheduled drugs. Something that also should be legal (with reasonable discrimination). I would choose a different metaphor because this one doesn't work in your favor.
- derefr 9y agoI believe in safe injection sites; in having way more doctors; in having more state-sponsored free clinics; in encouraging said free clinics to be willing to prescribe narcotics in cases where the patient is unable to function without them; in support programs for getting over addiction using drugs like naltrexone; etc. I also, I should especially highlight, don't believe in prosecuting people for drug possession, of any kind or amount. But I don't believe that we would benefit, on net, if you could buy heroin in the corner convenience store without a doctor's encouragement to do so. The number of people who would be able to safely manage their own treatment, would be outweighed by the number of people who would become newly addicted due to increased access and the aura of illegitimacy being removed.
- Sevii 9y agoPoor people are allowed to legally gamble away their money in situations where its 100% known that they will lose it all.
- derefr 9y agoThis is kind of why commercial casinos are illegal in 30 states, why racetrack betting is illegal in 29 states, why online gambling is illegal in 46(!) states, and why the only legal (non-charitable) lotteries are state-run. It's not leftover morality laws; it's that monitoring commercial gambling to protect against exploitation of the poor is a really hard problem, one we haven't really solved. Some states choose to allow it despite this, and then deal with the consequences of increased poverty. Most don't. (And then they're forced to allow it in anyway by native on-res exceptions.) This is also why such commercial gambling establishments as are legalized, are heavily regulated. For example, see the Nevada state laws on gaming fraud: https://www.leg.state.nv.us/NRS/NRS-465.html#NRS465Sec070 https://www.leg.state.nv.us/NRS/NRS-465.html#NRS465Sec070 Those laws aren't there to stop people trying to cheat the house. They're there to stop the house from exploiting people by rigging the game.
- smsm42 9y ago> This is kind of why commercial casinos are illegal in 30 states, why racetrack betting is illegal in 29 states, why online gambling is illegal in 46(!) states, and why the only legal (non-charitable) lotteries are state-run. And we all know no poor person in these states ever gambled their money away! Or, alternatively, they did gamble it away, but since gambling is illegal, they were also cheated mercilessly and have no recourse and no place to complain, since being poor and telling police you participated in illegal activity gets you an express ticket to jail.
- zanny 9y agoMeanwhile, buying loot chests in Android games is perfectly legal and lets people spend thousands of dollars in a gambling stupor and get nothing for it.
- chimeracoder 9y ago
- abecedarius 9y agoI can see that being a millionaire already is (somewhat) correlated with being less vulnerable to scams, but if you were designing a rule to protect the vulnerable, is that really what you'd come up with? The first thing to come to mind for me, besides taking a test, is for people to show they can make it as a blackjack card-counter -- seriously, wouldn't an official investor-accrediting poker league, even, do a better job of sorting out or educating the marks and freeing up much more of the population to invest? If we have to deal with this problem by prior restraint at all.
- bfuller 9y agoNot everyone is against drug legalization
- njarboe 9y agoIn the US we let people gamble; the government even runs and promotes it in many states. We let people get credit cards to buy consumable products and then pay 20%-30% interest. We let them take out loans to buy real estate worth multiples of their annual salary and have a debt overhang greater than they could ever save in a lifetime. We let teen-agers take out $100k of student loans that can't even be dismissed by bankruptcy. We are not "protecting" people in all these other problematic financial situations. I might advocate for shutting down gambling, credit cards and getting the government out of student and home loans, but if we think those actions should be are allowed, investing in small companies should be also.
- tinus_hn 9y ago> I might advocate for shutting down gambling, [...] Why not reintroduce prohibition while you’re at it? It is not possible to force your opinion on other people like that, it only drives the behavior underground, which is a breeding ground for crime.