4 ms·
What part is actually hosted here? Do they store opaque encrypted blobs and pass those around, or can they see the actual secrets too?
by epistasis 9y ago
What part is actually hosted here? Do they store opaque encrypted blobs and pass those around, or can they see the actual secrets too?
- masukomi 9y agoI'm pretty confident that AgileBits only has access to the encrypted versions of stuff. They've thought about this long and hard and it would decimate their business if they did anything as stupid as storing things in plaintext. That's why you have to enter your master password... to decrypt the file.
- AGKyle 9y agoDisclosure: I work for AgileBits, makers of 1Password We outline the entirety of how this works in our white paper: https://1pw.ca/whitepaper https://1pw.ca/whitepaper We cannot tell what your data is. It's encrypted on your device using keys that only you know. Then we store it on our side on the server. The unique solution of using your Master Password and your Secret Key, makes brute forcing the data on our server an incredibly expensive job for anyone attempting to do so. It makes our servers an absolutely terrible target. I definitely recommend reading the white paper, it's quite easy to read, even if you aren't super interested in cryptography. If you have questions though just let me know. I'll make sure you get answers. Kyle AgileBits
- t0mbstone 9y agoAll it would take for 1Password to decrypt our entire vault is for 1Password to push out a software update that simply made it so that the client app uploaded the keys to 1Password's servers after the user typed it in. Without 1Password releasing their source code, end users would have no idea if such an update ever took place. We just have to trust 1Password as a company. Well, if we already trust 1Password as a company, what's the point of even using encryption? Might as well just store it in plain text in a database on your servers and trust that your employees won't look at them! Without open source auditing of all clients and md5 checksums of compiled binaries, security is nothing more than an illusion.
- AGKyle 9y agoIf that's your concern then I'm afraid there's little we can do to change your opinion and perhaps 1Password isn't the solution for you. I don't mean to sound rude or anything like that. Just being honest. We have had grand visions of offering portions of our source (notably the cryptographic portions) available for review, note, not open source in the sense you can use it but in a license that makes it available for review purposes. If 1Password.com was the sole solution we offered then open sourcing the entire app would be potentially feasible because our income wouldn't rely on people compiling their own version and editing out the license code. But it makes little sense for us to make that available if modified copies can be made available removing a chunk of our income. For what it's worth, we have over 90 people who depend on AgileBits to provide paychecks so people can support their families. That's a heavy burden when your decisions can impact that many lives. I'm just a member of our team, not a founder or owner or anything but hopefully you can recognize this side of things. We'd like nothing more than to do whatever we can to get users to trust us but there are limits to what we can do and still keep 1Password alive. If you absolutely have to see the code in order to trust an application then there are other options out there, but they won't provide the same level of support, features, or hands off management. These are trade offs you have to make as an individual. Only you can make those decisions for you. Every person at AgileBits uses 1Password, and we design it knowing we will be using it and we are all passionate about wanting our data secure. If we did something to put your data at risk, we did the same thing to ourselves. Just another view of that I suppose. Kyle AgileBits
- t0mbstone 9y agoI'm simply pointing out the elephant in the room. If there is no ability to audit the source code of the password manager, and the source code is managed by a third party company, then for all intents and purposes, the third party company has theoretical access to everything (regardless of what encryption is used). It boils down to trust, and that trust can be violated by a single rogue employee at AgileBits. It could also be potentially violated by a government agency gaining control of AgileBits.
- 9y ago