4 ms·
> Disagree. Insults are a problem if and only if they cause third parties to have unfairly* diminished regard for you. To give a topical example, there does not
by vkou 9y ago
> Disagree. Insults are a problem if and only if they cause third parties to have unfairly* diminished regard for you.
To give a topical example, there does not appear to be any insult which affects Trump: if you hate him then the insults prove you right, but if you love him then the insults are just fake news.
In societies where 'honor' killings take place, insults do cause third parties to have an unfairly diminished regard for you.
Here's an example closer to home - when a drug dealer gets ripped off for $500, he doesn't care about the money. $500 is nothing to him. What he cares about is appearing like an easy mark, which opens the door to everyone and their brother stealing from him. It's why the correct response to that kind of insult, in that kind of industry, is to go to the offender's house, and break their skull open by dropping an ATM machine on it.
He isn't killing someone for $500. He's killing someone to make it clear that he will not be taken advantage of.
Trump doesn't need to do that, because me insulting him on Twitter will not result in other people ripping him off. He is protected from that by a working legal system. My insults are not damaging, and even if it were, he would be able to sue me. Drug dealers, and people living in the mountains of Albania have no such recourse (Or do not trust it.)
- sillysaurus3 9y agoI think people in this thread are talking past each other. I wanted to clarify the other side of the debate: Nothing better illustrates the thar mentality better than the fury directed by Islamic militants against Danish and Norwegian cartoons of Mohammed. Sacrilegious art in other cultures can offend and get people angry but the lunatic response of radical Islamists is in a class by itself. It's the shrieking, out of control petulance of a three-year old throwing a tantrum. People infected with this attitude will be utterly incapable of recognizing wrongdoing by their own society, utterly incapable of taking criticism or recognizing the need for correction. This is remarkably close to the image of Hell painted by C. S. Lewis in his books Perelandra and The Screwtape Letters: a paralyzing self-absorption that imprisons the individual in hate and impotent rage while simultaneously blinding him to any possibility of escape. This doesn't seem like a question of legal systems.
- blackbagboys 9y agoThis seems like an utterly dissimilar phenomenon from the personal, tit for tat honor disputes between people who know each on an individual basis and are enmeshed in the same social network or framework
- ben_w 9y ago> I think people in this thread are talking past each other. I am also getting this impression. I think that while I am talking about libel and slander, vkou is talking about the need to be taken seriously?
- rhizome 9y agoYou're equating both societies' sense of what an insult is. Sometimes it's just a daughter's choice of boyfriend.
- vkou 9y agoAnd if we're talking about lunatic radicalism and out-of-control petulance, sometimes it's just a flag being burned, kneeling at a football game, a black man living in a white house, or whatever nonesense about impure blood and 'White Europe' gets fascists marching in the streets these days. All of these things have elicited death threats. Again, the difference is that in our society, the threat of law keeps those people from carrying them out. A few decades ago, the threat of law did not, and lynch mobs were common.
- rhizome 9y agowell, 'honor' is socially defined, so the animating context for a killing, so to speak, matters. Some are actual confrontations, but more often an attack will be based on imaginary consequences or implications of someone else's behavior or existence.[1] Long story short: you're making category errors left and right. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Balbir_Singh_Sodhi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Balbir_Singh_Sodhi